CARRIE CLARK: Duke Energy's failure sheds light on a way forward
Thursday Jan. 5, 2023 -- The lessons from the Christmas storm and big chill are clear: Climate change is causing more extreme and unpredictable weather; Gas and coal aren't always dependable in extreme weather, while renewable energy with battery storage is more reliable.
Posted — UpdatedDuke Energy’s rolling blackouts across North Carolina on December 24 and 25 were the Christmas present nobody wanted. The blackouts were Duke’s response to high demand and frigid temperatures, which were not anticipated by Duke and their equipment and backup plans were unable to handle.
This is what we learned from a meeting Gov. Roy Cooper called with Duke executives on Tuesday, followed by a hearing before the North Carolina Utilities Commission on the same issue. Gov. Cooper demanded answers from Duke, as did the Utilities Commission.
Duke accepted responsibility for the outages and helped us better understand the failure. Four key takeaways emerged:
- Duke didn’t anticipate a storm of this magnitude because we haven’t experienced one before, so their forecasts were wrong;
- Duke’s gas and coal-fired power plants were less effective in extreme cold;
- Additional backup power wasn’t available from neighboring states because they were facing similar conditions from the storm;
- Duke said renewable energy resources performed as expected, and that the outages did not occur because of renewable energy generation.
This event is similar to the one that happened in my native Texas in 2021, which cost the lives of 246. We are incredibly fortunate that North Carolina didn’t suffer a similar loss of life. However, unfortunately, the same mindset prevails in power generation. North Carolina and Texas overwhelmingly rely on coal and natural gas as the primary resources to produce electricity.
One of the mandates of the law is to continue to provide the lowest cost and most dependable energy possible. Opponents of a shift to clean energy have called for more natural gas power plant construction. They say this is the lowest cost and most dependable solution.
The lessons we should learn from the storm are clear in Duke’s responses to Gov. Cooper and the Utilities Commission:
- Climate change is causing more extreme weather, which is unpredictable. We are facing more historic storms, not fewer;
- Gas and coal aren’t always dependable in extreme weather, while renewable energy with battery storage is more reliable.
Under Gov. Cooper’s leadership, North Carolina is quickly becoming a clean energy powerhouse, with high-paying jobs and associated economic development, along with the obvious climate benefits. The costs of solar and wind generation and battery storage are going down.
Fortunately, the Utilities Commission highlighted both the Duke outages and the Inflation Reduction Act in its order to Duke. When Duke presents its revised plan to the Utilities Commission in September, they will no longer be able to credibly say natural gas is the cheapest and most reliable path.
Fortunately, their Christmas failure shed light on the best way forward for our state. This storm could ultimately lead to a real gift for the people of North Carolina, not just a lump of coal.
Copyright 2024 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.