Local News

Friend of Lovette could face charges in Duke student's murder

Posted July 25, 2014

— Durham Chief Assistant District Attorney Roger Echols said Friday that his office is considering possible charges against the friend of a man accused of murdering Duke University graduate student Abhijit Mahato six years ago.

Meanwhile Friday, closing arguments in Laurence Lovette's first-degree murder trial were scheduled for Monday morning after prosecutors rested their case and defense attorneys chose not to call any witnesses.

More than two dozen people testified over six days of testimony, including Phillip Maybrey, who took the witness stand saying he initially told police he was with Lovette and that he heard him shoot the 29-year-old Mahato early on the morning of Jan. 18, 2008.

But Maybrey, 22, also said he lied because investigators "deceived him" when they showed up at his job telling him they wanted to talk to him about another case.

"I felt very offended and disrespected, because I'd been lied to," Maybrey said. "They could have come to me like a man and said 'We want to talk to you about this murder.'"

Maybrey testified under a subpoena on Monday and acknowledged that his testimony could expose him to criminal liability.

"I just told them what they wanted to hear," he said.

Echols wouldn't say Friday if prosecutors have previously pursued charges against Maybrey, and he did not say what charges might be possible or offer a timetable on a decision.

Maybrey is the half-brother of Demario Atwater, who, along with Lovette, is serving life in prison for the death of 22-year-old Eve Carson, a University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill student killed nearly two months after Mahato.

Shanita Love – the state's key witness and Atwater's ex-girlfriend – testified Wednesday that Lovette, 23, admitted to the Duke slaying and said that Carson's death was a copycat murder.

Love's testimony was also key in Lovette's 2011 conviction for Carson's slaying.

Both Carson and Mahato were college students who were ambushed at their homes and taken to ATMs to withdraw hundreds of dollars. Carson was shot five times in a neighborhood near UNC. Mahato was taken back to his apartment near Duke and shot once in the head.

The only difference in the cases, Love testified, is that Maybrey was with Lovette in the January crime and Atwater was with him in March.

In addition to Lovette, police initially charged Stephen Lavance Oates in Mahato's death. Prosecutors, however, dismissed the charges last year, citing insufficient evidence tying him to the crime.

Defense attorneys – who contend Love is not credible – told Superior Court Judge Jim Hardin that they were considering calling Oates to testify next week, prompting Hardin to issue an order to have him appear in court.

Although he was no longer implicated in Mahato's death, Oates is serving a prison sentence for convictions in a series of other robberies and shootings in January 2008.

On Thursday and Friday, forensic firearms investigator Stephanie Walcott testified for the state that a shell casing from Mahato's Anderson Street apartment was fired from the same 9 mm Luger as a shell casing found at the scene of a second shooting – a crime prosecutors have also linked to Lovette through Love.

That second shooting, in which a man was shot in the leg, happened March 19, 2008, at an apartment on Chapel Hill Boulevard in Durham – a mile from Mahato's home.

What jurors didn't hear from Walcott, however, is that the shell casing from another shooting on Duke University Road – also on March 19, 2008 – was also fired from the same 9 mm weapon.

Oates, according to Lovette's defense, was arrested in that case.

"If they want to bring that up about this other shooting, there's a mechanism for them to do that, and that's a presentation of their case," prosecutor Jim Dornfried said Thursday.

He objected to jurors hearing about Oates in cross-examination.

"I'm not really understanding why the state is objecting, and I really now know it wasn't a mistake that you did not put it into evidence," defense attorney Karen Bethea-Shields said. "I'm not really understanding why we're having a problem making sure the jury understands all (Walcott) found out."


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Lorna Schuler Jul 25, 2014
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Well said!

  • HANS FOR PRESIDENT!!!!! JK Jul 25, 2014

    PDMARTINJul 25, 3:05 p.m.

    He felt "disrespected". The way people use that word at ever turn it now means nothing. If it was used in the proper context it means alot. But not in today's society.


    Very true. In days of old, earning respect meant being a stand up man/woman in your community, working for what you have, and being someone others looked up to. Now punks think you have to cower to them in fear in order to "respect" them. Biggest crock I've ever heard. A cold blooded killer or aomeone that would lie to protect one deserves the farthest thing from respect. Period!

  • LetsBeFair Jul 25, 2014

    so, which lies are true?

  • itsnotatumah Jul 25, 2014

    View quoted thread

    The first step would not be using the racist or slavery bs. No one living is responsible for that so time to grow up and move on. I take ownership of my actions and consequences.

  • LetsBeFair Jul 25, 2014

    He sure told them didn't he! ... disrespect him and you won't hear the truth until he say so.

  • Denise Martin Jul 25, 2014
    user avatar

    He felt "disrespected". The way people use that word at ever turn it now means nothing. If it was used in the proper context it means alot. But not in today's society.

  • 678devilish Jul 25, 2014

    We should all learn to RESPECT each other. If we did, what a wonderful world it would be. But the parents need to teach their children how to respect, so as they grow up it will be instilled in them.

  • Trixie Jul 25, 2014

    Where does a 15 year old get off expecting respect and to be treated like a man? He needed a good kick in the pants, and a reality check. That's where good parenting comes in to play. I can't even imagine what my parents would have said if I told them a deserved respect at 15! LOL!!!

  • David McIntee Jul 25, 2014
    user avatar

    We need to rid the streets of the murderers. Take him into custody now. Sort it out later, at a minimum, he lied to investigators and that in and of itself is a crime.

  • Mee Jul 25, 2014

    View quoted thread

    Question: "Where are they learning that?"

    Answer: From parents--NOT being a parent (try telling your child NO once in a while). From the schools--too afraid to be slapped with a lawsuit from parents who think their little baby does no wrong that they just move these troubled kids as fast as they can through the system. From Hollywood--who claims "art" imitates life. From Music & TV--glamorizing violence and criminal behavior. From the Government--who repeatedly tells us "it's not your fault you're poor, or uneducated, (thief, drug dealer, gang banger, etc) or just plain EVIL---it's someone elses fault--you're the victim".

    We've become a nation of where victims are blamed and the criminals are given a pass (it's not their fault they're committing crimes--it's society's).

    Go us.