Local News

Judge denies lower bond in backpack bones case

Posted March 8, 2013

— A Superior Court judge on Friday denied a request for a lower bond for a Mebane man charged with killing a woman and toting her remains around in a backpack.

Michael Dorman has been in jail since his July 2010 arrest, even though the murder charge was dropped for 18 months before the state Court of Appeals ruled in February that a judge incorrectly dismissed it.

Defense attorney Lawrence Campbell sought a $50,000 bond for Dorman, but Assistant Durham County District Attorney Roger Echols argued that the bond should be increased, not lowered, because of Dorman's previous criminal record and the severity of the charge.

Judge Orlando Hudson ruled that Dorman's bond would remain at $150,000.

It was Hudson who dismissed the murder charge in August 2011, saying that former District Attorney Tracey Cline had conspired with police and state agents to deny Dorman's right to a fair trial by destroying key evidence.

Local authorities released the remains of 31-year-old Lakiea Lacole Boxley to her relatives shortly after Dorman was indicted. When her family cremated the remains, Hudson said, it deprived the defense from conducting forensic tests on them.

An autopsy determined that Boxley, who had been missing since March 2008, might have been shot in the head. Dorman told investigators that he only found the remains and planned to use them for his sexual gratification.

He was arrested after one of his friends told authorities that Dorman admitted to killing a prostitute and had asked him to help dispose of her remains, which he had in a backpack.

Michael Dorman in court Backpack bones suspect to remain in Durham jail

On Friday, Campbell argued that Dorman is mentally ill and that investigators have no evidence that he killed Boxley, other than his confession.

"They don't know where it happened. They don't know when it happened. They don't know how it happened," he said.

Campbell also challenged the authenticity of a DVD of Dorman's interview with police, noting that prosecutors were never able to provide him with a working version of the DVD until recently. He even went so far as to call Echols to the witness stand to testify about it.

Echols said he has evidence beyond Dorman's confession.

The case helped escalate a feud between Hudson and Cline, who shortly thereafter began publicly accusing the judge of corruption and attempts to undermine criminal prosecutions.

Cline asked that Hudson not hear any criminal cases in Durham County, but other Superior Court judges found her claims to be groundless. In March 2012, she was removed from office after a judge determined that her repeated attacks on Hudson brought her office into disrepute.

Hudson said he would allow other Superior Court judges to take over the Dorman case, although he still might remain involved in some segments.

Dorman's appellate attorneys have appealed the Court of Appeals ruling to the state Supreme Court, Campbell said.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Sweet summertime Mar 11, 2013

    Are you kidding me? Lower your bond? REALLY? smh

  • Mrs.DarylDixon Mar 8, 2013

    "Come on judge, throw the man a bone." - Obamacare rises

    HEY OH!!! lol

  • Vstrom Mar 8, 2013

    What Clien did by allowing one of the major if not the most important pieces of evidence to be destroyed was the inept action. YOU CANT DO THAT!!! jhk0704

    So you are saying that every murder victim should be kept in cold storage until trial? What about Faith Hedgepeth? Is her case over because the body was released? Think people!

  • jenjengirl89 Mar 8, 2013

    "WRAL, Please do not let this story reach the National News Media, this will reflect badly on us of NC,"

    ROTFL, you know this is the internet, right?

  • jhk0704 Mar 8, 2013

    Why is Judge Hudson still allowed to be involved in this case? He's already screwed up on it previously. He is totally inept

    Hopw exactly did he screww up? What Clien did by allowing one of the major if not the most important pieces of evidence to be destroyed was the inept action. YOU CANT DO THAT!!! Its law 101 that the defense has the right to examine all pieces of evidence and have tests conducted by their own specialists. What Cline di was wrong.

  • Obamacare rises Mar 8, 2013

    Come on judge, throw the man a bone.

  • pappybigtuna1 Mar 8, 2013

    WRAL, Please do not let this story reach the National News Media, this will reflect badly on us of NC, that so few have some common sense on what to do with this guy.

    For those of you feel he has been mishandled, lets buy him a bus ticket to Washington, DC and allow him to live there, maybe Judge Hudson can accompany him, they could get a place together

  • Obamacare rises Mar 8, 2013

    Seriously......this guy again?

  • 321oohaw Mar 8, 2013

    kornfan2448...He had less bones in his back pack then originally thought so they lowered the bond accordingly.

  • kornfan2448 Mar 8, 2013

    I thought when he was originally arrested, his bond was $1,000,000. Why is it now at only $150,000?