Local News

Hayes convicted of second-degree murder in Laura Ackerson's slaying

Posted February 19

— A Wake County jury found Amanda Hayes guilty of second-degree murder Wednesday in the death of her husband's ex-girlfriend, Laura Ackerson, whose dismembered remains were found in a Texas creek nearly three years ago.

Wake County Assistant District Attorney Boz Zellinger Amanda Hayes trial closing arguments

Hayes, five weeks from giving birth to a girl, along with her husband, Grant Hayes, was arrested on a charge of first-degree murder 12 days after Ackerson's July 13, 2011, death.

She was later indicted on a charge of accessory after the fact to murder, and she went to trial Jan. 21.

Forty-nine witnesses, including the defendant, took the stand over 13 days of testimony in the month-long trial, and the jury of three men and nine women returned its verdict Wednesday after more than 11 hours of deliberations in the case.

"I would just like to apologize with my whole heart, being and soul, personally to Laura. I apologize to her, to her family, to her children, to my family, to Grant's family, to everyone who had to work this case, to everyone who had to sit through this trial," the 41-year-old Hayes told Superior Court Judge Donald Stephens. "I am truly, truly sorry with every ounce of my soul."

Amanda Hayes Amanda Hayes testimony
"She's a manipulator. She's a liar," said Ackerson's father, who added that he did not believe her apology was sincere.

Stephens sentenced Hayes to 13 to 16.5 years – 157 to 198 months – in prison.

"Based upon my view of the evidence, it is quite possible and likely that Amanda Hayes could have saved the life of Laura Ackerson, and she chose not to," Stephens said. "She chose, instead, to participate in her killing."

Wake County prosecutors, say Amanda Hayes hated Ackerson – the mother of Grant Hayes' two young sons – because of a bitter child custody dispute and that the couple wanted to "erase" her from their lives.

Defense attorneys argued that it was Grant Hayes who killed Ackerson, cut up her body, put it in coolers and carried it in a U-Haul trailer without his wife knowing.

Amanda Hayes testified that she found out Ackerson had died while at her sister's home in Richmond, Texas, where Grant Hayes coerced her into both admitting to the crime and helping him find a place to dump the remains.

She only helped, she said, out of fear of what he might do to her, his 2- and 3-year-old boys and her 1-month-old and 22-year-old daughters.

"We're disappointed Amanda wasn't acquitted. We believed in Amanda," defense attorney Johnny Gaskins said. "Amanda would never have been in this situation, had it not been for Grant Hayes."

Wake County prosecutors disagreed

"I think the jury rejected her words, and that was the clearest thing that came out today – that her act and her sentences from the witness stand were rejected by the jury," said Assistant District Attorney Boz Zellinger, who also prosecuted Grant Hayes in September.

A jury found him guilty of first-degree murder in less than two hours.

He has maintained that his wife accidentally killed Ackerson during an argument and that the only thing he did wrong was help with the cover-up because he loved her and wanted to protect her.

Gaskins, however, argued that she, like Ackerson, was a victim of Grant Hayes. He described him as a dangerous sociopath who used his wit and charisma to manipulate and control his wife and to take advantage of a large sum of money she received from an inheritance.

The couple was broke and about to be evicted from their Raleigh apartment at the time of the crime, and Grant Hayes not only spent Amanda Hayes' inheritance but also had pawned off several pieces of expensive jewelry she owned.

"There is no reason to believe that Mrs. Hayes suffered any less domination and abuse than Laura talked about and discussed in her (child custody) case, albeit it is our position that it was more mental and emotional, and her dynamic was different," defense attorney Rosemary Godwin told Stephens before the judge handed down Amanda Hayes' sentence.

Friends of the 27-year-old Ackerson testified that they believed Grant Hayes had physically abused her when the two were together and that she believed he was such a threat to her that she remarked to one friend that if anything ever happened to her – "Grant did it."

How she died is unclear.

North Carolina's chief medical examiner testified that Ackerson's remains were so badly decomposed that her death was ruled "undetermined homicidal violence."

There was, however, a sharp puncture wound to the fourth cervical vertebra as well as crushed thyroid cartilage consistent with some type of asphyxia or blunt force trauma to the neck.

83 Comments

This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • dollibug Feb 20, 7:31 p.m.

    May Laura Ackerson RIP* May her family have comfort and closure. May GOD watch over the children who no longer have their parents. Perhaps better choices in life could have prevented this.

  • 678devilish Feb 20, 3:38 p.m.

    That means they can retry.

    In the Dunn case I pray that the courts and jury will get it right this time...with life in prison and no parole.

  • smcallah Feb 20, 3:06 p.m.

    Lots of you appear not to be aware that sentences in NC are not arbitrarily up to the judge's... View More

    — Posted by jurydoc

    But carrying out those sentences is up to the Department of Corrections. If they want to give credit for good behavior, they can, and they do.

  • smcallah Feb 20, 3:04 p.m.

    Wow! So I can straight up commit 2nd degree murder nowadays and only have to spend around 15... View More

    — Posted by jabbat

    Yup, and you can shoot a car full of kids that are annoying you and get aquitted on murder... View More

    — Posted by Jimmytwotimes

    There was no acquittal in the Dunn case. The jury was deadlocked. That means they can retry.

  • smcallah Feb 20, 3:01 p.m.

    No verdict on the accessory charge? She should have been found guilty of that too. She was an... View More

    — Posted by mrschizzy

    If you're found guilty of actual murder in the 2nd degree, you're no longer an accessory to it. You did murder.

  • monami Feb 20, 2:19 p.m.

    "She was denied the mitigating range and the State was denied the aggravative range."

    The defense presented (insulting) mitigation arguments, which the judge denied. The State did not indict this defendant-now-convicted murderer with aggravating factors. Since that was omitted from the indictment, the judge could not apply the aggravated sentence. He said this in court. The aggravating factor brought forth by the prosecution (but too late) was committing murder in the presence of a child.

  • cuatthe1sttee Feb 20, 2:00 p.m.

    Lots of you appear not to be aware that sentences in NC are not arbitrarily up to the judge's... View More

    — Posted by jurydoc

    No, Judge Stephens sentenced Amanda to the high end of the presumptive range of a class B2 felony. He gave her EVERY single month he could have given her under the presumptive range. She was denied the mitigating range and the State was denied the aggravative range.

  • cuatthe1sttee Feb 20, 1:57 p.m.

    Why doesn't Laura's family have custody of her two kids? If this was my daughter/sisiter/niece,... View More

    — Posted by brandy213122

    -

    I agree, and I don't know. I've never understood why they have never gone for custody of the... View More

    — Posted by DontVote4LiarsCheatsOrThieves

    The tried but did not get custody for some reason

    — Posted by TheoryGirl

    Actually, Amanda Hayes has no family other than her sister in Texas and 21 year old daughter.

  • tiblet Feb 20, 1:50 p.m.

    I would have been shocked if any other verdict were handed down.

  • TheoryGirl Feb 20, 1:30 p.m.

    Why doesn't Laura's family have custody of her two kids? If this was my daughter/sisiter/niece,... View More

    — Posted by brandy213122

    -

    I agree, and I don't know. I've never understood why they have never gone for custody of the... View More

    — Posted by DontVote4LiarsCheatsOrThieves

    The tried but did not get custody for some reason

More...