Trump's go-it-alone immigration strategy ends in chaos, confusion
On Wednesday morning, White House cooks were flipping steaks and unboxing popcorn machines ahead of the yearly congressional picnic. Within the hour, the picnic was scrubbed, the steaks on ice, and the popcorn machines trucked away.Posted — Updated
A day earlier, President Donald Trump enthusiastically told House Republicans in the Capitol basement he was behind them "1,000%" in their attempts to pass an immigration bill. On Friday he dismissed the effort as a waste of time.
Speaking to reporters as the humanitarian crisis worsened, Trump brushed away a question about his options: "You can't do it through an executive order," he said on the North Lawn. Five days later, he sat at his desk in the Oval Office attempting to do just that.
"You're going to have a lot of happy people," he said optimistically as he applied his sawtooth signature.
Jumping from position to position as migrant parents remained separated from their children, the President this week put his go-it-alone strategy of governing to the test. Images and audio of despondent children led to outraged calls for action, which prompted outsized reaction from Trump. People close to him say the President has rebuffed advice anew from aides and lawmakers as he works on his own to solve a crisis of his own making.
His gut-driven response has led to confusion and confrontation within the federal government. Officials have convened ongoing meetings at the White House over how to interpret the executive order, including on Thursday night and Friday. Different agencies, including Customs and Border Protection and the Justice Department, haggled with the White House over how the order and Trump's "zero-tolerance" policy align in terms of which migrants are referred for prosecution.
Meanwhile, the majority of the 2,300 children who have been separated from their parents remain so, with little indication of how they might be reunited.
The continued fallout over family separations at the US border amounted to a high-stakes experiment for how Trump can operate outside the normal guardrails of the presidency. Wary of anyone else's counsel, he repeatedly discarded advice from his chief of staff on how to proceed. He ignored legal warnings from his top lawyer. And he acted as his own White House communications director, a position that's now been vacant for months.
The result was pandemonium.
In defense of his policy, Trump felt emboldened to repeat mistruths and outright lies, day after day, during extended and mostly improvised television appearances. For migrant parents still separated from their children, the President's actions were largely ineffective. Even Trump's political allies feel jolted and uncertain.
Inside the administration
Inside the West Wing, beleaguered staffers watched the events of the past week unfold with unenthusiastic anticipation of what's to come. Many are still eying the exits -- including chief of staff John Kelly and White House counsel Don McGahn -- but with few qualified staffers ready to replace them some feel obliged to remain on. Departures still come regularly, including this week the operations chief Joe Hagin.
The aide most identified with Trump's hardline stance, Stephen Miller, has drawn barbs from colleagues who accuse him of overseeing what amounted to a chaotic mess. Some have harkened back to his role in executing the travel ban on residents of certain Muslim majority countries, another bumpy rollout mired in legal complications. But there's little to indicate his standing with the President was diminished; as Trump was signing the executive order on Wednesday, staffers saw Miller laughing on a bench in the Rose Garden. He later accompanied Trump aboard Air Force One to Duluth.
The crisis did present an opening for Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen to improve her standing with the President, who had dressed her down during meetings for not being tough enough on border security. He watched with pleasure her contentious briefing with reporters on Monday, which was delayed for hours as she prepared in the West Wing. But her elevation has come with costs: she was loudly heckled at a Mexican restaurant on Wednesday and protesters assembled at her townhouse in Virginia on Friday.
Attorney General Jeff Sessions hasn't been granted a similar reprieve. Already detested by Trump for his recusal from the Russia investigation, Trump told people this week his attorney general had contributed to the political disaster that he was left to clean up. When Trump saw a clip of Sessions on cable news discussing the "zero-tolerance" policy that led to the separations, he sighed dramatically and cursed, a person who saw the episode said.
As midterm elections approach, Trump is seen by those inside the White House as more likely to act out in ways he believes can galvanize his conservative base. His upcoming schedule is stacked with campaign events, and he's expressed little enthusiasm for other types of travel, aides say. Even as he worked to explain his immigration decisions this week, Trump repeatedly returned to the November vote.
"The worse everything looks, they think the better they're going to do with respect to the blue wave, which is turning out, frankly, to be a red wave, if you look at the polls," Trump said during a Cabinet meeting Thursday. "I think we're going to have a red wave, not a blue wave."
In private meetings this week, Trump cast the immigration issue as a political one, according to people who heard his comments, likening it to a culture wars matter akin to kneeling NFL players or Confederate statues. He insisted he was doing right by his supporters and offered little indication he would cave to outside pressure.
Even in public, he offered few signs he would let up. He told a crowd of small business owners on Tuesday that his policy could act as a deterrent -- "they have to know they can't get in" -- a remark that reflected a determination he'd made in private with advisers.
Entreaties from his daughter and adviser Ivanka and first lady Melania Trump were initially met with resistance. Trump was unenthusiastic when presented with a proposal for his wife to travel to the border to visit a detention facility, according to a person familiar with the situation, but later endorsed the plan.
Through it all, the President told people he risked appearing weak if he or his administration reversed position. He verbalized the internal struggle on Wednesday morning.
"If you're weak, which some people would like you to be, if you're really, really, pathetically weak, the country's going to be overrun with millions of people," he said, gesticulating to illustrate the dueling options. "And if you're strong, then you don't have any heart. That's a tough dilemma. Perhaps I'd rather be strong, but that's a tough dilemma."
Change of course
Few inside the White House expected him to act alone, particularly given the adamant claims from top officials that any solution required Congress. So when Trump did abruptly change course midweek, a frenzy ensued. The executive order he demanded was so hastily written that Kelly and McGahn urged against signing it. Once it was inked, federal agencies scrambled to decipher its meaning.
But it only took one day and countless headlines declaring he'd caved for Trump to return to the sharp-edged rhetoric.
"They're the worst immigration laws in the history of the world. The whole world is laughing at the United States, and they have been for years," he said, before lambasting Democrats: "Their policies stink. They're no good. They have no ideas -- they have no nothing."
At the southern border, Trump's wife was working to soften the administration's image in a trip her office said she devised herself. Touring a facility for separated children that resembled an elementary school, Melania Trump told officials she wanted to find out how she could "help to be sure these children reunite with their families as quickly as possible."
All that was soon obscured by the revelation her jacket was emblazoned with the words "I REALLY DON'T CARE, DO U?" -- a seemingly unfortunate misstep on which the White House, in keeping with the week's them, managed to adopt a multitude of positions.
"There was no hidden message," the first lady's communications director said. After a quick huddle in the Oval Office upon Melania's return, she was overruled by the President.
"Refers to the Fake News Media," he said. "Melania has learned how dishonest they are, and she truly no longer cares!"
Copyright 2023 by Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.