Takeaways from day six of the Paul Manafort trial
Former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort's criminal trial had a sole, sensational focus on its sixth day: Rick Gates, his longtime deputy and right-hand man, testified against him for more than six hours.Posted — Updated
Gates described in detail his crimes against his employer and even an extramarital affair he'd had, while turning the knife on his longtime boss by outlining the crimes he claims Manafort directed him to commit.
Here are 4 takeaways from the day in court Tuesday:
1. Gates delivers
Prosecutors have a star witness in Gates, and they also have a wellspring of evidence. From 9:30 am until just after 3 pm, Gates corroborated the testimony of Manafort's bookkeeper and two accountants from the days before, along with prosecutors' evidence. Gates testified that he'd followed Manafort's instructions as they set up Cypriot and other foreign bank accounts, moved money from Ukrainians into the US, made sure Manafort's name was scrubbed from the accounts, then lied to the IRS and banks.
RELATED: Gates admits to affair, says Manafort approved shifting money through offshore accounts
And there were Manafort's emails, which prosecutors showed to the courtroom.
Manafort to Gates in 2011, telling him to "proceed" with secret foreign wire transfers.
Manafort to Gates in 2015, "WTF? How could I be blindsided like this" on his high tax bill.
Manafort to Gates in 2016, doctoring numbers in a financial statement.
"The circles are now squared," Gates told Manafort in 2016.
Gates knew the underbelly of the entire operation. He said so to the jury, adding to the prosecutors' pile of evidence.
2. Gates impeached?
It's not over until the singer sings some more. In prosecutors' questioning, then in a combative cross-examination from the defense team, Gates revealed the extent to which he had siphoned money from his boss and committed a host of other misdeeds.
Could his admissions alone be enough to puncture the jury's trust in what he says?
Manafort's team hopes so. It's hung much of its strategy on carving away at what Gates says. Defense attorney Kevin Downing pushed as hard as he could for the last two hours of Tuesday's proceedings to get a rise out of Gates, who refused to engage with more than flat, passionless responses. Gates even refused to call the man he had known for decades and worked under for years "Paul," instead referring to the defendant as "Mr. Manafort." The pair avoided all eye contact.
Gates' admissions throughout the day included having a flat in London so he could cheat on his wife, helping another colleague -- who's been indicted in a separate white-collar case -- fake an investment document and lying to investigators earlier this year after he began to speak to them about a plea deal.
By way of explanation, Gates said he had been living beyond his means at the time he stole hundreds of thousands of dollars from Manafort. "I regret it, clearly, and I'm taking responsibility for it," he said.
Later, Gates spoke directly to the 16 assembled jurors: "I'm here to tell the truth. ... Mr. Manafort had the same path. I'm here."
3. Defense hasn't shown Gates worked alone
Through all the defense team's bluster and Gates' confessions, Downing did not press the star witness into what his side had previously alleged. The defense asserted in its opening statement that Gates could have committed the bank fraud, tax fraud and foreign banking crimes that form Manafort's charges. In short, they said they wanted to pin it all on the underling.
But they did not distance the deputy much from Manafort the boss Tuesday in their questioning.
The defense team's cross-examination hasn't yet undercut the prosecution's assertion that Manafort knew about and directed Gates to lie to a raft of financial professionals and on official forms over several years. That area of questions could come first thing Wednesday morning, when Gates returns to the stand to face more of Downing's inquisition.
For now, the defense team has largely left in tact the possibility that Manafort engaged in the crimes alongside Gates.
Sure, Gates called himself a liar and a cheat on Tuesday. But so far as the jury has heard, Manafort is too.
4. Trump haunts the courtroom
In the world outside Alexandria's courthouse square, special counsel Robert Mueller continues his investigation into the Trump campaign's possible coordination with Russia. But inside the courtroom, trial proceedings had plodded along nearly Trump-free. Until Tuesday.
For the first time, the jury heard about the extent that Manafort and Gates had worked for the Trump campaign.
Jurors saw emails from Manafort imploring Gates to help a banker, Stephen Calk, make inroads into the campaign, inauguration and administration. And prosecutors flashed a note from a meeting Manafort and Gates had in 2013, showing that an unnamed Trump may have received Manafort's Yankees tickets.
Prosecutors had intentionally left many of these pieces of evidence blank on an itemized list of documents they are presenting in court, signaling they could be the most sensational and attention-grabbing files in the evidence binder.
There are still several more documents on the prosecutors' list called "intentionally left blank." Plus the Yankees ticketing staffer and the banker who worked under Calk have yet to testify.
How much more might we hear about Trump? That could be limited by ground rules both sides agreed to before the trial, including that Manafort's team must not assert that the special counsel's office had a political motivation.
Downing tried to take it further at a climactic moment of his Gates questioning Tuesday. "Were you interviewed on several occasions about your time at the Trump campaign?" he edged in. A prosecutor objected, and Ellis spoke to both sets of attorneys under seal before the court took a mid-afternoon break.
The question didn't come up again.
Copyright 2023 by Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.