5 On Your Side

Stock vs. broth: Chefs should know the difference

Consumer Reports looked at chicken broth, chicken stock and bone broth to determine the difference -- and which is best for you.

Posted Updated

Monica Laliberte
, WRAL executive producer/consumer reporter
RALEIGH, N.C. — Grocery store shelves are lined with broth and stock of all kinds, including organic, low-sodium and bone broths.

Many chefs substitute one for the other without hesitation, but according to Consumer Reports, there are some differences.

Stock and broth are both made with a combination of meat and bones, and both can add flavor to all kinds of dishes, including casseroles, rice, vegetables and mashed potatoes.

Broth has a higher proportion of meat, giving it a lighter body and meatier flavor, while stock is generally made with a higher proportion of bones and tends to have more body, experts say.

"Because stock is used as a base in recipes that call for extra seasoning, store-bought stock tends to have less sodium than broth," said Amy Keating, a nutritionist with Consumer Reports.

A third option, bone broth, generally provides more protein than stock or regular broth.

"Many people believe that bone broth has special health benefits," Keating said. "But there's little research to back that up."

Experts recommend deciding which flavor you like best while opting for as little sodium as possible. Labels that read "low sodium" typically have less salt than those that read "reduced sodium."

Consumer Reports warns that sodium in canned broth can be very high. It found products with close to 900 milligrams per cup, so check the labels closely.


Copyright 2023 All Consumer Reports material Copyright 2017 Consumer Reports, Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Consumer Reports is a not-for-profit organization which accepts no advertising. It has no commercial relationship with any advertiser or sponsor on this site. For more information visit consumer.org (http://consumer.org/)