NC House divided over how, whether to teach America's racist past
"It's wrong, and as far as I'm concerned. It's mean-spirited," a Native American member of the House tells his Republican colleagues.Posted — Updated
Black Democrats and the House's lone Native American, called the bill anti-history, anti-education and, in the words of Rep. Kandie Smith, D-Pitt, tantamount "to a book burning." They said it would hamstring teachers, leaving them confused about the rules and fearful to lead frank discussions on race and the sadder epochs of American history.
“We’re trying to circumvent history is what we’re doing here," said Rep. Charles Graham, D-Robeson, a member of the Lumbee tribe. “It’s wrong, and as far as I’m concerned, it’s mean-spirited.”
Republicans kept quiet on the bill for the most part during floor debate, letting bill sponsor Rep. John Torbett, R-Gaston, make their case.
“This bill does not change what history can and cannot be taught," Torbett said. "It simply prohibits schools from endorsing discriminatory concepts."
House Bill 324 would forbid schools from promoting the idea that any race or sex is inherently superior and from teaching that anyone should feel guilt, discomfort or responsibility for "actions committed in the past by other members of the same race or sex." It also forbids promoting the idea that the United States is racist or sexist or that it was "created by members of a particular race or sex to oppress members of another race or sex."
The bill is a response to a shifting social studies curriculum in North Carolina and the influence of critical race theory, a point of view that acknowledges the existence of white supremacy and systemic racism and holds that some institutions are inherently racist because they maintain the momentum of racial inequality.
The bill would allow teachers to "state" those concepts, but they'd have to "make clear" that the school system doesn't endorse them. The measure is similar to Republican-backed bills in other states.
Democrats said the measure would limit difficult conversations to save white people's feelings, but those conversations are needed.
“If you genuinely believe that the solution will just come by never mentioning racism again, you’re fooling yourself,” Smith said.
Rep. James Gailliard, D-Nash, ticked through racist chapters in American history, from slavery to the Supreme Court's Dred Scott decision to presidential opinions that Native Americans were "savages," to cases of mortgage lending discrimination revealed by studies published even in recent years.
Twelve million people were brought here as slaves, he said.
"How can our school systems not teach that our nation was founded on oppression?" Gailliard asked.
Torbett spoke twice on the bill.
"To be clear, explicitly clear, this bill does not change in any way what history can and cannot be taught," he said. "It tells our children what we honestly owe them. … What we owe them is that education system that unites and not divides.”
Copyright 2023 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.