National News

Multiple Deaths as Train Derails on Amtrak Route

Posted December 18, 2017 8:20 p.m. EST

Jay Inslee, governor of Washington state, speaks to reporters at Dupont City Hall in Dupont, Wash., Dec. 18, 2017. Multiple people were killed and more than 75 were taken to local hospitals after an Amtrak train derailed from a highway overpass on Monday morning, according to local authorities. (Ruth Fremson/The New York Times)

DUPONT, Wash. — A passenger train on a newly opened high-speed Amtrak route jumped the tracks on an overpass south of Tacoma on Monday, slamming rail cars into a busy highway, killing at least three people and injuring more than 100 others, officials said.

The derailment of Amtrak Train No. 501, making the inaugural run of a new service from Seattle to Portland, dropped a 132-ton locomotive in the southbound lanes of the Northwest’s busiest travel corridor, Interstate 5. Two passenger coaches also fell partly in the traffic lanes, and two other coaches were left dangling off the bridge, one of them wedged against a tractor-trailer. On the highway below lay seven crumpled cars and trucks, and huge chunks of concrete that were ripped away from the damaged overpass.

All 12 of the train’s coaches and one of its two engines derailed. The National Transportation Safety Board dispatched an investigative team to investigate everything from the speed of the train to whether a technology known as positive train control could have slowed it.

“It felt like the end of the world, and I was standing amid the wreckage,” said Emma Shafer, 20, a modern dance student who was napping aboard the train with her shoes off when it derailed. She found herself in a coach dangling at a steep angle toward the highway — the man behind her yelling, his legs pinned, while a parent trapped with a baby in a restroom banged on the door for help getting out.

The crash, at 7:33 a.m. Pacific time and about midway between Tacoma and Olympia, killed at least three people, local police and fire officials said late Monday afternoon. Earlier, a federal official briefed on the crash said that six people had been killed. Some of those injured were in vehicles on the highway and not on the train.

But investigators are still going through the wreckage and could not say for certain how many people have died. “It appears that all of the fatalities are contained in the rail cars that went into the woods,” said Detective Ed Troyer a spokesman for the Pierce County Sheriff’s Department, adding that rescue workers were using chain saws to try to reach victims in those cars.

CHI Franciscan Health, a regional hospital network, said that the injured were transported to nearby hospitals, including four who were classified “level red,” reflecting the most severe injuries.

The train carried 77 passengers and seven crew members, said Gay Banks Olson, assistant superintendent of Northwest operations for Amtrak.

President Donald Trump wrote on Twitter that the crash on Amtrak’s Cascades service showed the need for increased infrastructure spending.

“The train accident that just occurred in DuPont, WA shows more than ever why our soon to be submitted infrastructure plan must be approved quickly,” Trump wrote. “Seven trillion dollars spent in the Middle East while our roads, bridges, tunnels, railways (and more) crumble! Not for long!”

In fact, the tracks where the accident occurred were brand new and the result of a recent infrastructure investment program.

Backed by the state of Washington, Sound Transit, the regional transit agency, used $180 million from the 2009 federal stimulus package to buy an old, 14.5-mile stretch of track and upgrade it for high-speed passenger service. The project, known as the Point Defiance Bypass, was devised to allow Cascades trains to stop using a more roundabout route that they shared with freight trains, making for faster, more reliable travel.

The state also spent $58 million from the stimulus bill on eight new locomotives, specifically for that service.

The Cascades service embodies the complex, overlapping responsibilities on many of the nation’s rail lines. Officials said the service is owned by the states of Washington and Oregon, and operated by Amtrak, whereas the Point Defiance Bypass track is owned by Sound Transit, a regional transit agency, and dispatched by BNSF, the freight company that used to own the line.

“There have been a lot of trial runs” on the line, said Olson of Amtrak. She said it was far too soon to discuss a cause for the disaster.

The train derailed where the track curved onto the bridge across Interstate 5. The state Transportation Department had boasted that the new route would have a top speed of 79 mph, though it was not clear if a slower limit was in place where the train crashed. Shortly before the accident, a passenger, Chris Karnes, chairman of the advisory board to Pierce County’s transit agency, took to Twitter to marvel at how fast the train was, noting, “We are passing up traffic on I-5.”

Federal law requires railroads, by the end of 2018, to have technology known as positive train control, which automatically slows trains down if they are exceeding speed limits or approaching dangerous conditions. In its latest progress report to the railroad administration, Amtrak said it had installed positive train control on all 603 miles of track on the Northeast Corridor, from Washington to Boston.

The Washington state Department of Transportation has said that the entire Cascades route will have the system by mid-2018, but it was not clear whether it was in operation on Monday on any part of the line.

Positive train control could have prevented some of the nation’s worst rail disasters, like the 2008 collision of a commuter train and a freight train in Los Angeles that killed 25 people, or the 2015 derailment of an Amtrak train in Philadelphia that went into a curve at more than twice the allowed speed, an accident that killed eight people.

Gov. Jay Inslee of Washington, who declared a state of emergency, cautioned against jumping to the conclusion that excessive speed or shoddy work upgrading the line were to blame for Monday’s crash.

“Suspend judgment about what happened in this incident,” he said, after visiting victims who were taken to the nearby DuPont City Hall. “No one knows what happened in this incident.” Interstate 5, the main route linking the cities along Puget Sound, was closed to southbound traffic, and vehicles heading north moved slowly past the wreckage. Officials said they did not know how long it would take to remove the remains of the train, make sure the bridge was safe to pass beneath, and reopen the southbound lanes.

Paul Woodbury, 29, who was in the sixth car of the train when it derailed, described a chaotic scene, with severely injured people on the ground and screams piercing the air as he climbed out of the wreckage. Once outside, in the cool morning mist, “people stood around, shellshocked,” he said, until emergency workers came to get them.

Other survivors told local media about picking through broken glass and twisted metal, struggling to pry out windows to escape, and using the flashlight function on their cellphones to see in the ruined, darkened coaches. Witnesses told of motorists leaving their vehicles on the highway to help pull people from the wreckage.

Later, some of the rail cars were too precarious for rescuers to enter in search of victims, said Brooke Bova, a spokeswoman for the Washington State Patrol.

The Cascades line is a popular one, running through spectacular scenery — the sound, forests, farms and, most striking of all, the Cascades range, including Mount Rainier. In the past, the trip between Portland and Seattle has taken about four hours.