Did you know that by the time kids reach middle school, many lose interest in learning? They become detached from school and disengaged from their lessons.

The disengaged teen is not a new phenomenon, but its impact is more visible now than ever.

Other WRAL Top Stories

A recent book, The Disengaged Teen, dives into this current crisis through research from Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop.

They shed light on the different modes of student engagement in school and highlight the urgent need for teen intervention from both educators and parents.

Four modes of Student Engagement

Teens engage with school in four distinct ways, according to Anderson and Winthrop.

They label these as “modes” that act as identities for students, defining how they interact with school.

Students can shift between these modes depending on their environment, curriculum, and support systems. However, it can be risky for youth to be stuck long-term in the first three modes.

1.      Resister Mode: These students resist and struggle learning, often doing so in silence. They feel inadequate and struggle to take positive action, leading to behaviors like skipping assignments, feigning illness, or chronic absenteeism.

2.      Passenger Mode: Teens in this mode coast along like a “classroom passenger princess.” They do just enough to get by. To them, school feels meaningless, so they disengage emotionally and intellectually.

3.      Achiever Mode: Youth who embody this identity tie their self-worth to performance. While they earn high grades, they battle the weight of perfectionism and a crippling fear of failure.

4.      Explorer Mode: The ideal mode, students here are driven by curiosity and persistence. These learners engage deeply, take on challenges, and view failure as part of growth.

The Parental Perception Gap

The modes not only define school engagement, but they signify the way teens perceive themselves.

Adolescence is a transformative period, marked by vast cognitive and emotional restructuring. Teens can easily get trapped in one of these modes as they deal with ever-shifting feelings and the challenges of growing up.

Parents and educators play a critical role in helping youth develop healthy identities.

As mentors, the goal is not to just create high-performing students. Instead, we need to help teens grow what Anderson and Winthrop call “Explorer Muscles.” These muscles mean students can learn, adapt, and push through challenges.

However, parents often struggle to know when their teens don’t have these muscles.

There is a parental perception gap—a disconnect between how engaged parents believe their teens are and what students report.

Journalist Kevin Mahnken once said, “Kids check out of school as they get older, and parents are in the dark.”

So, how do we change this?

Cultivating engaged kids starts by helping them find the right kind of motivation.

Motivation can allow teens to become interested learners with healthy identities.

Motivation can’t be fear-based, though. According to cognitive neuroscientist Tali Sharot, research shows that this type of incentive is proven to be ineffective. When confronted with negative information, teens (and adults) tend to shut down or distort reality, instead.

Fear induces inaction rather than change.

What type of motivation works then? There are three primary types that parents should try with their teens:

1.      Social Incentives

We are inherently social beings. Teens, in particular, care deeply about what their peers think and do. Highlighting positive behaviors among their peer group can be a powerful motivator.

Sharot’s research shows that knowing how others behave triggers a response in the emotional center of the brain, increasing the likelihood of conformity to positive habits.

2.      Immediate Rewards

Future goals feel abstract to teens, which is why immediate rewards are more effective in driving behavior.

Small, tangible rewards—recognition, privileges, or personal satisfaction—help reinforce desired behaviors and make progress feel attainable.

3.      Progress Monitoring

Rather than focusing on what teens are doing wrong, emphasize their progress to help give them motivation.

When individuals track their growth instead of failures, they gain a sense of control that increases their engagement and willingness to improve. For example, parents can avoid giving warnings about failing grades and instead highlight improvements to reinforce momentum.

Reframing Disengagement

Teens’ identities can be shaped by their educational engagement. A teen’s connection—or lack thereof — to school influences their self-perception.

Schools, families, and communities must work together to ensure teens feel seen, valued, and capable.

The disengagement crisis isn’t inevitable for our own teens. We can reignite curiosity and resilience in our youth.

Let’s be intentional and guide them toward learning that excites, challenges, and empowers them for a thriving future.

Gale McKoy Wilkins is a certified family life coach expert educated through the North Carolina State University Family Life Coaching program who holds a William Peace University Human Services degree. To learn more about Family Life Coaching, check out my teachable course through my life-coaching organization, Project Arrow. Find it online at https://project-arrow.teachable.com or call our office at 919-824-7528.