GOP's new maps moving through legislature
Four-and-a-half hours after a Senate committee hearing on voting district maps started Thursday, debate had grown testy, with white Republicans jostling with black Democrats over questions of race.
Posted — UpdatedThursday's meeting began with a couple of tweaks from Democrats that Republicans backed, moving smaller groups of voters to keep a historic African-American community intact in one Wake County district and moving another 300 or so people in Cumberland County so that a Democratic senator's second home would remain in his district.
Then it became a partisan slog of proposals and exhortations from Democrats met by talking points from the Republican majority, all repeated several times as both sides looked to expose chinks the other's armor and a court reporter took down every word for the case file. By the end, four-and-a-half hours after the meeting started, debate had grown testy, with white Republicans jostling with black Democrats over questions of race.
"Perhaps the ridiculous nature of this, of this map, speaks for itself," state Sen. Ralph Hise, R-Mitchell, who has spearheaded the majority's map-making effort in the Senate, said as he introduced the group's plan to the committee.
"It cannot be imagined to be a coincidence," said state Sen. Dan Bishop, R-Mecklenburg, one of the senators who stood to lose his seat under the plan.
Anita Earls, the coalition's lead attorney on this case, responded with an emailed statement after the meeting.
"It is outrageous that any alternatives to the Republican majority’s maps are met with cynicism and those drawing them are attacked," Earls said. "Our plaintiffs participated in drawing these maps and put forward districts that focused on being fair to all voters. They did not focus on protecting or targeting incumbents."
Bishop was particularly vocal during debate Thursday, pressing Senate Minority Dan Blue and others on how and why they used racial demographics to draw alternative maps. Democrats argue that you can't fix a racial gerrymander without looking at race, and members point out how similar some of the GOP's newly proposed districts look to those already thrown out by the court.
They also noted the same consultant drew both sets of maps: Tom Hofeller, a map-maker who has drawn districts for Republican majorities around the country.
Republicans hope to short-circuit any attempt to find another racial gerrymander in their new maps.
"There could not be a claim that we somehow over utilized race when we did not use race at all," Hise said.
Related Topics
• Credits
Copyright 2024 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.