Opinion

Editorials of The Times

Democracy Isn’t Dead in Turkey Yet

Posted Updated

By
The Editorial Board
, New York Times
Democracy Isn’t Dead in Turkey Yet

Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s electoral victory in Turkey on Sunday, which returned him to the presidency and gave his coalition command of most parliamentary seats, was a crushing disappointment for Turks and people around the world who are alarmed by his authoritarian behavior and rejection of democratic principles.

Because of constitutional changes narrowly approved in a referendum last year, he will now extend his 15-year-long hold on power with sweeping new authority over the legislature and the judiciary, part of his plan to become a modern-day Ottoman sultan.

And yet, even after he imprisoned thousands of people he viewed as opponents, ensured his cronies would control most of the media, and suppressed dissent, Erdogan faced his toughest electoral struggle. Many Turks have grown tired of his imperial behavior, are uncomfortable with his imposition of Islamic strictures on a secular state and are disturbed by signs of economic weakening.

Democracy is remarkably resilient in Turkey, even if badly battered. You can see it in the 87 percent of all Turkish voters who cast ballots, including at least 1.5 million who live in Germany and elsewhere overseas.

Despite Erdogan’s determined efforts to quash voter turnout by Turkey’s ill-treated Kurdish minority, the HDP, a liberal democratic party that emphasizes minority rights and is led by an imprisoned Kurd, won nearly 12 percent of the vote, allowing it to qualify again for seats in Parliament.

Even more encouraging was the fact that Turkey’s fractured and long-demoralized opposition forged an alliance behind Muhharem Ince, a former physics teacher and veteran lawmaker, with the center-left Republican People’s Party. Ince came nearly out of nowhere to challenge Erdogan, the country’s most dominant politician since Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of modern Turkey, and won 31 percent of the vote, behind Erdogan’s 53 percent.

While Ince wasn’t ultimately able to keep Erdogan’s support below 50 percent and force him into a runoff as some hoped, he mounted an unexpectedly feisty challenge that drew huge crowds to 107 campaign rallies across the country. His compelling political case centered on pledging a return to parliamentary — rather than strong-president — government, a more independent judiciary, greater personal freedoms and a lifting of the state of emergency imposed by Erdogan after a botched coup in 2016.

The election also raised the profile of another credible presidential contender, Meral Aksener, a conservative nationalist who broke from the Nationalist Movement Party, Erdogan’s ally, and formed a new party, called Good. Aksener also opposed the presidential-led authoritarian regime that Erdogan plans to lead and promised to support Ince in the event of a runoff.

Although it may be difficult to summon up optimism after a defeat, if Ince and Aksener stay engaged in politics, they could build a stronger and more organized opposition that will draw in new and younger voters and compete again for control of Parliament, and the presidency, in five years.

Rescuing Turkish democracy from Erdogan’s determined efforts to corrupt the system will also require sustained involvement by the millions of Turks who voted against him and yearn for the days when their country was once on the path to becoming a modern Muslim democracy.

Despite these small victories, there is no sugarcoating the bleak days ahead. This remains a chastening demonstration for advocates of democracy and freedom everywhere that strongman rule still has a chilling appeal to many.

After years of accruing power informally, Erdogan can now officially assert yet more control by dispensing with the office of prime minister, directly appointing top officials, and intervening in the legal system. Given an unexpectedly robust showing by his Justice and Development Party’s partner, the nationalist MHP, Erdogan seems likely to have a broad, and malleable, parliamentary majority.

The new mandate is likely to make Erdogan an even more difficult NATO ally, one who cozies up to Russia, buys Russian missile defense systems and a Russian nuclear reactor, and tangles with the United States over the Kurds in Syria and Iraq.

With the new powers allowing Erdogan to run again and potentially remain in office until 2028, there could be many years ahead to deal with the problems of one-man rule.

Democratic Primary Choices

Here are recommendations in Tuesday’s Democratic primary races in New York for the U.S. House of Representatives. Polls in New York City and Dutchess County will be open from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. In other counties in the 19th District, polls will be open from noon to 9 p.m.

District 9 (Brooklyn)

Adem Bunkeddeko

District 19 (Catskills and Hudson Valley)

Gareth Rhodes

Copyright 2024 New York Times News Service. All rights reserved.