Editorial: Relentless partisan manipulations of state courts threatens justice for all
Wednesday, April 11, 2018 -- It is a fundamental element of a democracy that citizens have courts, including judges, free from undue political or financial influence. Justice that is rigged, no matter by powerful economic interests or by partisan politicians who thrust their thumbs on the scales, is not justice. It is tyranny.Posted — Updated
That statement stands in stark contrast to the tantrum that Berger and Moore threw a little more than a year ago when three North Carolina judges – two Democrats and a Republican – had the temerity to unanimously rule that a power-grab by the General Assembly was wrong.
“Judges are not legislators,” the two said. “If these three men want to make laws they should hang up their robes and run for a legislative seat.”
But, it was the ominous threatening sentence that followed that was most troubling. It was the launch of an all-out assault on justice and the state court system. The independence and impartiality of our state courts may be the casualty.
The two GOP judges’ ruling this week helps further the legislators’ warning.
Within weeks Berger and Moore launched their assault on the courts with the goal of both enshrining a partisan complexion on justice as well as make the courts subservient to the General Assembly – despite the state Constitution’s clear pronouncement that “the legislative, executive, and supreme judicial powers of the State government shall be forever separate and distinct from each other.”
In the last year, the legislature has:
- Abolished primary elections for judges.
- Worked to impose gerrymandered state’s judicial districts to elect more Republicans and fewer blacks and Democrats.
- Reduced the terms of judges – thus threatening their independence and impartiality -- from eight to two years.
- Cut the number of judges on the state Court of Appeals to favor Republicans.
That’s just in the last year.
These legislators have led the state’s retreat from, and abolition of, a non-partisan and publically-funded system to elect judges that was a national model. They’ve even changed state laws, in middle of the 2016 campaign, to tilt the state court of appeals election in favor of Berger’s son.
Let’s be clear. It is a fundamental element of a democracy that citizens have courts, including judges, free from undue political or financial influence. Justice that is rigged, no matter by powerful economic interests or by partisan politicians who thrust their thumbs on the scales, is not justice. It is tyranny.
Concern about this megalomaniac behavior is far from partisan. Joining the voices of Democrats are alarmed prominent Republicans.
Active Republican Bob Orr, who served on the state Supreme Court, was more direct:
Orr is right. It is time for Berger and Moore to take their big thumbs off the scales of justice.
Copyright 2023 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.