Opinion

Opinion

Editorial: Cure to 'Silent Sam' problem is weak. Move statue off campus

Posted December 7, 2018 5:00 a.m. EST

Friday, Dec. 7, 2018 -- Capitol Broadcasting's editorial cartoonist.

CBC Editorial: Friday, Dec. 7, 2018; Editorial #8367
The following is the opinion of Capitol Broadcasting Company


The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill has a bad problem with what to do with the remains of “Silent Sam,” the recently dethroned Confederate statue. The campus Board of Trustees’ proposed solution – a $5.3 million “history center” – makes matters worse.

UNC officials say a 2015 state law limits their options and even forbids moving the statue off campus. It was a solution imposed in 2015, less to peacefully resolve the conflicts over the Jim Crow-era monuments around the state, than to cynically inflame partisan passions and ignite a political base.

Let’s be truthful:

  • Silent Sam and his kin on the state Capitol grounds, in courthouse squares and other sites around North Carolina, are monuments to racial oppression and historical revisionist propaganda. Their appearance and the intended message has been an unmistakable reminder, pointed particularly at African-Americans: “We honor those who fought to keep you slaves; The U.S. Constitution does not apply to you; You are not going to vote; You are not going to be educated; You are not entitled to full citizenship and equality.”
  • The Civil War was NOT a war between states. It was a rebellion of another nation made up of states that seceded from the United States.
  • Confederate Vice President Alexander H. Stephens, in the “Cornerstone Speech” delivered in Savannah on March 21, 1861, clearly states what the war was about.
    “Our new government is founded upon … its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and moral condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth.”
  • The Confederate dead may be respected for having done their duty. They were not heroes.

Other than the politically-motivated sanctification of these statues, there is no reason they cannot be moved. Their continued presence, as seen by events on the UNC campus, in fact fosters threats to public safety.

“The university faces a high risk of violence, civil disorder, and property damage if the monument is restored to its original position,” was the conclusion of a security study by Chris Swecker, former assistant director of the FBI.

UNC officials have been clear about what they’d like to do with Silent Sam: “Our preference is to relocate the artifacts to a secure off-campus location.”

Rather than continuing to degrade and insult North Carolina citizens with the inappropriately prominent displays of racial discrimination and subjugation, it is time to develop a plan to appropriately relocate these relics.

It should NOT be a $5.3 million shrine, but a place where they can be displayed in proper context.

Fortunately, North Carolina has a perfect spot – the Bentonville Battlefield in Johnston County. It is the site of the last major Confederate offensive – less than three weeks before Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee surrendered in Appomattox.

It is a state-owned 130-acre site, already includes a visitors center, exhibits and information that puts the site and March 19-21, 1865 events in context.

Costs to provide an appropriate and adequate exhibit site would be minimal, particularly compared to the exorbitant $5.3 million cost estimated for the UNC site – not to mention the $800,000-a-year operation expense. There would be little need for additional staff and there’s already security at the Bentonville site.

Some – far too many apparently in the General Assembly – look fondly on these statues. But they are testament to a dark time in North Carolina and the South. Those times have left deep wounds. The state and too many of its people still struggle to overcome the toll discrimination has taken.

The General Assembly can start to fix some of the damage it created by repealing Session Law 2015-170 so UNC, other campuses and local agencies, can determine for themselves how best to dispose of these relics of oppression. It should also free the state to provide an appropriate space at Bentonville to for the statues.

Capitol Broadcasting Company's Opinion Section seeks a broad range of comments and letters to the editor. Our Comments beside each opinion column offer the opportunity to engage in a dialogue about this article.

In addition, we invite you to write a letter to the editor about this or any other opinion articles. Here are some tips on submissions >> SUBMIT A LETTER TO THE EDITOR