Opinion

CLAUDIA KOONZ: GOP political theater vs. the truth of Jan. 6.

Wednesday, July 20, 2022 -- Republicans understand politics as theater and deploy spectacular lies to drive the action forward. After the momentum created by the Jan. 6 House hearings, the U.S. Department of Justice must drive the narrative forward by opening a criminal prosecution now.

Posted Updated

EDITOR'S NOTE: Claudia Koonz is Peabody Family Professor, Emeritus, History Department, Duke University. Her book, "Mothers in the Fatherland" was a National Book Award finalist.

Republicans understand politics is war by other means, and that its ‘other means’ is theater. As national attention turns to the U.S. House Jan 6 hearings, their offstage antics escalate.

A weapon-toting Missouri senatorial candidate issued a “RINO hunting permit” in a video ad. Mary Miller, R-Il, called the overturn of Roe “a historic victory for white life.” Ronny Jackson (R-TX) tweeted, “the WITCH HUNT Committee of unselects needs to be DISSOLVED!” Before writing off the crazed fringe of the GOP we should remember how Adolf Hitler snatched victory from a catastrophic attempted putsch in 1923.

In November 1923 police fired on a raucous gang of about 2,000 insurgents in downtown Munich. Fourteen attackers and four policemen died. Hitler and eight comrades were charged with high treason. A guilty verdict could have meant years in prison and, in Hitler’s case, long-term deportation to his home country Austria.

Hitler transformed a crushing defeat into victory because sympathetic Bavarian judges allowed him to take center stage with a big lie. While his co-defendants pleaded not guilty, Hitler proudly took responsibility for the treasonous debacle. For 24 days he raged, often for hours at a time, against the “Jewish-Marxist criminals” whose surrender to Allied armies in 1918 had been the “greatest disgrace in German history.”

His narrative converted treason against the democracy he despised into an act of courage. “Even if you [judges] find us guilty a thousand times over, the goddess of the eternal tribunal of history will smilingly tear apart the … sentence of the Court because she will acquit us.” He did not have to await the verdict of history. Hitler’s paltry five-year sentence was commuted before the next Christmas. Hitler gloated that the trial had, “enormously increased people’s enthusiasm.” It made him an international celebrity.

In the following years, while ordinary politicians debated policy, Joseph Goebbels explained Nazis’ new strategy for war against the government they despised. “We will use democracy to destroy democracy.” But while outrageous lies and sporadic terror solidified the Nazi hard core, the Weimar Republic stood firm. Voters, with turnout rates above 80 percent, cast less than 3 percent of their ballots for Nazi candidates. Then, with the onset of the Great Depression, unemployment climbed to 33 percent. Political gridlock paralyzed the government.  In five national elections from 1931-32, voters shifted from moderate to extreme parties, and the Nazi vote increased to over 30 percent.

Facing fractious opponents, the Nazi Party escalated its violence, fraud and libel --- crimes that became virtues in its imagined war for survival against a fictitious “Judeo-Communist” conspiracy.

Trump mirrors Hitler’s delusional rants when he calls the ”stolen” election, “the greatest crime in history.” Fact checking is pointless because politics is spectacle. Each outrageous lie brings an opportunity for loyalists to pledge their allegiance in a war against values they despise.
The “Stolen Election” fraud drove not only insurrectionists and their President on Jan 6 but also the 147 members of Congress who refused to certify the 2020 election. Attacks on representative democracy escalated as state legislators and the U.S. Supreme Court brazenly thwarted majority rule on reproductive choice, gun ownership and the separation of church and state. In the theater of political war, each affirmation of “Stop the Steal” became a “winning strategy” for over 100 GOP primary candidates.
Thanks to the moral courage of the Jan 6 Committee witnesses, the Trump conspirators’ treasonous intent and criminal acts were revealed. Meanwhile Trump roared, “There’s no cleaner example of the menacing spirit that has devoured the American left than the disgraceful performance being staged by the ‘unselect’ committee” and derided Cassidy Hutchinson as “a total phony and "leaker." Against the Trump team’s sideshows, the Jan 6 Committee has driven the drama forward.
Now, with testimony from White House insiders fraying GOP solidarity, the offense mounted by the Jan 6 Committee continues. At the conclusion of the seventh hearing, remarks by Jamie Raskin, D-MD suggested a motto for upcoming campaigns. No more carnage! It’s up to the Department of Justice to fulfill that promise.
As Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said, ‘Presidents are not kings.” They cannot use democracy to destroy democracy by overriding our votes. By a slim margin most Americans believe Trump should face criminal charges. As conservative Judge Michael Luttig told the Jan 6 Committee, “False claims that our elections have been stolen from us corrupt our democracy, as they corrupt us.”

Four months may be too little time to complete an unhindered Department of Justice prosecution, and state and local elected officials may manage to steal the November election.

What will history say about an attorney general who visited Ukraine to endorse the hunt for Russian war criminals but FAILED to prosecute the criminal conspiracy to overthrow the 2020 election?

Copyright 2024 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.