Big Winners From Tax Cut Are Banks Big and Small
Posted January 16, 2018 7:41 p.m. EST
WASHINGTON — The nation’s banks are finding a lot to love about the Trump administration’s tax cuts.
The $1.5 trillion tax overhaul signed into law late last year provided deep and lasting tax cuts to all types of businesses, but financial institutions are among the biggest winners so far, reaping benefits from a lower corporate rate and more preferable tax treatment for so-called pass-through companies, which include many small banks.
While some of the biggest banks are reporting fourth-quarter earnings hits stemming from the new tax law, they see rich benefits over the long term, including effective tax rates that are even lower than the new 21 percent corporate rate.
Citigroup said Tuesday that it would take a one-time $22 billion hit from the tax law, largely related to the bank’s tax-deferred assets, which now must be recalibrated to reflect the lower corporate rate. In a news release, Citigroup chief executive Michael Corbat said the law nevertheless “not only leads to higher net income and increased returns, but also serves to strengthen our capital generation capabilities going forward.”
JPMorgan Chase & Co., the nation’s largest bank, and Wells Fargo both said Friday that they expected the new law to reduce their effective tax rates next year to 19 percent, a cut of nearly one-third from what they paid in 2016. The reduction will give the banks a combined boost of more than $7 billion in 2018 alone. PNC Financial said Friday that it expected its effective tax rate to fall even further next year, to 17 percent.
“The good news is that tax reform has produced both current and future benefits for our shareholders,” PNC’s president and chief executive Bill Demchak told analysts Friday. He said the bank’s preference would be to divert the tax savings “toward dividend” — which is to say, to return a higher dividend to shareholders.
Since the tax bill was signed into law, analysts have raised their consensus estimates for financial firms’ 2018 earnings growth by almost 75 percent, according to data compiled by S&P Capital IQ.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., a persistent critic of Wall Street, said the response from financial firms confirmed that “banks are the big winners” from the tax law, and not workers.
Warren said she found it galling that less than a decade after the financial crisis, “banks are making record profits and scooping up the biggest benefits from the Republican tax bill, while many working families are still recovering from that crisis.”
More than 70 financial institutions have announced they will raise wages or offer bonuses to employees after the tax law’s passage, including big firms such as Bank of America and community banks such as Bank of the Ozarks. All told, those institutions account for about half of the companies that have promised raises or bonuses since President Donald Trump signed the bill into law, according to a running list by Americans for Tax Reform, a group that advocates low taxes.
The payouts to workers reflect a small slice of the windfall that banks large and small are in line to receive. The law includes a reduction in the corporate rate to 21 percent from a high of 35 percent last year, as well as a 20 percent deduction for income from pass-through companies. One-third of all community banks are organized as pass-throughs, according to the Independent Community Bankers of America, which represents those firms and was among the groups pushing for a lower pass-through rate.
Analysts projected the financial industry would reap some of the largest benefits from that reduction given that banks typically paid much higher effective tax rates in the past than many other industries, like manufacturing.
The boon for banks comes as the industry begins to regain some of its swagger in the wake of the financial crisis and as it seeks to roll back some of the post-crisis regulations put in place by the Obama administration under the 2010 Dodd-Frank law.
Officials at top banks have mostly showered Trump with praise for his economic policy agenda, which they say is expanding growth. Jamie Dimon, chief executive officer of JPMorgan Chase, called the new tax law a “significant positive outcome for the country” in a news release accompanying the bank’s earnings on Friday. The gains come despite a one-time hit of $2.4 billion that JPMorgan Chase reported in the fourth quarter, the result of a provision in the law that forces companies to pay a one-time tax on profits that are held overseas.
Other large banks will report earnings on Tuesday and are expected to similarly reveal large savings from the tax overhaul.
American Express, in a financial filing this month, said the lower corporate rate “is expected to be a significant ongoing benefit to us. Beginning in 2018, we anticipate an effective tax rate in the low twenties before discrete tax items.”
Democrats pushed banks to go further in passing benefits of the tax bill on to their workers. “Every dollar going to stock buybacks and higher dividends for shareholders is not going into the pockets of working families in Ohio and across the country,” said Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio, the top Democrat on the banking committee.
Wells Fargo, which has been under a cloud of regulatory and legal challenges, said last month that it would raise its minimum pay to $15 an hour. A spokesman initially said the move was not related to the tax bill, but reversed course a day later and said that, in fact, the tax cuts did prompt the move.
Dimon said on Friday that JPMorgan Chase would be “increasing and accelerating” investments in “employees, customers and communities,” though he did not specify what that would mean for individual workers. On a call with analysts, Marianne Lake, the bank’s chief financial officer, suggested some of the benefits would be used to increase dividends and stock buybacks.
Other banks have announced additional share buybacks in recent weeks, including Bank of America and Fifth Third Bank. Both of those banks also said they would provide bonuses to some workers as a result of the tax overhaul. Comerica Bank said on Tuesday that it spent a net $3 million in the fourth quarter of 2017 on employee bonuses linked to the tax bill. Over the same period, it spent $148 million buying back stock.