Health Team

UNC-CH researcher says 'Concussion' has good, bad impact

Posted December 29, 2015

— A neuroscientist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill who has studied concussions for more than two decades says a new film about brain injuries and professional football is prompting good discussion of the issue but may create unnecessary paranoia over it as well.

Kevin Guskiewicz said the film "Concussion" is part truth, part fiction in telling the story of a scientist who first linked a degenerative brain condition to the repeated blows to the head football players dish out and receive and then faced down the National Football League over his research. Guskiewicz is a former trainer for the Pittsburgh Steelers who now heads the Matthew Gfeller Sport-Related Traumatic Brain Injury Research Center and the Center for the Study of Retired Athletes at UNC-Chapel Hill.

"It was very entertaining movie, certainly made for Hollywood," he said Tuesday. "(It's) based on a true story, but they certainly twisted the truth in certain parts of the movie to keep it entertaining."

Guskiewicz has studied and worked with concussed athletes of all levels, from high school to the NFL in hopes of making sports safer. He said there's much that researchers still need to learn about the brain condition, chronic traumatic encephalopathy.

"We have no idea how many people in the United States, or in the world, might have CTE and what the risk factors may be," he said. "There may be genetic predisposition to this that just hasn’t been uncovered yet."

He said he's worried that the film may feed the paranoia that America is in a concussion crisis.

"There are no more concussions on our playing fields today as there were 10 to 15 years ago. It’s simply we know more about them," he said. "More people are showing up in emergency departments and doctors' offices, so it just appears there are more than there used to be."

Guskiewicz has three sons who played football, and none had a concussion. He said he hopes the movie doesn't drive youths off the field of play.

"There are far more benefits to being active participants in sport than there are the risks and consequences around concussions for the millions of kids we’re trying to keep active to prevent childhood obesity and diabetes," he said. "I would say it’s never been safer to play sports than it is today because of the awareness and rules changes that have been made in many sports."

Still, he said, the movie is bringing needed awareness to the issue of concussions and safety.

"One of the things I’m glad has come out of all of this that there has been more attention paid to the issue, and parents have gotten involved," he said. "I think, as a result, we’ll see more parents becoming active participants in decisions about their children and their participation in sports."


Please with your account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Christian Bonanno Dec 31, 2015
    user avatar

    This guy should be stripped of his medical licence. I never saw such an obvious paid shill for the University. A gross attempt at keeping the money flowing into UNC Football.

    He says; "There are no more concussions on our playing fields today as there were 10 to 15 years ago. It’s simply we know more about them." No, we know that there are a lot more long term negative effects from even slight concussions so it makes the risks of getting a concussion higher. The doctor in that film even recently said: "Regarding CTE, I think the real risk isn't concussion but repetitive blows. The big thing is to reduce the unnecessary, excessive, gratuitous head contacts. I think that's what the long-term safety of the sport (depends on), more than isolated concussions.

  • Roscoe P Coltrane Dec 30, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    If you don't like contact sports, don't participate in them or watch them. There are very few sports, that are non contact. Even still in those, there is an inherent risk of danger. Bob, I do hope you don't play golf, tennis, or run marathons. You should not go bowling, participate in yachting, swim, hunt or even go fishing. About all you can do, is play shuffleboard, but if you are an avid shuffleboard player, you could break a hip or have a heart attack, because you would be old. Just sin it your favorite chair and watch your clock tick your life away.

  • Paul Donovan Dec 29, 2015
    user avatar

    It doesn't matter, people aren't going to see it after months of the media trying to hype the movie. It did 4.3 million in its first weekend which is nothing for such a hyped movie.