Thousands cast provisional ballots in NC primary

Posted March 22, 2016

Nearly 8,000 Wake County voters cast provisional ballots in the March 15, 2016, primary.

— At least 40,000 voters across North Carolina cast provisional ballots during the primary because there was some sort of administrative issue when they came to the polls.

In Wake County, so many voters – nearly 8,000 – cast provisional ballots that the Board of Elections has delayed its official canvass day – the day a county’s results for most elections become official – from Tuesday until Thursday morning.

Fourteen other counties also delayed the completion of their official canvass as local elections officials sift through provisional ballots trying to determine which will fully count, which will partially count and which won’t be counted at all.

The higher number of provisional ballots is most likely a reflection of increased voter turnout and interest in the March 15 primary, driven mainly by interest in the Republican and Democratic presidential contests.

“I’ve never had a presidential candidate show up at a polling place on Election Day,” said Gary Sims, elections director for Wake County. Democrat Hillary Clinton campaigned at Southeast Raleigh Magnet High School as voters went to the polls. Her rival, Bernie Sanders, along with Republicans Ted Cruz and Donald Trump held rallies in the state in the week leading up to the election.

A provisional ballot is one that is linked to a specific voter so it can be traced and examined at a later time. Voters are given provisional ballots when there is some sort of administrative problem with their ballots.

For example, more than a quarter of those who cast provisional ballots are those for whom there was no record of registration.

Another reason voters received provisional ballots was they voted at the wrong precinct on primary day. Those ballots will count for statewide and countywide races but not for legislative seats or county commissioner if it was cast in the wrong district.

Voters who had problems with the new voter ID rules were also given provisional ballots. Despite this being the first election with voter ID in place, election officials say those issues did not trigger the bulk of provisional voting. Only about 2,400 voters across the state – or about 6 percent of the provisional ballots – had ID problems. As a percentage of 2.3 million voters who cast a ballot in the primary, the number with voter ID issues was tiny: 0.1 percent.

According to Sims and state elections officials, one of the biggest and more surprising causes of provisional voting were members of one party trying to vote in the other party’s primary.

“I’ve never seen so many people just wanting to vote in a different party,” Sims said.

In Wake County, 17 percent of those who cast provisional ballots were trying to vote in the wrong party. That’s up from roughly 9 percent in a typical year.

Anecdotally, voters trying to cast ballots for and against Trump may have caused many of the failed cross-party votes. The Trump campaign, for example, was encouraging Democrats to cross party lines. But North Carolina law doesn’t allow registered Democrats to vote in the Republican primary.

Because state officials are still working through provisional ballots, it’s unclear whether the final numbers will bear out this speculation.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Maurice Pentico Jr. Mar 23, 2016
    user avatar

    0.1% of voters had difficulty voting due to an ID. (Note: Difficulty, not denied) Even with RECORD turnout!

    Wow... just think how well the system will be working next election, and the elections to come!!!

    Good job!

  • Hamilton Bean Mar 23, 2016
    user avatar

    Well, so much for the dire predictions of gloom, doom, disenfranchised poor, minority, etc voters due to the ID requirement. NAACP, etc are looking just a tad foolish if you ask me..

  • Scooter Barrette Mar 23, 2016
    user avatar

    Thank you NC legislature for disbanding same-day registration and pre-registration for high-schoolers! What's that? Only 50% of the provisional ballots actually were counted?

  • Phillip Mozingo Mar 23, 2016
    user avatar

    So, how do you NOT know where your voting precinct is and how do you expect to vote without being registered?? Some people will try anything!

  • Doug Smallen Mar 23, 2016
    user avatar

    So you register and don't follow up to see if it is on the books before the election, how dumb of just lazy is that!

  • Eric Bohlen Mar 22, 2016
    user avatar

    I cast one because my address is not in the system as of yet. Easy to do and they make a point to ensure your vote counts. ID or no ID, if you are ok to vote, they will count it