The single word etched on this 9/11 memorial that is sparking controversy

Posted September 11

 (Deseret Photo)

Controversy is brewing in the town of Owego, New York, over some of the words etched on a new monument honoring lives lost during the 9/11 terror attacks.

The monument — made, in part, from pieces of the subway rail that ran underneath the Twin Towers — will be permanently located in Hickories Park.

But the display, which will be dedicated over the weekend, has reportedly drawn the ire of the Islamic Organization of the Southern Tier, a local Muslim group.

At the center of the controversy is a reference on the monument to "19 Islamic terrorists" who were responsible for the attacks, according to WICZ-TV.

"On September 11, 2001, nineteen Islamic terrorists unsuspectedly boarded four airliners departing east coast airports to hijack the planes and carry out a series of coordinated attacks against the United States," the inscription reads. "This is a tribute to all the lives lost that day and to the heroic sacrifice of all who rushed to help. As Americans, we honor their memory by living our lives in freedom."

The text concludes, "We will never forget."

The Islamic Organization of the Southern Tier reportedly wrote a letter to Owego officials saying the words "Islamic terrorists" are improper and asked that the monument's language be changed to "terrorists" or "al-Qaida terrorists" instead.

But city manager Donald Castellucci told conservative commentator Todd Starnes that he disagrees with the Islamic Organization of the Southern Tier's arguments.

"They want us to change the word from 'Islamic terrorist' to either 'terrorist' or 'al-Qaida terrorist,'" Castellucci told Starnes. "I sent them back an email saying I disagreed with their premise 100 percent."

It's a sentiment that reflects what Castellucci previously told WICZ-TV, saying that he has no plans to "whitewash things."

"I don’t live in a politically correct world," he told the outlet. "I live in a historical fact world … whether it’s American, homegrown, Christianity, Islamic, you call it what it is. And we don’t whitewash things, especially here."

Former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, who was mayor at the time of the 2001 attacks, said during a Fox News interview Tuesday that he agrees with Castellucci's assessment, likening a potential removal of the word "Islamic" to taking "mafia" out of textbooks due to its association with Italians.

"My reaction to the Italian mafia was real simple — I’m Italian-American, I’m not embarrassed about them. I don’t belong to them. I want nothing to do with them and they represent the bad part of my ethnic background," he said during a "Fox & Friends" appearance. "Every ethnic background has a bad part."

While Giuliani said that Islam also has this dynamic, he said the "good part of the Islamic religion" shouldn't feel hurt by the term "Islamic terrorism," but should feel anger, seeking to see extremism eradicated; he added that he feels similarly about the mafia and wants to see it "wiped out."

The Owego monument is set to be dedicated Sept. 11, the 15th anniversary of the terror attacks that shocked the nation and the world.

Email: Twitter: billyhallowell Facebook:


Please with your account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Kenneth Jones Sep 16, 10:33 a.m.
    user avatar

    Everyone should have a problem with the official blame going to 19 hijackers. Architects and Engineers for 9/11 truth is a good place to start. WTC 7 is another good place to start. Question everything because the media only questions us.

  • Ken Ackerman Sep 15, 4:25 p.m.
    user avatar

    The statement wouldn't lose any meaning if it just said "Nineteen Terrorists". I know that most Muslims are not like these guys just like most Americans aren't like Timothy McVeigh.

  • Mike Smith Sep 12, 12:15 p.m.
    user avatar

    So you wouldn't object to a monument lamenting McVeigh's "American Terrorism"? I'd find it offensive myself.

  • Chris VanderHaven Sep 11, 9:43 p.m.
    user avatar

    I don't care if they're offended. The 19 hijackers were Islamic extremists. Period. If they were Buddhist, Jewish, Atheist, etc., I still wouldn't care. Their religious fanaticism is an integral part of what drove them to do the act, and thus needs to be mentioned.