@NCCapitol

@NCCapitol

Teen tanning ban passes committee

Posted February 26, 2013

A bill that would ban teens under 18 from using indoor tanning salons passed the House Health Committee Tuesday, but not without more accusations of misinformation on both sides.

House Bill 18 was held up last week after opponents of the ban complained they had not been given time to present their side's arguments. 

The committee heard testimony Tuesday from Pinehurst tanning salon owner Jim Bivens. He said the current requirement for parental consent for teens between 14 and 17 is sufficient regulation.  

"This bill is not doing anything to help small business. It’s doing nothing but hurt it," Bivens said. "This is 25 percent of my business that this takes away." 

With about 2,600 tanning salons in North Carolina, Bivens warned, "If this impacts about 25 percent of our business, that’s about 5,200 employees that are potentially out of work."

"Are we going to run around and stop kids from suntanning when we let 15- and 16-year-olds drive cars at 70 mph?" he asked. "I don’t see where this bill’s going."

The committee also heard again from tanning industry advocate Joseph Levy, who insisted that medical professionals were misleading lawmakers about the data linking tanning to cancer.

House takes up teen tanning ban House takes up teen tanning ban

"There absolutely IS debate about the role – and defining the role – that UV plays in the development of melanoma skin cancer," Levy insisted, citing a 2011 meta-analysis by Norwegian physicist Johan Moan.

Dr. Kelly Nelson of the Duke University Melanoma Center accused Levy of misinforming the committee and misusing research papers "to confuse the issues about this bill."

"Dermatologists and pediatricians and family physicians and oncologists from all over the state ask you to support this legislation," Nelson said. "It’s certainly not to benefit our bottom line. This legislation will hopefully lead to a reduction in business for me."

Rep. Marilyn Avila, R-Wake, was still skeptical. "I find it hard to come down on one side or the other when there is still a question about the validity" of the research, she said.  

"We can ban by law (teens') use of a suntan bed – but you and I both know we’re not going to ban their use of a suntan bed," she said, warning that teens would just turn to tanning beds in private homes or spend more time lying out in the sun.

As for concerns about higher skin cancer risk, Avila said children and teens die every day in car accidents. "Are we going to ban them from riding in automobiles?"  

But Rep. Jim Fulghum, R-Wake, a doctor, said the most recent meta-analysis of UV studies, published in 2012, leaves no doubt about the link between UV exposure and cancer. 

"To not act on recent evidence would be putting our heads in the sand," Fulghum said.

The measure was approved on a voice vote, but it was not unanimous. It now goes to the House Regulatory Reform Committee.

22 Comments

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Oldest First
View all
  • lopo Feb 28, 10:20 a.m.

    Lets see, BLoomberg makes it illegal to buy 2 liter sodas with a pizza, S.F. in calf. makes it illegal to buy meat on Mondays, now this. Why do people want the government in their lives?

  • Proud Black Constitutionalist Feb 27, 4:51 p.m.

    @vinylcarwraps,

    I always paid federal taxes in my 27 years in the army. I guess I paid your taxes too. Well, that's obama's wealth redeistribution plan I guess.

  • Minarchist Feb 27, 4:26 p.m.

    I support this law.....tanning does nothing but harm for most people but it is ironic that its the small gov GOP thats passing it......
    Grand Union
    February 27, 2013 12:32 p.m.
    Report abuse

    LOL thanks for knowing when its best for people to tan. Thank you for saving people from themselves. Now get on the corner and start hading out umbrellas. The SUN is out todday!!! AHHHHH make a law. You can only be out in the sun 2 hours per day. LOL

  • Minarchist Feb 27, 4:25 p.m.

    goldenosprey,

    You'll wish you hadn't said that once obama care is in full fling and you're paying out of the wazoo for below standard healthcare, unless, you're one of the 47%
    Proud Black Conservative
    February 27, 2013 3:44 p.m.
    Report abuse

    Im in the Air FOrce. When I was active how much Fed taxes should I pay? I remember when I was 19 I paid zero Fed taxes and Bush gave me a $300 check. Never heard the word "socialism" then. Odd. He was re-elected. LOL I love the two party sheep.

  • Minarchist Feb 27, 4:23 p.m.

    Where were these liberals when obama slapped a 20% tax on tanning beds to pay for his obama care?
    Proud Black Conservative
    February 27, 2013 2:01 p.m.
    Report abuse

    Your comment has nothing to do with the fact that Republicnas are creating laws to protect people from themselves. Should we put tanning meters on beaches and have cops patrol the meters so people dont sit out in the sun too long? When does it stop? The GOP banned areolas and a shot down a medical plant. LOL a PLANT!!! Maybe you should get off the ideologies and turned towards liberty. This law is BIG gov. Period. Lib this lib that, Cons this Cons that. Divisive people.

  • Proud Black Constitutionalist Feb 27, 3:44 p.m.

    goldenosprey,

    You'll wish you hadn't said that once obama care is in full fling and you're paying out of the wazoo for below standard healthcare, unless, you're one of the 47%

  • goldenosprey Feb 27, 3:14 p.m.

    This progressive was saying 20% was not enough. Skin Cancer costs the rest of us who use sunscreen money when I gotta subsidize The Situation's premiums.

  • Proud Black Constitutionalist Feb 27, 2:01 p.m.

    Where were these liberals when obama slapped a 20% tax on tanning beds to pay for his obama care?

  • goldenosprey Feb 27, 12:48 p.m.

    It's also ironic this legislation is opposed by conservatives who tend to be old and white - the ones most threatened by the sun's rays, and in their minds, anyway, dark skin.

  • Grand Union Feb 27, 12:32 p.m.

    I support this law.....tanning does nothing but harm for most people but it is ironic that its the small gov GOP thats passing it......

More...