Doctors skeptical of study linking flu vaccine and miscarriage
Posted September 13
NEW YORK — A new study is causing concern for pregnant women who have received the flu vaccine or who are considering it.
The study of U.S. pregnancies found that women who had miscarriages between 2010 and 2012 were more likely to have had back-to-back annual flu shots that included protection against swine flu.
According to WRAL's Dr. Allen Mask, the swine flu virus contains DNA material from ducks, and pigs, but is mostly human. People do not get the swine flu from pigs, he said.
Vaccine experts think the results may reflect the older age and other miscarriage risks for the women, and not the flu shots. Miscarriages are more common in women over age 35, Mask said.
Health officials say there is no reason to change the government recommendation that all pregnant women be vaccinated against the flu. They say the flu itself is a much greater danger to women and their fetuses.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has reached out to a doctor's group, the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, to warn them the study is coming out and help them prepare for a potential wave of worry from expectant moms, CDC officials said.
"I want the CDC and researchers to continue to investigate this," said Dr. Laura Riley, a Boston-based obstetrician who leads a committee on maternal immunization. "But as an advocate for pregnant women, what I hope doesn't happen is that people panic and stop getting vaccinated."
Riley points out that the average OB-GYN doctor does not read Vaccine, the journal where the study appeared, and she, along with many of her colleagues, remain skeptical of the results.
Past studies have found flu vaccines are safe during pregnancy, though there's been little research on impact of flu vaccinations given in the first three months of pregnancy.
The U.S. Advisory Committee on Immunizations Practices recommends that women in all stages of pregnancy get a flu shot. Pregnant women are at high risk for complications of the flu, particularly those in the second and third trimester and those who have just given birth.
Flu and its complications kill thousands of Americans every year. The elderly, young children and pregnant women are especially at risk. When a new "swine flu" strain emerged in 2009, it killed 56 U.S. pregnant women that year, according to the CDC.
The study's authors, two of whom are CDC researchers, saw a big difference when they looked at women who had miscarried within 28 days of getting a shot that included protection against swine flu, but it was only when the women also had had a flu shot the previous season.
They found 17 of 485 miscarriages they studied involved women whose vaccinations followed that pattern. Just four of a comparable 485 healthy pregnancies involved women who were vaccinated that way.
The first group also had more women who were at higher risk for miscarriage, like older moms and smokers and those with diabetes. The researchers tried to make statistical adjustments to level out some of those differences but some researchers don't think they completely succeeded.
Mask noted the results stem from an observational study that studied the medical records of women who had miscarried but observational studies cannot prove that something, like a flu shot, caused something else, like a miscarriage.
Chromosomal abnormalities account for about 50 percent of all miscarriages, Mask said.
Mask said the authors of the study are not clear about whether the findings are real or the product of an unobserved statistical fluke.
Other experts said they don't believe a shot made from killed flu virus could trigger an immune system response severe enough to prompt a miscarriage. And the authors said they couldn't rule out the possibility that exposure to swine flu itself was a factor in some miscarriages.
Two other medical journals rejected the article before a third, Vaccine, accepted it. Dr. Gregory Poland, Vaccine's editor-in-chief, said it was a well-designed study that raised a question that shouldn't be ignored. But he doesn't believe flu shots caused the miscarriages. "Not at all," said Poland, who also is director of vaccine research at the Mayo Clinic.
Though this study may cause worry and confusion, it is evidence "of just how rigorous and principled our vaccine safety monitoring system is," said Jason Schwartz, a Yale University vaccine policy expert.
Some of the same researchers are working on a larger study looking at more recent data to see if a possible link between swine flu vaccine and miscarriage holds up, said James Donahue, a study author from the Wisconsin-based Marshfield Clinic Research Institute. The results aren't expected until next year at the earliest, he said.
This story has been corrected to say that Marshfield Clinic Research Institute is based in Wisconsin.