State seeks delay in court order to redraw NC congressional maps

Posted February 8, 2016

— North Carolina lawmakers and the State Board of Elections on Monday filed emergency requests for a stay with a panel of three federal judges who have ordered the state to redraw its congressional districts because two are unconstitutional.

The judges late Friday ordered lawmakers to redraw the maps by Feb. 19 and not to hold any elections for U.S. House until new maps were approved and in place.

Elections officials and lawmakers both said the order jeopardizes the March 15 primary, noting that mail-in absentee voting is already underway.

"We trust the federal trial court was not aware an election was already underway and surely did not intend to throw our state into chaos by nullifying ballots that have already been sent out and votes that have already been cast," Sen. Bob Rucho, R-Mecklenburg, and Rep. David Lewis, R-Harnett, said in a statement. "We hope the court will realize the serious and far-reaching ramifications of its unprecedented, eleventh-hour action and immediately issue a stay."

More than 8,600 absentee ballots have already been sent out statewide, and about 430 have already been filled out and sent back, according to the State Board of Elections.

"While we don’t weigh into the politics of the redistricting lines as an agency, we make sure that these court orders are enforced, and (the judges) need to know the logistics behind that," said Josh Lawson, general counsel to the elections board, noting that 3.7 million ballots have been printed and that voter guides have been mailed to people statewide.

"The pressures that we have are not made up. They are real, live democracy questions," Lawson said. "This is kind of democracy in real time, needing to make sure that we have everything ready for elections that, in fact, have already started."

The three-judge panel ruled that the 1st Congressional District, which spreads like an octopus across northeast North Carolina and has a tentacle that dips into Durham County, and the 12th Congressional District, which snakes along Interstate 85 between Greensboro and Charlotte, were drawn by the Republican-led General Assembly in 2011 so that the majority of voters in each were black.

G.K. Butterfield, the Democratic incumbent in the 1st District, is running unopposed until November, but Democratic 12th District Congresswoman Alma Adams faces two primary challengers.

Butterfield said he doesn't believe a stay should be granted, noting that lawmakers were aware that courts have ruled that states cannot draw voting districts to include or exclude people because of their race.

"The legislature knew this, and they assumed the risk of packing black voters into these districts, and now they’ve got to be held to account for it," he said, adding that candidates "should not be required to run in a district that is unconstitutional."

Lawmakers have maintained that the maps were drawn for Republican advantage and that race wasn't a driving factor, but the judges didn't buy that argument. Evidence showed that the partisan claim "was more of an afterthought than a clear objective," they wrote in their ruling.

"It’s very, very frustrating to get a decision saying, 'You did it wrong' without actually saying, 'Here’s what you did wrong,'" said Lewis, who oversaw the General Assembly's redistricting process along with Rucho.

The North Carolina Supreme Court has twice approved the congressional and legislative maps, ruling against voters and groups such as the NAACP that complained black voters were packed into a select number of districts.

Lewis said he believes lawmakers could meet the Feb. 19 deadline for the new maps if required to do so.

"It is very difficult to redraw these maps. We have the one person, one vote [rule]. We have other considerations," he said. "So, I do think it’s not an easy process by any means, but I do think it is possible to redraw the maps and be ready for the House and Senate to consider them next week."

Gov. Pat McCrory would have to call a special legislative session to approve the new maps, and a special primary would have to be held this summer to select nominees for U.S. House for the November election. The extra primary would cost the state about $9.5 million, and Lewis said it would come at the cost of confused voters as well.

"Do they vote? Do they not vote? This has really created a very difficult situation for the citizens of this state, and it's extremely unfortunate," he said.

Despite lingering questions about the congressional primaries, Lawson of the state elections board urged people casting absentee ballots to go ahead and vote in those races.

"If you have a ballot, vote your full ballot. Let the State Board of Elections worry about the legal consequence of that, whether that actually will count in those congressional races," he said. "We don’t want people self-censoring. We don’t want people to assume that theirs will be among the lines redrawn, because that may not be the case."

Read the ruling


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Larry Price Feb 9, 2016
    user avatar

    doubt they'll have much luck. The same thing recently came up in the 3rd and 4th districts of Virginia, which appear to be less gerrymandered than these two.
    They didn't get anywhere with their stay requests at the federal level.

  • Robert Hartley Feb 9, 2016
    user avatar

    They knew it was wrong when they made it. They took a risk of not getting caught and guess what, ya got caught.

    Now fix it and spend some more of our money that you claim to want to keep in our pockets by reducing everyone's taxes but the bottom half.

  • Fanny Chmelar Feb 8, 2016
    user avatar

    "We broke the law by gerrymandering the districts but, hey, can we just get through one more election and then fix it?"

    Pffft. Embarrassing and pathetic.