Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

1:20 a.m. • 6-18-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 82° F
  • Wed: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 82° F
  • Thu: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 83° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image
@NCCapitol
Dianna Lightfoot (SOURCE: Facebook)
print friendly

State's new Pre-K chief opposes pre-K

Published: 2013-02-06 14:31:00
Updated: 2013-02-06 18:16:36

Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Aldona Wos announced Tuesday that Dianna Lightfoot has been appointed the state's new director of Child Development and Early Education.  

The Division of Child Development and Early Education, or DCDEE, oversees the state's child-care program as well as NC Pre-K, which was moved into Health and Human Services from the Department of Public Instruction last session. 

From the DHHS news release:

"Ms. Lightfoot is a strategic and tactical top tier policy executive with extensive healthcare, child welfare and education expertise,” said Secretary Wos. "Her leadership will ensure we meet the State’s longstanding commitment to protect and serve our young children.”

Lightfoot has served as president of the National Physicians Center, a non-partisan, non-profit organization that supports and promotes healthcare public policies and education, a post she has held since 2001. ... She holds a master’s degree in psychology and community relations, a counseling license and a secondary teaching credential.

The National Physicians Center for Family Resources, which Lightfoot founded in 2001, advocates against "institutional" preschool programs.

"In the case of early childhood education programs, available research suggests they may actually be inferior to early learning opportunities at home. In addition, it appears the demand for out of home childcare is not as prevalent as many advocates claim," says an open letter signed by Lightfoot on the group's website.

The letter also warns that "There is great potential for early learning institutions to foster more dependency on the government (i.e. taxpayer) and more of an entitlement mentality." 

"Will institutions focus on character building and teaching strong values? If so, whose values will children be taught?" it asks.

The North Carolina Democratic Party immediately criticized the move, noting the state was a national pioneer in early childhood education.

"For Gov. McCrory, who stated his support for Pre-K during the campaign, and Secretary Wos to appoint someone who actively advocates against Pre-K, who believes that educating our children will result in 'an entitlement mentality,' demonstrates a total lack of respect for the educational process and a willingness to sacrifice North Carolina’s future a political goal,” Democratic spokesman Clay Pittman said in a statement.

Before 2001, Lightfoot served in executive positions at conservative think tanks in South Carolina and Alabama.  

She starts work at DHHS next Monday at an annual salary of $110,000.

"When she comes to work here Feb. 11, she'll be working for the secretary, and they both work for the governor," DHHS spokeswoman Julie Henry said when asked about  Lightfoot's potential conflict of interest.

Henry said Lightfoot has resigned from the National Physicians Center and suggested that she may have changed her views, but she couldn't say whether the new director now supports public preschool.

Lightfoot has not yet responded to interview requests.

Read More Posts from this Blog

38 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.


page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

They are playing with fire and if they keep pushing these folks are going to cause all hell to break out.

Kiwileex3 - did you "notice" that her "research" includes quoting a poll done by Glamour magazine? Yeah, really scientific.

It just keeps getting better and better. The inmates now have total control of the asylum.

Did anyone *notice* that Secretary Wos is a PHYSICIAN which means she had years of education in the subject.. including a MASTER'S in PSYCHOLOGY (which includes child development)? Don't you think she would know what is important during a child's development better than you random clowns? I'm sure she has plenty of research backing up her opinions. I'm also pretty sure her opinion is that your mother/family/community should be teaching you "(1) social development, (2) physical development, (3) emotional development, and (4) cognitive development" (wikipedia) instead of an institution that you have no role in, and I couldn't agree more.

Don't forget the DCDEE is the same agency that allows its staff to decide whether a child is "at risk" ("other factors as determined by the caseworker"). Let's see, if the program goes under they'll be out of a job too. Talk about a conflict of interest!

"...to appoint someone who actively advocates against Pre-K, who believes that educating our children will result in 'an entitlement mentality,' demonstrates a total lack of respect ..."

Read that rant again carefully. Pre-k, all by itself, is suddenly equal to "educating our children"! Because she doesn't agree with pre-k, she's against educating children, PERIOD. Who's the extremist here?

How can someone who is opposed to early education run the Division of Child Development and Early Education? How ridiculous! I'm afraid to see where NC schools are headed... I'm not sure it's in a positive direction.

What I have read about Ms. Lightfoot is disturbing as it appears that she is very much in the dark about the benefits of early childhood education, especially for low income and at risk children. However, being a fair-minded person, I am willing to listen and learn from what she has to say and do in the months ahead. I am hopeful that she, too, knowledgeable, open-minded and will seek valid information in the area of early brain development, early learning experiences, and how all combined have a tremendous impact on a child's success in school, liklihood of graduating from high school and seeking higher education, and becoming productive citizens in the future. As an educator, a mother, and grandparent, one only has to observe a child from birth to age five to see clearly that the formative years are the early years, time in which a child's foundation for future success is established.

U.S. students are number one after elementary school. They fall back on performance after middle and high school. There isn't much reason to "fix" something that is working fine when you have other broken pieces of the machine.

Preschool is not free daycare! It is bad enough North Carolina is 49th in the country for education, politicians want to make it worse. Children need Preschool in order to be ready for kindergarten in this century! These wonderful teachers work really hard to prepare children for kindergarten and on! It is time for North Carolina to make our children and their education a Priority!

Thanks for sharing this cooldaddy. This is getting worse and worse...

"It should be pointed out that the organization that Lightfoot has been a leader of, the National Physicians Center for Family Resources Inc, has been involved in promotion of "ex-gay therapies", disseminating disinformation about homosexuality in the US against gay marriage, and involvement in getting anti-gay death penalty laws passed in Uganda. It is a religious advocacy group promoting a specific agenda using flawed and biased research to support its extremist views. This goes beyond a "conflict of interest" and raises questions about her qualifications to serve in a position of authority in a state agency."

How can someone that is opposed to early education actually be appointed to run a Department on Early Education? This is completely crazy. McCrory needs to think about the choices that Wos is making...

Many years of research have shown the benefit of early childhood education. This is a giant step backwards.

Well I am sad to say that I am not surprised by the absolute about face on this issue by McCrory from what he said during the campaign. I don't know why anyone believed a word he was saying.

@Morrigan- No one stays in poverty because they don't want to get out of it. Seriously, do you believe the poor are living the good life and want to protect their right to be poor? I guess that's why more lottery tickets are bought by the poor than the wealthy because they don't want to get rich? Please try to say things that make sense.

All current, valid data shows that early education pays off especially for the economically disadvantaged. Ms. Lightfoot is a documented conservative ideologue who has taken a public stand against early education...it is obvious that our new governor wants to pay for his campaign donors' pet projects by gutting programs that benefit those in the most need. The unemployed, disadvantaged children, the disabled and those who need affordable health insurance.

It should be pointed out that the organization that Lightfoot has been a leader of, the National Physicians Center for Family Resources Inc, has been involved in promotion of "ex-gay therapies", disseminating disinformation about homosexuality in the US against gay marriage, and involvement in getting anti-gay death penalty laws passed in Uganda. It is a religious advocacy group promoting a specific agenda using flawed and biased research to support its extremist views. This goes beyond a "conflict of interest" and raises questions about her qualifications to serve in a position of authority in a state agency.

"The way for the kids to get out of the cycle of poverty is education,"

"They have to WANT to get out of it, and they don't. Hasn't history proved that?"

What an ignorant statement!! Does an infant or toddler or pre-K child KNOW they want to stay in poverty???? Have you considered that at some point the cycle of poverty has to be broken and that by giving EVERY child a level playing field when they enter kindergarten is a HUGE step towards breaking that cycle?? You need to do some research on brain development in infants and young children. You might be amazed at what research has shown us about the infant brain. For this woman to say waiting till a child is in first grade to start remediation, etc shows how ignorant she is. This appointment is a slap in the face to the young children of NC and their futures. (She is also a Tea Party favorite, so that should tell you something about her.). How she could be appointed to oversee work that she doesn't believe in is beyond the pale.

If you have to work 2 jobs and don't have the time to spend with your pre-school aged children, then maybe you shouldn't have had them. I believe in a hand-up system that helps people going through a rough time...not a hand-out system that supports all the bad choices that people make in life.

"How exactly is Ms. Lighfoot expected to promote and direct early education..."

Maybe she's going to abolish it. Your free day care is ending!

GOOD! Maybe this will be a step towards people having only those children that they're prepared to make sacrifices for.

"The way for the kids to get out of the cycle of poverty is education,"

They have to WANT to get out of it, and they don't. Hasn't history proved that?

"The North Carolina Democratic Party immediately criticized the move, noting the state was a national pioneer in early childhood education."

Does that mean they can mess it up without consequence?

@babbleon - I am a full time working mother and also a part time student. I don't have a ton of time either. But I still don't feel that it is the governments place to pay for our children to get an early education. If they feel school should start at 3 then maybe they should change the law to add 2 more grades.

NC takes another step backwards under Republican Tea Party leadership. What a surprise.

This should prove interesting, considering the expectations placed on children as soon as they enter kindergarten. For kids who haven't been exposed to a structured preschool environment (from a social AND educational standpoint), losing pre-k programs may be most detrimental to their kindergarten classmates and teachers/teachers assistants.

Each dollar put into early childhood education saves taxpayers $4 to $11 down the road. We should be expanding it.

@BaseBallMommy: Some parents don't have the time and money to teach their kids at home. It's hard to read to your kid every night when you're working two jobs to pay rent.

The way for the kids to get out of the cycle of poverty is education, and with the changes we've made to the curriculum, that education needs to start before kindergarten.

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/wellness/story/2011/02/Early-childhood-education-benefits-both-kids-taxpayers-study-says/43259964/1

Ms. Leslie, first let me say thank you for commenting on MS. Lightfoot's "apparent potential conflict of interest". Secondly, I read the letter on the NPC website and was very saddened by Ms. Lightfoot's outlook and opinion of ECE; as well as her reference to completely outdated research data and later use of non-scientific/research based opinions stated as facts instead of using current peer-reviewed research findings and/or should have listed the appropriate cites for all of these. How exactly is Ms. Lighfoot expected to promote and direct early education when she doesn't believe in early education as stated in the letter "Reform should start with the age groups in which children are more physically and emotionally mature, and therefore, ready to absorb and retain what they are taught (i.e. grades 1-12)" -basically 6 years and up? (http://www.physicianscenter.org/v1/positions_education-wk.php)

Great to hear. Maybe she will show everyone that preschool is not necessary for one to do well in school. Also, that it is not the Governments responsibility to provide that svhooling until the child is of the age to enter the school system for kindegarten! Good Luck to her!!

Oh, no. Surely this is just a bad joke.

page 1 | 2
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Political Video Picks

 
  • The state House will take up bills eliminating tax checkoff funding for political parties.

  • Former Gov. Jim Holshouser, who died early Monday, was hailed by North Carolina politicians as a decent man who bridged partisan…

  • The North Carolina Chapter of the NAACP gathers for Moral Monday protests on June 17. Chapter president the Rev. William Barber says…

  • President Barack Obama's approval rating dropped 8 percentage points over the last month, and for the first time in his presidency…

  • Who and what is behind the protests at the state legislature, and is anybody listening?

  • U.S. Senator Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) today delivers the Weekly Republican Address, assuring Americans that Senate Republicans "will…