Local News

State considers allowing electronics back in landfills

Posted June 20
Updated June 21

Map Marker  Find News Near Me

— In a consumable world, many towns, counties and states encourages residents and businesses to reduce waste and recycle as much as possible. Even state law contributes to the cause in North Carolina. Under current law, televisions, computers, basically anything with a screen is banned from landfills, but a bill being considered in the state legislature could reverse that ban.

The change could add up for the Town of Cary, where electronics factor into a goal that 40 percent of waste be recycled.

"We get a lot of electronics," said Joe Stewart. "People drop it and break it. Young'uns might knock it over, throw a ball and hit it."

Stewart collects recyclables for Cary and estimates the town fills a 40-yard bin with old electronics each week. That works out to about 220 tons each year.

"We got into this about three years ago. We didn't know what we aware getting into really," Stewart said.

In 2010, lawmakers voted to ban televisions, computers and other electronics from landfills in North Carolina and set up an electronics recycling program, funded by television and computer manufacturers through annual fees and contracts with recyclers to accept their products.

Sen. Trudy Wade, R-Guilford, a longtime opponent of the program, counted the cost of recycling among her arguments against the ban.

"There's no money in it," Wade told the Senate Commerce Committee.

"If recycling ever comes back and there’s a profit to be made, we can always change the law and go back to recycling," she said. "But right now, we have a bigger problem with them being abandoned and the possibility of having some kind of contamination because we don’t have anywhere to put them."

Wade claimed that in rural areas, where no official recycling programs exist, people dispose of electronics by throwing them in the woods or ditches.

For awhile, Cary made money off the recycling of electronics, but in recent years they've had to pay a vendor to take the items. It's all part of the ebb and flow of the recycling economy.

"We've seen an increase, especially the last three or four years now," said Cary Solid Waste Manager Bob Holden.

Abdel Barakat, owner of a Raleigh shop called Undead Electronics, attributes the growing pile of electronics to the quality of the products.

"You get a DVD player or a Blueray player, it might work for a year, it might work for a couple of months. You know it's a disposable item. It's not like they used to make them," he said.

Stewart says no matter what happens at the legislature, one thing just makes perfect sense to him.

"I hope they keep recycling," he said. "It's better than going to a landfill."

The State Senate has passed the bill. The regulatory reduction measure, House Bill 169, is under consideration in the House.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Matt Nickeson Jun 21, 2:18 p.m.
    user avatar

    If you have ever lived outside of the Raleigh area you would know that recycling centers are essentially nonexistent. Since it is illegal to throw electronics devices into the trash people end up dumping them in the woods and uncontrolled landfills. The question is whether it is better to contain the heavy metals in electronics in landfills or disposed of elsewhere with no protections. I see nothing in this that would force municipalities from continuing to collect electronics for recycling. Oh, and name calling is very childish and not conducive to an actual debate and exchange of ideas.

  • Tripp Weiland Jun 21, 9:17 a.m.
    user avatar

    What does making a profit have to do with keeping arsenic, lead and cadmium out of landfills. Ok I am sure it was nice to have the program pay for itself or make a profit but contaminating the drinking water or other environmental damage will cost a lot more than recycling electronics. Ask Flint MI.


  • Bobby Lee Jimmy Billy Jun 20, 6:15 p.m.
    user avatar

    I don't see any money in Sen. Trudy Wade either.

  • Jim Frei Jun 20, 6:05 p.m.
    user avatar

    Not a smart move. And since its coming from Trudy "I hate the environment" Wade, you know its a bad idea to put electronics into landfills.