Bob Holliday: Women's Home-Court Advantage Not Right
In 1989, the NCAA decided its Women's Basketball Championship should follow the same rules as the Men's Championship.
The NCAA kicked local television cameras out of all venues and passed along the same stringent requirements for media coverage as written for the men. To be eligible, media outlets must cover 90 percent of a school's games and staff all tournament rounds in order to be eligible to cover the Final Four.
The NCAA made certain its women's tournament adhere to the procedures prescribed for the men's tournament in other areas: expansion to 64 teams; seeding based on wins and strength of schedule; and using the pod system to minimize travel.
There remains one major difference between the men's championship and the women's championship: men's teams cannot play on their home court; women's teams can.
Monday night, North Carolina, the top-seeded team in the entire tournament, had to play Vanderbilt on its home court. Top seeds are supposed to be protected in terms of travel and playing sites, but the Tar Heels went up against a No. 8 seed that enjoyed a home-court advantage. Imagine the hue and cry if No. 1 Connecticut had had to play No. 8 Kentucky in Lexington during the men's championship!
The NCAA is, of course, concerned about attendance. It fears that if the Vanderbilts and Old Dominions couldn't play in the tournament games they host, not enough fans would come to the games. But with the increasing parity in women's basketball, one of these years a top seed is going to lose to a lower seeded team playing at home.
The NCAA should place fairness above money and abolish this practice.
Or, the NCAA could stop paying lip service to the notion that its policies must be uniformly applied. For example, if the NCAA relaxed the media requirements, the Women's Championship might get better coverage-which might help attendance.
The NCAA kicked local television cameras out of all venues and passed along the same stringent requirements for media coverage as written for the men. To be eligible, media outlets must cover 90 percent of a school's games and staff all tournament rounds in order to be eligible to cover the Final Four.
The NCAA made certain its women's tournament adhere to the procedures prescribed for the men's tournament in other areas: expansion to 64 teams; seeding based on wins and strength of schedule; and using the pod system to minimize travel.
There remains one major difference between the men's championship and the women's championship: men's teams cannot play on their home court; women's teams can.
Monday night, North Carolina, the top-seeded team in the entire tournament, had to play Vanderbilt on its home court. Top seeds are supposed to be protected in terms of travel and playing sites, but the Tar Heels went up against a No. 8 seed that enjoyed a home-court advantage. Imagine the hue and cry if No. 1 Connecticut had had to play No. 8 Kentucky in Lexington during the men's championship!
The NCAA is, of course, concerned about attendance. It fears that if the Vanderbilts and Old Dominions couldn't play in the tournament games they host, not enough fans would come to the games. But with the increasing parity in women's basketball, one of these years a top seed is going to lose to a lower seeded team playing at home.
The NCAA should place fairness above money and abolish this practice.
Or, the NCAA could stop paying lip service to the notion that its policies must be uniformly applied. For example, if the NCAA relaxed the media requirements, the Women's Championship might get better coverage-which might help attendance.
- Devils and Heels are on a collision course Posted: March 1, 2009
- The Heels have a week to stew over this one Posted: February 22, 2009
- Mid-week musings Posted: February 17, 2009
0 Comments
Featured Blogposts
American Idol and Garner native Scotty McCreery performs at N.C. State's Hoops 4 Hope. The circus is in town. And Olympic-level table tennis stops in Cary. Here's what's happening this weekend.
- What's on Tap
Charity events planned around Hoops 4 HopeThe Hillsborough Street Community Service Corporation is sponsoring Play 4Kay events on Hillsborough Street starting Feb. 8 to support Hoops 4 Hope and the Kay Yow Cancer Fund.
- WRAL SmartShopper
Love for Less: frugal Valentine's Day tipsShowering your loved ones with goodies is always fun to do on Valentine's Day, but not if it leaves you drowning in debt! With a little planning and creativity, you can show your loved ones you care and stay within your budget.
Other Recent Blogposts
- WRAL WeatherCenter Blog: Space travel has own traditions and supersitions
- WRAL WeatherCenter Blog: What happened to Pluto
- WRAL WeatherCenter Blog: The winter so far at RDU
- Brian Shrader's Siteseeing Blog: What's trending: Antelope shoes and ping-pong baby
- Brian Shrader's Siteseeing Blog: How cereal box designs have changed
Click to See All CONTESTS available from WRAL.com
Special savings on contacts at Eye Care Associates






WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.
This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.