Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

6:14 a.m. • 5-21-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 82° F
  • Wed: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 84° F
  • Thu: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 80° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image

Published: 2011-05-06 18:21:00
Updated: 2011-06-02 19:22:44

Brad Cooper was framed, defense attorney says


Howard Kurtz
Howard Kurtz
print friendly

One of two defense attorneys for Brad Cooper said Friday that he firmly believes his client was framed and that he believes there is a strong chance to win an appeal on Thursday's first-degree murder conviction.

Cooper, 37, was arrested in October 2008, more than three months after his wife, Nancy Cooper, was found strangled to death 3 miles from their Cary home.

Evidence presented during the eight weeks of testimony was mostly circumstantial, with the exception of a Google Maps search that, defense attorney Howard Kurtz says, was the only piece of evidence that prosecutors had that linked Brad Cooper to the crime.

"Their case was exclusively based on this one map, and the map, in and of itself, bears several different neon signs that point ‘tampering here’ that were very difficult to find, mind you, but once found were very easy to see," he said.

The state argued that three days before Nancy Cooper’s decomposing body was found in an unfinished subdivision, Brad Cooper used his work laptop to search for the same site. Brad Cooper has said his wife went jogging and never returned home.

"There was information planted on the computer. Now, I cannot say by whom, but I can say that the files were placed on the machine," Kurtz said. "I think we can prove beyond any doubt that's what happened."

Kurtz said anyone who came into contact with the computer could have tampered with it.

"That would include all of the police," he said. "That's the first group of people who could do it, but it's not limited to the police by any means, and I'm not saying the Cary Police Department did that."

"Beyond the police, any neighbors that were living in the wireless range could easily have the capability to alter files on the computer," he added.

Jurors were never allowed to see the evidence to prove the tampering, Kurtz said, because Superior Court Judge Paul Gessner ruled that the defense's expert witness wasn't qualified in computer forensics.

A second defense expert wasn't allowed to testify, partly because prosecutors said timing didn't allow for them to prepare for adequate cross-examination.

"There was no other evidence that I heard in that courtroom that was persuasive in any way, shape or form. I think that is the only piece of evidence that (the jury) could have chosen to make a decision based upon," Kurtz said. "To me, it was devastating that we were unable to address it."

Kurt said he does not believe Gessner understood the technology being presented.

"I think when technology becomes so central to a case, as this one, we should actually have judges who are trained and who understand the intricacies of the technology they're going to be making life-altering decisions over," he said.

Cary Police Chief Pat Bazemore couldn't be reached for comment after Kurtz's interview Friday, but in an interview earlier in the day, she defended her detectives' work based on Kurtz's claims during the trial that it was dishonest and inept.

Mistakes were made, Bazemore said, but "we learn from them, and we move on."

"But there's never been a question about our detectives' integrity and their ability to investigate this case," she said.

Cooper, meanwhile, is at Central Prison in Raleigh, where he'll stay as he undergoes a diagnostic and admission process into the state prison system.

"He accepted what he heard in the courtroom," Kurtz said. "I believe he understands that the appellate process is just beginning, and I think we have a tremendously good chance at appeal."


707 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

View Comments VIEW ALL 707 COMMENTS

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Latest Comments
Will Wake county DA Colon Willoughby be the first DA in the state to have two murder convictions overturned by the Innocence Commission. Will Cary become the first town in the state to have two innocent men have their life sentences overturned by the Innocence Commission.

Willoughby was in the courtroom along with Cummings. Maybe Gessner whined that it wasn't it his fault and blamed it on the defense and prosecutors not having their act together. Maybe Stephens and others thought Gessner handled the case inappropriately.

We, the people and citizens of the USA..have a right to answers on this trial...dollibug

I agree with dollibug..The jury represents the public does it not? The American Justice system is built on that if we are accussed of a crime we are to be tried before a jury of our peers?? So if these jurors in BC's case represent the public as his jury of peers, then yes we the public deserve to know why they found him guilty! They speak for us, so I disagree with the judge when he says they do not owe anybody an explanation. Especially in this case where it was streamed Live and videos were avaiable for all. So we all had access to view what they viewed except when the cameras had to be turned off. We heard and we saw what they saw, and a large portion of the public does not agree with the verdict they came to and we do not understand how the convicted him when there was so much reasonable doubt in this case!

@ compressed air111 - if you got priveledges revoked how are you getting through to moderator.. I was just curious? someone may have reported abuse on you don't know ,, I have seen nothing you have said out of the way.

on the Young case someone must have taken control for the judge to make comments like he is not gonna be putting up with no junk on this trial. So we do know that the upper hand seen what went wrong on the cooper trial but what are they going to do about it now??

View Comments VIEW ALL 707 COMMENTS

Latest Videos

 
  • The North Carolina Court of Appeals heard oral arguments for about an hour Tuesday morning in the high-profile case of Brad Cooper,…

  • WRAL News reports on the lengthy first-degree murder trial of Brad Cooper and some of the issues arising from the case.

  • Superior Court Judge Paul Gessner reads the verdict of the jury on May 5, 2011, in the first-degree murder trial of Brad Cooper.

  • Richard McGough, a private investigator for the defense, testifies he didn't see Nancy Cooper wearing a diamond pendant necklace in…

  • Brad Cooper's mother, Carol Cooper, testifies April 27, 2011, that she was watching the news on Oct. 27, 2008, and heard that her son…

  • Prosecutor Howard Cummings questions Brad Cooper's mother, Carol Cooper, on April 27, 2011, about some wooden ducks from the Cooper…

  • Lead detective George Daniels testifies April 15, 2011, that he saw red marks on Brad Cooper's neck, but that he didn't photograph…

  • Lead detective George Daniels testifies April 15, 2011, that Brad had the "motive, means and opportunity" to set up calls and make it…

  • Lead detective George Daniels testifies April 15, 2011, that he believes anger and pent-up aggression were the motives behind Nancy…

  • Lead investigator George Daniels said Brad Cooper looked like he was trying to cry following the news that his wife had been found…

  • Family members cry April 7, 2011, as they sit in court and listen to a 2008 voicemail from Nancy Cooper.

  • Nancy Cooper's twin sister, Krista Lister, testifies April 5, 2011, that she was angry that Nancy met a man in Florida and was…

  • Krista Lister, Nancy Cooper's twin sister, recalls a conversation with Brad Cooper following her sister's disappearance.

  • Hannah Prichard said she told her friend, Nancy Cooper, that Brad Cooper "was crazy."

  • Hannah Prichard testified March 31, 2011, that Nancy Cooper found some "very disturbing" lists that Brad had written.

  • A Cary man accused of strangling his wife and dumping her body in an unfinished housing development nearly three years ago was found…

  • Reaction from the family of Nancy Cooper to the first-degree murder verdict in the trial of Brad Cooper.

  • Reaction from the Wake County District Attorney's Office to the first-degree murder verdict in the trial of Brad Cooper. (Audio…

  • Mike Hiller testifies April 27, 2011, that he read Nancy Cooper’s autopsy report six times and posted theories about her murder on…

  • Mike Hiller testifies April 27, 2011, in the Brad Cooper murder trial that he talked with Jessica Adam outside the Coopers' house on…

  • A man who says he had an affair with Nancy Cooper testified Tuesday as part of defense attorneys' attempts to discredit Cary police.

  • The lead detective investigating Nancy Cooper's July 12, 2008, death took the stand late Thursday in the first-degree murder trial of…

  • Lead investigator George Daniels said he saw markings on Brad Cooper's neck when he met with him shortly after his wife went missing.…

  • Lead investigator George Daniels said Brad Cooper would not give consent for authorities to search his home and asked if he was a…

  • Nancy Cooper's friend, Theresa Hackeling, testifies April 5, 2011, that Nancy slept in jeans with keys in her pocket, daughters…

  • Krista Lister, Nancy Cooper's twin sister, describes a fight between her sister and husband Brad Cooper as they prepared their home…

  • Krista Lister, Nancy Cooper's twin sister, said plans for her sister to leave husband Brad Cooper changed after he saw a copy of the…

  • Superior Court Judge Paul Gessner on March 25 reminds jurors of rules that prohibit them from talking about the Brad Cooper murder…