Local Politics

Raleigh firefighters fuming over changes to city time-off policies

Posted September 14
Updated September 15

— After Raleigh firefighters criticized cuts to the time off they earn for vacation and sick leave, a city panel recommended Thursday to undo recent changes to leave policies for city workers.

The City Council last week approved without debate changes to various employment policies, from job classifications to performance reviews to paid leave, that officials said was part of the two-year overhaul of the pay structure for Raleigh city workers.

But firefighters argued the changes were in retaliation for their months of public lobbying for raises, which they say embarrassed city officials.

"It is obvious that the majority of this council, led by Mayor (Nancy) McFarlane, does not care about public safety employees and are specifically targeting us and punishing us for blemishing their image over the past year," Nick Rhodes, a spokesman for the Raleigh Professional Firefighters Association, said in a Facebook post.

The City Council raised starting salaries for firefighters from $33,654 to $39,200 this year, which officials said is the highest starting salary in any municipality in the Triangle. Veteran firefighters also received a pay boost in the city budget.

Rhodes said firefighters felt blindsided by the changes to leave policies.

"We never knew this was on the table or that it was being looked at," he said Thursday. "It feels like we were betrayed. It feels like they gave with one hand and took from the other. They're trying to put out this perception to the public that we're getting huge pay raises, but at the same time, they're taking benefits away from us."

Robert Harris, president of the local chapter of the Police Benevolent Association, agreed.

"People join city government job for the benefits. These benefit cuts affect everyone from the top down in every department within the city," Harris said in a statement. "It is very disappointing that the city would try and take away from the people who give everything to this city. We miss holidays, birthdays and many other important family events while serving the city."

The changes include eliminating years of service when calculating how much vacation time firefighters earn each month. Under the new policy, every firefighter gets 12 hours off per month worked, but Rhodes notes that firefighters work 24-hour shifts, so they have to use two vacation days to get a day off.

Firefighters get only eight hours of pay for holidays, and if they have to work both the actual holiday and the city's designated day off – if Christmas is on a Saturday or Sunday, for example, the city will designate a weekday to close its offices – they will get bonus pay for only one of the two and regular pay for the other.

Rhodes also noted that many firefighters work part-time jobs when off duty to make ends meet, and Raleigh's new policies prevent them from using city sick leave if they get hurt or sick on their second jobs.

Councilman David Cox said he didn't understand the impact of the changes when he voted for them.

"We're all only human, so when something like this happens, we have to take a step back, take a deep breath, go over it and fix it," said Cox , who personally visited 12 fire stations around Raleigh over the past week to listen to firefighters' concerns.

"My position is that I'm not taking benefits away from anybody," he said. "We need to have a more public discussion about these things rather than treat it as a business-as-usual item."

Raleigh spokesman John Boyette said the policy changes "were intended to address some inconsistencies we have across our organization" from the compensation system overhaul.

City Councilwoman Mary-Ann Baldwin was among those who support the changes. She said they were vetted for two years.

"I think it's a good plan. I think it's a great plan," Baldwin said. "I think it's a very generous plan, and I think it's very fair. Are there some tweaks that needed to be made? Yes."

McFarlane said the firefighters' criticisms were because of "misinterpretation."

"A lot of it is confusion, but we're checking on everything. We've heard all the concerns," she said, adding that city staffers will publicly explain the new policies during next Tuesday's City Council meeting.

But Raleigh's Civil Service Commission on Thursday recommended that the council restore many of the leave benefits to city workers.

"I think it would be a strong recommendation, at least from me, that they take a hard look at this before they rescind any of the benefits from police or firefighters," said Rick Armstrong, a member of the Civil Service Commission and vice president of Teamsters Local 391, which represents the Raleigh Police Protective Association.

11 Comments

Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Teddy Fowler Sep 15, 2:23 p.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    Partially true... but you left off the fact that they are regularly scheduled off for 4 straight days which allows them to often work other jobs... or take many 4 day "weekends" off regularly... there is a definite benefit to having more days off than most people and they don't even have to use vacation most of the time...

  • Kelly Thornburg Sep 15, 1:06 p.m.
    user avatar

    For those saying they should get the same holidays, vacation days and sick days as other COR employees -- it is apples and oranges. They do not work a standard 8 hour weekday. Each shift is 24 hours. A "day off" for them would mean using 24 hours of accrued time versus 8 hours for a M-F 8 hour employee, hardly a fair equivalent - particularly if you remove years of service increases in accrual rate. M-F folks get paid a full 8 hour work day for a holiday. But a firefighter's holiday pay is only 8 hours even though his/her normal work day is 24 hours. So the "benefit" of a paid holiday is actually stiffing a firefighter for 16 hours. It is not a special treatment because of a union or a perception of heroism - it is about providing benefits mathematically equivalent to the non-standard work schedule. I am not convinced city leaders were acting with malice or spite in this decision -- but I am also not convinced it was an innocent mistake.

  • Jack Ruth Sep 15, 9:38 a.m.
    user avatar

    Maybe they should become classroom teachers who do not get overtime pay and have no union representation to Or they could become volunteer firefighter who do it for the service to the community.

  • Mike Kallam Sep 15, 9:01 a.m.
    user avatar

    I plan to vote against every incumbent city council person and the mayor when they are up for election. They are disgrace to this city in the way they have treated our public servants.
    Shame on them.

  • Jimmy Jones Sep 15, 8:53 a.m.
    user avatar

    I'm not a supporter of Labor Unions, however Law Enforcement and Firefighters need collective bargaining rights in this state.
    I bet if you compare the salaries and benefits of the city/county managers to other employees, you'd see a HUGE disparity.
    I know where I work, the "manager" got an automatic 5% salary increase per year (no matter what), 4.9% 401(k) contribution (same as the LEO mandated contribution), medical, optical, dental insurance for him AND his family, a vehicle, travel allowance, etc.....the County Commissioners defended this by stating that he had "bargained" for these in his contract. The guy was making more than the darn GOVERNOR!!! In a medium sized county!!!.....well, let us peons bargain!

  • Teddy Fowler Sep 15, 8:42 a.m.
    user avatar

    They should get the same holidays, vacation days, and sick days as do all the city of Raleigh employees...

  • Jeff Freuler Sep 15, 8:40 a.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread


    Well if you think the PAY and benefits are so good why don't you go get a job as a firefighter or police officer

  • Linda Tally Sep 15, 5:42 a.m.
    user avatar

    The stock Council response has been, "We didn't understand what we were signing off on." Jeez Louise, if you don't understand it, don't vote on it! Pay attention to what you're doing, folks! Now get back in there and correct the damage you've done.

  • Henry Cooper Sep 15, 12:53 a.m.
    user avatar

    First look at the benefits package for city employees which includes FD and PD and who not working for the public sector gets these kind of benefits. Look at the health insurance they get then add dental, retirement, 401k matching, tuition reimbursement, life insurance, credit union. Look at the additional sick time they can accrue after 8 years... its ridiculous... Who accrues 5 sick days a month even after 8 years (maybe I am reading it wrong)?

    "Additional Sick Leave account and will accrue 5.44 days per month during your 8th year"

    https://www.raleighnc.gov/home/content/HumanResources/Articles/Benefits.html

    Every year health insurance goes up for the rest of us that is money in their pocket (it is also where some of the additional taxes we are feeling go).

    FD and PD stop whining and if you think you can do better then go get that better paying job that you desire so bad.

  • Scooter Barrette Sep 14, 10:52 p.m.
    user avatar

    *Ahem* Property taxes are set by the county and the state bond measure was a referendum by the people.

More...