Local News

Plea deal offered in Fayetteville girl's 2009 death

Posted April 8, 2013
Updated April 22, 2013

— As jury selection began Monday in the capital murder case of the man accused of raping and killing a 5-year-old Fayetteville girl more than three years ago, prosecutors offered a plea deal to end what is expected to be a two-month trial.

Mario Andrette McNeill, 32, of Pine Springs Drive in Fayetteville, has been charged with murder, kidnapping and rape in the death of Shaniya Davis. He could face the death penalty if convicted.

Shaniya Nicole Davis WRAL.com archive: Shaniya Davis case

Prosecutors said they wouldn't seek the death penalty against McNeill if he pleads guilty. The defense has until Tuesday to accept or reject the deal.

The deal came after Superior Court Judge Jim Ammons denied a request from defense attorneys that the case proceed as a non-capital trial.

Public defenders Harold "Butch" Pope and Terry Alford argued that McNeill's previous lawyer allowed him to make statements that helped investigators find Shaniya's body under an agreement that the death penalty wouldn't be pursued in the case.

Ammons said there is no evidence of such an agreement.

Shaniya's body was found in a kudzu patch off N.C. Highway 87 near the Lee-Harnett county line on Nov. 16, 2009, six days after her mother, Antoinette Nicole Davis, reported her missing from their mobile home on Sleepy Hollow Drive in Fayetteville.

McNeill, who was seen with the girl on a Sanford hotel security camera hours after her disappearance, later surrendered to police after investigators contacted his family. Police said he confessed to abducting her.

Dressed in a green polo shirt in court on Monday, McNeill said he wouldn't dispute that he left the Sleepy Hollow Mobile Home Park with Shaniya and that he took her to the hotel in Sanford and later left with her.

He has denied killing her.

An autopsy determined that Shaniya died of asphyxiation and that injuries she suffered were consistent with a sexual assault. A medical examiner noted in the autopsy that investigators believe the girl was used to pay off a drug debt.

Shaniya's father, Bradley Lockhart, and McNeill's mother were in court Monday.

Jury selection in the case is expected to last at least a week, as prosecutors and defense attorneys question the 97 prospective jurors at length about their views on capital punishment. The trial itself is expected to last another six to eight weeks.

Authorities say Antoinette Davis was complicit in her daughter's death. Arrest warrants state that she "did knowingly provide Shaniya with the intent that she be held in sexual servitude" and "did permit an act of prostitution with Shaniya."

Davis is charged with first-degree murder, indecent liberties with a child, felony child abuse, felony sexual servitude, rape of a child, sexual offense of a child by an adult offender, human trafficking and making a false police report. She will be tried after McNeill's case is over, and prosecutors aren't seeking the death penalty against her.

Shaniya's disappearance and death drew national headlines and focused a spotlight on human trafficking in the U.S.

The Cumberland County Department of Social Services came under fire, with prosecutors and Fayetteville police accusing the agency of withholding information about social workers' contact with Shaniya's family while authorities were still searching for the girl. The local DSS chairman later resigned.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • unpublished_1 Apr 9, 2013

    The father is just as guilty as the mother. He had been advised to remove her from the mother, that she was in a bad environment, and he did nothing to protect her. He should have protected her at all cost.

    I TOTALLY AGREE!!! Does anyone not think the father should be held accountable for this also? He knew what type of environment his child was in & he did NOTHING to fix it! I'm a single father & I KNOW if you r in that child life, u can see when things aren't right! I feel sorry for the victim, "Shaniya" I feel the father should be held accountable for his LACK of fatherhood also!!!

  • gr8Brit Apr 9, 2013

    And when he is sentenced to death just take him downstairs from the courtroom and hang him in the basement, don't put him in prison for years wasting all my tax dollars.

  • NotUrTypicalAmerican Apr 9, 2013

    McNeill rejected the plea. Good. The sick psycho needs the death penalty.

  • PJM Apr 9, 2013

    BURN BABY BURN........This man destroyed a childs life and neither her mother nor this crumb of a mans life need to be spared. "plea deal" are you serious! That child did not have a change to plea for her life...again neither one of them deserve their next breath of air.

  • For the U.S.A. Apr 9, 2013

    Instance death for killing or raping a child! Get it over with NOW!

  • bill0 Apr 9, 2013

    "This guy is THINKING ABOUT THE PLEA? If I was him I would have grabbed it instantly and got down on my knees to thank the powers that be for this unbelievably generous offer."

    Well, he says he is innocent. So far, the public records available suggest the prosecutors have no evidence against the guy other than photos of them together - with the girls still very much alive. If he did accept this girl as payment for a drug debt, it is entirely possible that he just turned around and re-sold her for cash.

    "went inside a Russian Prison.... then just MAYBE it would deter some crime."
    You do realize that russia is an incredibly violent and corrupt country, right? Their prison system obviously isn't something to model.

  • buford Apr 9, 2013

    Breaking News: Mario Andretti McNeill maintained his innocence Tuesday and rejected a plea deal in the capital murder case of a 5-year-old Fayetteville girl. Prosecutors say McNeill raped, kidnapped and murdered Shaniya Davis in 2009. He could face the death penalty if convicted.

    I have a feeling he's going to walk...please don't let it happen...

  • Jimmytwotimes Apr 9, 2013

    Alright he rejected it, that means death penalty!

  • NoObamaCare Apr 9, 2013

    Sounds like he just rejected the plea deal...He must be going for the INSANITY plea after that move!

  • Kaitlyn Apr 9, 2013

    Well he rejected the plea deal so the DP is back on the table.