Debate over 'Hamilton' speech exposes post-election cracks

Posted November 19

Vice President-elect Mike Pence, top center, leaves the Richard Rodgers Theatre after a performance of "Hamilton," in New York, Friday, Nov. 18, 2016. (AP Photo/Andres Kudacki)

— President-elect Donald Trump demanded an apology from the cast of the Broadway musical "Hamilton" a day after an actor in the hit show delivered a pointed message about diversity to his running mate who was in attendance. The speech aimed at Mike Pence prompted angry responses from liberals and conservatives alike — underscoring yet again the fractious aftermath of the 2016 election.

The bitter back-and-forth came after the vice president-elect caught Friday night's performance of "Hamilton" with his nephew and daughter. A mixture of boos and cheers could be heard inside the theater as Pence took his seat. When the show ended, Pence was asked by a cast member to hear a prepared speech after the curtain call from the multiracial and multicultural cast, saying it is concerned about the Trump administration.

"We, sir, we are the diverse America who are alarmed and anxious that your new administration will not protect us, our planet, our children, our parents, or defend us and uphold our inalienable rights," said Brandon Victor Dixon, who plays Aaron Burr, the nation's third vice president, as his fellow actors joined hands. "We truly hope that this show has inspired you to uphold our American values and to work on behalf of all of us."

The unusual address quickly went viral and Trump on Saturday tweeted that it was "very rude," arguing that Pence was "harassed" and theater "must always be a safe and special place." He urged the cast to apologize. Dixon responded on Twitter that "conversation is not harassment sir" and added that he appreciated Pence stopping to listen.

Pence had ducked out before Dixon finished the unprecedented message but heard the full remarks from the hallway outside the auditorium.

Trump transition officials did not immediately respond to requests for comment. A representative for the show said none of the cast members would be available to speak Saturday.

Melissa Kremholz, of Indianapolis, the capital of Pence's home state of Indiana, attended the show Friday night and was seeing it again Saturday afternoon. She said she could see how Dixon's speech might be interpreted as impolite and gave Pence credit for coming, but backed the Broadway cast's right to explain how uneasy many Americans feel.

"I think it was really important for them to speak what they had to say because the whole musical talks about how our country came to be and our American values and how our country was built on immigrants and people of all different backgrounds," she said. "I think it's really important that they actually spoke their minds and I think they did so very respectfully, too."

The show's official Facebook page was inundated with comments ranging from calling Dixon's speech "disrespectful," ''inappropriate" and "uncalled for." Many threatened to not buy tickets to future performances. Tickets for the show are not available for another year; "Hamilton" is sold out through September 2017.

The American Civil Liberties Union weighed in on the side of the Broadway cast, saying the First Amendment is a cornerstone of America "even if it sometimes makes our leaders uncomfortable."

"President-elect Trump needs a refresher on his high school civics class. Americans don't apologize — not even to presidents or vice presidents — for the lawful and proper exercise of their constitutional rights," ACLU Executive Director Anthony D. Romero wrote in a statement.

But Noel Leifer, from Manchester, New Jersey, who was in line to see a matinee Saturday with his wife, Peggy, said he understood why so many people felt that actors lecturing the next vice president from a Broadway stage were somewhat impudent.

"It was a protest. It was a bit disrespectful. They are going to be the leaders of the country. I didn't vote for them — I think they're poor candidates — but they're still going to be leaders," said Leifer, who was celebrating his wife's birthday with tickets he bought a year ago.

As for a boycott of the show, he didn't think that would ultimately fly. "I don't think too many people who have spent the money for this show are going to boycott it just to make a protest statement."

The musical is by Lin-Manuel Miranda, who wrote the story, music and lyrics. It stresses the orphan, immigrant roots of first U.S. Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton and has a terrifically varied score, ranging from pop ballads to gospel to sexy R&B. It has been cheered for reclaiming the nation's founding story with a multicultural cast.

Miranda, in a tweet, said he was "proud" of Dixon and the "Hamilton" cast "for leading with love," before reminding people that everyone is welcome at the theater.

Miranda had been a big booster for the failed presidential campaign of Hillary Clinton, including performing at an all-star fundraiser for her last month. The cast also put on a special "Hamilton" show at a Clinton fundraiser last summer.

The person playing Alexander Hamilton that Pence saw was Javier Munoz, an openly gay actor. Pence supported numerous efforts to ban gay marriage as governor of Indiana and opposed unfettered federal funding for HIV and AIDS treatment.

Many in the Broadway community quickly defended the actions of the "Hamilton" cast, including new Tony Award-winner Cynthia Erivo, who mocked: "You want the theater full of people you have alienated to be protective of you?" And Josh Gad, a Tony nominee for "The Book of Mormon," wrote: "I know the booing upsets some of you. But this is what happens when you run on a platform of hate."

Janise Gray, of Union, New Jersey, who saw the show Saturday afternoon, considered the speech an anguished cry from those fearful they will be pushed aside under Republican rule.

"One way or another, we want everybody to be represented and the way the campaign was, it wasn't feeling that everybody was being represented," she said, adding that she was glad Pence came.

"From what I've heard, it sounded like it was fair and equitable. It was just a statement of 'please represent everyone. We are a diverse country and we need to be inclusive,'" she said. "That's what this country was founded on."


Mark Kennedy is at


Please with your account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Sam Nada Nov 20, 1:53 p.m.
    user avatar

    Hears = Hearts

  • Sam Nada Nov 20, 1:51 p.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Trump/Pence didn't win a majority of the hears and minds of Americans. I guarantee you that. The issue of how this country is governed is FAR from over. The people Trump wants to silence, and dismiss, and ban, and marginalize will not be silent. This has just begun. Get used to it.

  • Steven Brown Nov 20, 10:06 a.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    That's funny, the White House is sold out for the next four years. Good luck with your boycott on it also...

  • Buster Brown Nov 20, 9:44 a.m.
    user avatar

    Dear snowflakes and cupcakes and safety pins-Trump/Pence WON--ISSUE CLOSED. Just go ahead there and show off your immature, infantile losers attitudes by continuing to call them names and try to hang dumb labels on them. Are you trying to insure that the Democrats/leftst/socialist NEVER win another election???

  • Barrett Powell Nov 20, 8:58 a.m.
    user avatar

    That's right, keep up the negative rhetoric that the people that elected Trump are "snowflakes" and racist, and whatever else. That divisiveness is what lost you the election. The rest of the Country is sick of it. As long as you take that posture and the immature reacting to this election the more elections you will loose.

    It's like your the kettle calling the pot black...look in the mirror. The last 8 years have divided this Country more so than any other time since the Civil Rights movement. And that is NOT because we had our first half black President. It's because the media and the left decided if you don't agree with them your a bad person and your attacked.

    Like I said, keep it up and keep digging.

  • Stephen Batchelor Nov 20, 8:35 a.m.
    user avatar

    The cast of Hamilton got it right! The irony in all of this is that tRump and his so called cabinet of hate can lob bombs of hate and and vitriol and call it policy. While they believe the American public has to take it?! Re-read the 1st Amendment! The cast of Hamilton mic-dropped Pence and delivered the ultimate anti-hate speech!! Bravo and well done!!!!

  • Renee Warren Nov 20, 8:14 a.m.
    user avatar

    Does anyone else think this is a bit of irony, folks hollerin' about certain groups of freedoms and liberties while lauding a man who actually enslaved the population as a whole via monetary means?

    As per site (and other sources, too), this is the history of Hamilton..."In a publication entitled "A History of Central Banking in America" the Fed proudly labels Hamilton as its founding father, boasting that he even spoke just like a contemporary Fed chairman. The First Bank of the United States, which was opposed by Jefferson and Madison, created 72 percent inflation in its first five years of operation, as Murray Rothbard wrote in A History of Money and Banking in the United States. It was not rechartered in 1811, but was resurrected by Congress in 1817, after which it created America's first boom-and-bust cycle, which led to the Panic of 1819, the title of another of Rothbard's great works on American economic history."

    smh at the wonder...

  • Sam Nada Nov 19, 8:51 p.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Research Pence's record of statements and actions on LGBT and racial issues for yourself.

  • Mare Procellis Nov 19, 8:44 p.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    You know what isn't necessary? Vice presidents. Until some foreign leader pops off.
    Was the Hamilton speech rude? Sure. But who normalized rudeness? Trump. Trump is so deeply offensive to the majority who voted against him don't clutch your pearls when The People give him and his bootlicking Christian supremacist toadies an earful.

  • Sam Nada Nov 19, 5:50 p.m.
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    That's funny. Hamilton is sold out for nearly 2 years. Good luck with that boycott on Broadway in NYC. There are also consequences for elections, and choosing VP's who have advocated homophobic and racist policies. The desire for equality for all will never be silenced. The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.