Local News

No criminal charges to be filed in Duke fraternity rape investigation

Posted July 2, 2015

— Durham District Attorney Roger Echols said Thursday his office will not file criminal charges against members of a Duke University fraternity accused in a sexual assault that allegedly happened at an off-campus party in January.

Echols said he made the decision not to pursue an indictment against members of Alpha Delta Phi after an “extensive and thorough” investigation that including witness interviews, forensic examinations and consultations with experts.

“The nature of the conduct investigated and of the alleged offenses investigated is personal and sensitive,” Echols said in a statement. “It is with respect for the sensitive subject matter and the complaining witness that I will not release more details of the investigation to the public.”

A female Duke student told authorities that she was at a party Jan. 8 at 2505 Chapel Hill Road – a house leased by Alpha Delta Phi members – when she had a mixed drink and later had what she thought was hot chocolate.

She told police she refused a fraternity member when he allegedly led her to his upstairs room prior to her second drink, and the last thing she remembered clearly was dancing with friends.

According to search warrants, she told police she had vague recollections of being led next door, seeing people sitting in a living room and going into a bedroom with a poster of rapper Drake on the wall. She remembered telling a fraternity member, “Let’s go back to the party,” but doesn’t remember walking back, the warrants state.

When she awoke the next afternoon, the woman told police, the leggings she had been wearing were on the floor next to the bed and appeared to be torn.

“Although this is a very difficult decision to accept by the complaining witness, who has been extremely cooperative with the Durham Police Department and the Office of the District Attorney, this is the appropriate decision given the available evidence and the applicable law,” Echols said.

The fraternity was suspended from the university pending the outcome of the investigation. The organization could not be immediately reached for comment.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Kenneth Brewer Jul 3, 2015
    user avatar

    Isaiah 5:20

  • William Teach Jul 3, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Do you have proof? Or just belief? If you have hard facts, let's see it. Take it to the local news media. Take it to the State AG.

    Otherwise, you're just engaging in Libel.

  • Erika Phipps Jul 2, 2015
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Yeah, because females never lie about rape, especially after they made some bad decisions.

    Maybe Rolling stone should investigate.

  • Greg Dail Jul 2, 2015
    user avatar

    Where's the evidence she was, what's that you call it roofied? Look I don't necessarily disagree I'm just asking where's the evidence.
    However, I can confirm the Durham DA's office is a sad joke. A relative of mine took his own life with his "friend's" STOLEN 10 mm hand cannon. The DA declined to prosecute. The Durham Sheriff Dept. couldn't believe the decision.
    And so it goes, Nifong lives.

  • William Teach Jul 2, 2015
    user avatar

    So, after being convicted in the court of public opinion, after being flayed in the news and social media, it turns out that there is no evidence to file charges.

    Where do they go to get their reputation back?