State News

Report: Zahra Baker's stepmom cuts deal to avoid death penalty

Posted December 3, 2010

— The stepmother of a slain Hickory 10-year-old has cut  deal with prosecutors that eliminate the death penalty if she is ever brought to trial in the girl's disappearance, WBTV reported Friday. 

Zahra Baker was reported missing Oct. 9. Police confirmed Nov. 19 that human remains found in Caldwell County matched her DNA profile.

Elisa Baker was arrested Oct. 10, and she is accused of trying to throw off investigators by writing a fake ransom note for another child. Her attorneys have argued that her $97,000 bond should be reduced because she helped police find Zahra.

An investigator with the Hickory Police Department wrote in applying for a search warrant that Elisa Baker's lawyer told him Zahra had been dismembered, and that she and her husband dumped a mattress and box springs at a trash dump in Granite Falls and wrapped Zahra's prosthetic leg in a white trash bag and threw it into an apartment dumpster in Hickory.

The warrants note that Elisa Baker showed "deception" in a polygraph test when asked if she knew of any harm that came to Zahra.

Regional District Attorney James Gaither Jr. told WBTV on Friday that a deal was struck with Elisa Baker, but he would not comment on the terms.

Another source told WBTV that prosecutors agreed to take the death penalty and life in prison off the table, if she would provide investigators with information about the little girl's whereabouts.

Zahra lived with her stepmother and father, Adam Baker. In the course of the investigation, according to the warrants, investigators found that Elisa Baker had a history of referrals to the Department of Social Services for alleged abuse of her biological children. Caldwell County DSS reported in July that Zahra got a black eye from her stepmother.

Zahra's father, Adam Baker, has adamantly denied involvement in his daughter's death. He faces unrelated charges of assault with a deadly weapon, failure to return rental property, communicating threats and writing worthless checks.

5 Comments

This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • dlk13ster Dec 6, 2010

    I understand the objections, and a large part of me sympathizes. But the sad truth of the matter is that the gov. simply does not have the manpower or resources to bring EVERY single criminal case to trial, and subsequent appeals.

    Were it not for plea deals that help bring cases to quick and speedy conclusions, our judicial system would be an even bigger entangled morass than it already is.

    That's not to excuse or justify what is happening today, but it IS something people need to understand.

  • rlee1117 Dec 6, 2010

    THE PEOPLE IN NORTH CAROLINA SHOULD BE IN A UPROAR OVER THIS!! ITS A LIL GIRL HERE PEEPS THAT GOT MURDERED!!! WE WANT JUSTICE FOR ZAHRA! R.I.P. ZAHRA YOU WILL NEVER BE FORGOTTEN!!

  • CarolinaGirlRJA Dec 6, 2010

    WHAT?!?!?! I hate our legal system here. They help criminals more than they punish them. It seems that justice may never be served for Zahra. What a shame. I guess if that's the only way to find out exactly what happened, then that's what they have to do. So unfortunate and wrong though. :(

  • pebbles262004 Dec 6, 2010

    I guess the prosecutors does not care anything about Zahra either to make that kind of bargain!!! Makes me sick......

  • bknyny1979 Dec 6, 2010

    Wow! something is just not right with this! "Prosecutors agreed to take the death penalty and life in prison off the table"! There are still no murder charges being bought up? Sad all the way around. R.I.P Zahra