Perdue vetoes GOP attempt to fight federal healthcare overhaul

Posted March 5, 2011

Gov. Bev Perdue has vetoed House Bill 2, the “Protect Health Care Freedom” act.

The measure was one of the top agenda items for the legislature’s new Republican leadership. It was approved last month on a mostly party-line vote.

The news broke on Twitter this afternoon via Perdue spokeswoman Chrissy Pearson.  In a statement shortly thereafter, Perdue called H2 "superfluous" and unconstitutional. "This is an ill-conceived piece of legislation that's not good for the people of North Carolina," the governor said. "Therefore I veto it."

H2 was an attempt to forestall federal healthcare reform by making a section of it – the individual mandate – unenforceable under state law. The measure would have made it illegal to require any North Carolinian to purchase health insurance, or to punish anyone for not buying it. It also required the Attorney General to defend any state citizen against federal lawsuits stemming from the mandate.

In an advisory letter to the governor last week, Attorney General Roy Cooper called the measure unenforceable and unconstitutional. “State legislatures cannot pick and choose which federal laws the state will obey,” Cooper said, “even those laws we don’t like or agree with.”

Cooper also warned Perdue that H2 could cost the state millions in federal Medicaid funding, saying one provision in the bill would ban state Medicaid providers from paying an HCR-required fee for a new anti-fraud program.

Last night, House Majority Leader Paul Stam, R-Wake, sent out an advisory written by non-partisan legislative staff, arguing that H2 would be enforceable, and would not ban providers from paying the anti-fraud fee. That’s here.

Today’s veto is Perdue’s third. N.C. governors have only had veto power since 1996. The governor at that time, Jim Hunt, never exercised it. His successor, Mike Easley, used it nine times over his eight years as governor.


This blog post is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • 27610-USA Mar 9, 2011

    The GOP in Washington promises to block all funding to Obama Health Care.

  • 27610-USA Mar 9, 2011

    We will get one. :)

  • tws1234 Mar 9, 2011

    If I become Governor of NC, I would reverse everything Gov. Perdue did, and make it right.

  • tws1234 Mar 9, 2011

    We really do need a new Governor at the next election. Bev Perdue doen,t know what she is doing at all. We should have her impeached. I know I,m going to try to run for Governor in 2012, and I will make NC right again.

  • tws1234 Mar 9, 2011

    I know one thing for sure, NC or President Obama will force me to get health insurance. I will fight it in court.

  • hoochiemochie Mar 7, 2011

    Hello Governor Mcrrory

  • 27610-USA Mar 7, 2011

    Just think, when the GOP in Washington blocks all funding to Obama Health Care until the 2012 election, we are home free!

  • driverkid3 Mar 7, 2011

    donna101;;;Well, She just lost my vote and the vote of literally hundreds of other people I know who voted for her.

    See what trouble you inflicted on NC?

  • _kommon_sense_ Mar 7, 2011

    LOL your out numbered if they decide to vote XD

  • 27610-USA Mar 7, 2011

    Well since she is only going to be a one termer maybe Obama will give her a job as one of his lobbyist in his new Democratic Lobbyist firm pushing for more Foreign Spending to the Middle East when he loses the 2012 election. Then she can travel the world with her buddies Obama, Kerry and Clinton.