Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

6:19 p.m. • 6-19-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Thu: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 85° F
  • Fri: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 85° F
  • Sat: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 85° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image

Published: 2009-02-12 10:08:00
Updated: 2009-03-09 17:12:52

Court: Vaccine not to blame for autism


Autism study
Autism study
print friendly

Vaccines aren't to blame for autism, a special federal court declared Thursday in a blow to thousands of families hoping to win compensation and to many more who are convinced of a connection.

The special masters who decided the case expressed sympathy for the families, some of whom have made emotional pleas describing their children's conditions, but the rulings were blunt: There's little if any evidence to support claims of a vaccine-autism link.

The evidence "is weak, contradictory and unpersuasive," concluded Special Master Denise Vowell. "Sadly, the petitioners in this litigation have been the victims of bad science conducted to support litigation rather than to advance medical and scientific understanding" of autism.

Michelle Weaver, whose 7-year-old son has autism, disagreed with the court's findings.

"This is the government trying to cover their butts," the Harnett County mother said bluntly. "Thousands upon thousands of us cannot be wrong."

Science years ago reached the conclusion that there's no connection, but Thursday's rulings in a trio of cases still have far-reaching implications – offering reassurance to parents scared about vaccinating their babies because of a small but vocal anti-vaccine movement. Some vaccine-preventable diseases, including measles, are on the rise, and last fall a Minnesota baby who hadn't been vaccinated against meningitis died of that disease.

The special court represented a chance for vindication for families who blame vaccines for their children's autism. Known as "the people's court," the U.S. Court of Claims is different from many other courts: The families involved didn't have to prove the inoculations definitely caused the complex neurological disorder, just that they probably did.

More than 5,500 claims have been filed by families seeking compensation through the government's Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, and Thursday's rulings dealt with the first three test cases to settle which if any claims had merit. The first cases argued that a combination of the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine plus other shots triggered autism.

"I must decide this case not on sentiment but by analyzing the evidence," said Special Master George Hastings Jr., writing specifically about Michelle Cedillo of Yuma, Ariz., who is disabled with autism, inflammatory bowel disease and other disorders that her parents blame on a measles vaccine given at 15 months.

"Unfortunately, the Cedillos have been misled by physicians who are guilty, in my view, of gross medical misjudgment," Hastings concluded.

Attorneys for the families said they were disappointed and may appeal.

"There was certainly no scientific proof that vaccines caused autism, but that's not the standard – the standard is likelihood," said Kevin Conway of Boston, who represented the Cedillos. "We thought our evidence was solid."

"Certainly, those three families are discouraged with the ruling," added Tom Powers, a Portland, Ore., attorney overseeing all the claims. "It's a big step. It's a significant step, but it's not the last step."

Indeed, the court's ruling will do little to change the minds of parents who believe vaccines have harmed their children, said the head of a consumer group that questions vaccine safety, the National Vaccine Information Center.

"I think it is a mistake to conclude that because these few test cases were denied compensation, that it's been decided vaccines don't play any role in regressive autism," said Barbara Loe Fisher, the center's president.

Weaver remains convinced her son, Ben, wouldn't have autism if not for immunizations he received at 12 and 15 months of age.

"Within 24 hours (of the first vaccinations), he developed an extremely high fever. Screaming, vomiting, and it never got better. It got worse," she said.

Doctors told her the child's symptoms were the result of a viral infection. So he got another round of vaccines three months later, which Weaver said wiped out nearly all traces of the boy she knew.

"He lost his speech completely. He'd crawl in a hole and cover up," she said. "It's almost like a death. It really is."

The court still must rule on additional cases that argue a different link – that vaccines that once carried the mercury-containing preservative thimerosal are to blame, if the mercury reached and damaged brain cells – and Powers said families making those claims remain hopeful. The court has given no timetable for a ruling.

But Thursday's rulings clearly gave great credence to numerous large studies that have looked for but not found any link between the measles vaccine, other vaccines and autism.

"Hopefully, the determination by the special masters will help reassure parents that vaccines do not cause autism," the Department of Health and Human Services said in a statement that pledged to continue research into possible causes and better treatments.

"It's a great day for science, it's a great day for America's children when the court rules in favor of science," said Dr. Paul Offit, an infectious disease expert at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and developer of a vaccine for rotavirus.

"A choice not to get a vaccine is not a risk-free choice," Offit added, pointing to recent outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases that authorities suspect are partly due to delayed or rejected vaccinations.

Two children in North Carolina are diagnosed with autism each day, according to the Autism Society of North Carolina. Spokesman David Laxton said further research is needed on any link between the disease and vaccines, but he encouraged any family concerned about vaccines to discuss the risks with its pediatrician to make an informed decision.

Autism is best known for impairing a child's ability to communicate and interact. Recent data suggest a 10-fold increase in autism rates over the past decade, although it's unclear how much of the surge reflects better diagnosis.

Worry about a vaccine link first arose in 1998 when a British physician, Dr. Andrew Wakefield, published a medical journal article linking a particular type of autism and bowel disease to the measles vaccine. The study was soon discredited, and British medical authorities now are investigating professional misconduct charges against Wakefield.

Then came questions about thimerosal, a preservative that manufacturers began removing from all vaccines given to infants in 2001. Today it is present only in certain formulations of the flu shot.

Weaver said her son has made great strides with therapy, but she said she will always blame vaccines for his condition.

"I will go to my grave knowing and believing this is what's wrong with my child," she said.


57 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

View Comments VIEW ALL 57 COMMENTS

This story is closed for comments.

Latest Comments
That's ok affirmativediversity since i'm unable to live forever I guess you the tax payer can be the cash cow when I'm gone. And for your info. the "right thing" would be having my kid self sufficient and not need anyone's help but that's not likely to happen.

"I do not believe autism is caused by vaccines. What I do believe, however, and this is documented, that some people's bodies cannot withstand the trauma caused by the formula (vaccine+preservative+whateverthehellelseisinthere) injected into them, and this causes symptoms similar to clinically diagnosed autism."

Local Know It All - I share your opinion. My 5 year old son was diagnosed with ASD when he was 2 years old and I can say with all certainty that he comes by it naturally.

It's my belief that people forget that medicine is not a perfect science and that there will always be those who react adversely to a medication, procedure, or preventative vaccine that the majority of recipients respond to appropriately.

Yup, This is the same country that tells you to watch out for Mercury in Tuna fish but says you can have mercury in your mouth in dental fillings. Makes you wonder ,doesn't it!

By the way, I don't think anyone is saying that vaccines are the only cause of autism, however they are often a direct cause of all types of problems, especially in children. For those who have children with autism, I would strongly urge a natural, dietary approach to treatment and healing. There are chelation and detoxification options for eliminating heavy metals, dietary changes, and supplementation. Supplementation of natural vitamin D3 (not synthetic) at doses higher than the recommended daily allowances (4,000 IUs or more) can help with a whole host of problems. I would recommend finding a naturopathic doctor and doing some research online because there are many doctors taking a non-drug approach and helping many people with alternative therapies than the ones being promulgated by the same people who made the millions off the harmful vaccines in the first place (the corrupt drug companies who steer all the "research" and "science" that promote their own toxic products).

teeterbug113...here is some hard truth...if your child is disabled (in anyway, especially in a meaningful way) they are the member of the only minority left in this country that can be legally segregated, routinely discouraged from employment, is ineligible to adopt or become a foster parent, is constantly portrayed as "helpless" "needy" or in essence "lacking and unequal"...if your child never works and you do not instill a sense of worth, value or work ethic then society is more likely to consider you having done "the right thing"...

You deserve NOTHING because your child has a disability!!! Now, your child deserves EVERY opportunity EVERY OTHER CHILD receives BUT your child's disability is NOT a cash cow or a "debt" anyone should repay you! Your busy worrying about the apples when the oranges are falling off the tree!

View Comments VIEW ALL 57 COMMENTS