World News

Four American hostages killed by pirates, US says

Posted February 22, 2011

— A pirate fired a rocket-propelled grenade at a U.S. Navy destroyer shadowing a hijacked yacht with four Americans aboard Tuesday. Then gunfire erupted, the military said. U.S. special forces rushed to the yacht only to find the four Americans fatally wounded.

One of those killed worked for a Hillsborough company.

The experienced yacht enthusiasts from California and Washington are the first Americans killed by Somali pirates since the start of attacks off East Africa several years ago. One of the American couples on board had been sailing around the world since 2004 handing out Bibles.

Their deaths appear to underscore an increasingly brutal and aggressive shift pirates have been showing toward hostages.

A pirate who said his name was Muse Abdi said killing hostages "has now become part of our rules," and he referred to a pirate who was sentenced in a New York court last week to 33 years in prison for a 2009 attack on the U.S. cargo vessel the Maersk Alabama.

"From now on, anyone who tries to rescue the hostages in our hands will only collect dead bodies," he said. "It will never ever happen that hostages are rescued and we are hauled to prison."

Pirates had hijacked the 58-foot yacht Quest south of Oman on Friday. Since then, four U.S. warships and sky-high drones shadowed the vessel's movement as pirates tried to sail it to the Somali shore. U.S. officials negotiated with the captors via radio.

But at 8 a.m. East Africa time Tuesday, a rocket-propelled grenade was fired from the Quest at the USS Sterett, a guided-missile destroyer 600 yards (meters) away. The RPG missed, and almost immediately afterward, small arms fire was heard coming from the yacht, said Vice Adm. Mark Fox, commander of the U.S. 5th Fleet in Bahrain.

Several pirates then appeared on deck with their hands up. U.S. naval forces boarded the vessel and tried to provide lifesaving care to the Americans, but they died, Fox said. No U.S. forces were injured or killed.

The Quest was the home Jean and Scott Adam, of Marina del Rey, near Los Angeles. The two had been sailing around the world since December 2004. Phyllis Macay and Bob Riggle, of Seattle, Washington, had recently joined the Adams.

"Great sailors, good people. They were doing what they wanted to do, but that's small comfort in the face of this," said Joe Grande of the Seattle Singles Yacht Club, where Riggle and Macay were members.

Macay was an employee of Hillsborough-based Profitability Consulting and had been traveling the world on sabbatical, Chief Executive John Egger said.

"It's just devastating," Egger said after hearing of her death. "When I heard that they had the Navy around the boat, I thought, 'Well, they’ll just get her home,' and I just couldn’t believe it (when I heard she had been killed).

"It’s just very tough for me, my family and my working partners."

Macayworked in the retail furniture industry where she helped to train others. Egger described her as a high-energy person and hard-working professional, noting that he gladly granted her a sabbatical three years ago so she could sail the world with Riggle, a retired veterinarian.

"I was so happy for her," he said. "She kept saying (in e-mails), 'I'm still out here on the seas loving it.' So, she lived the life."

Around Christmas the Quest joined the Blue Water Rally, an around-the-world race. But race organizers said the Quest recently left the race despite what Fox said were warnings about the dangers of sailing in Horn of Africa region.

The Blue Water Rally said in a statement Tuesday that though yachtsmen are discouraged from sailing in the region, the only other choices are to sail around the stormy and dangerous tip of South Africa or sail back across the Pacific.

The Adams were skilled and experienced sailors, having traveled from from Panama in 2005 to Fiji in 2007 and Cambodia last year. They most recently sailed from Thailand to Sri Lanka and India, and were on their way to Oman when captured.

Thirteen pirates were captured and detained Tuesday, and two other pirates had boarded the USS Sterett on Monday to negotiate, Fox said.

A member of a U.S. special operations force killed one of the pirates with a knife, Fox said. A second pirate was also killed, and the bodies of two other pirates were discovered on board, bringing to 19 the total number of pirates involved. The U.S. military didn't say how those two died and it was not known if the pirates had fought among themselves.

Pirates have increased attacks off the coast of East Africa in recent years despite an international flotilla of warships dedicated to protecting vessels and stopping the pirate assaults.

But the conventional wisdom in the shipping industry had been that Somali pirates are businessmen looking for a multimillion-dollar ransom payday, not insurgents looking to terrorize people.

"We have heard threats against the lives of Americans before but it strikes me as being very, very unusual why they would kill hostages outright," said Graeme Gibbon-Brooks, the head of Dryad Maritime Intelligence, adding that the pirates must realize that killing Americans would invite a military response.

Motivated by million-dollar ransoms, pirates have become increasingly bold in their attacks despite a flotilla of international warships patrolling the waters off East Africa. The last time pirates kidnapped a U.S. citizen — during the 2009 hijacking of the Maersk Alabama — Navy sharpshooters killed two pirates and rescued the ship's captain.

President Barack Obama, who was notified about the deaths at 4:42 a.m. Washington time, had authorized the military on Saturday to use force in case of an imminent threat to the hostages, said White House spokesman Jay Carney.

But Tuesday's bloody events are apt to leave U.S. military planners in a quandary: Do they go after the pirates harder? Do they attack their bases on Somalia's ungoverned shores? One maritime expert said it's too early to tell.

"This is a first," said Gibbon-Brooks, the analyst. "We don't know if the situation is related to a straight execution. We don't know if it was related to an attempt to break free. We don't know if it was related to an accident."

Gibbon-Brooks said the killings were "extremely unwise" by the Somalis, and that the deaths threaten what has been a successful and lucrative business model.

Two days before the hijacking, a New York court sentenced a pirate to 33 years in prison for the 2009 attack on the Maersk Alabama, a U.S. cargo vessel. A pirate in Somalia told the AP last week that pirates were more likely to attack Americans because of the sentencing.

"It's a black day for us and also the Americans, but they lost bigger than us," a pirate who said his name was Bile Hussein said. "If they still want a solution and safety for their citizens in the oceans, let them release our men they arrested."

Only minutes before the military announced that the four Americans had died, a Somali pirate told AP by phone that if the yacht were attacked, "the hostages will be the first to go."

"Some pirates have even suggested rigging the yacht with land mines and explosives so as the whole yacht explodes with the first gunshot," said the pirate, who gave his name as Abdullahi Mohamed, who claimed to be a friend of the pirates holding the four Americans.

Pirates — who currently hold 30 ships and more than 660 hostages — typically win a multimillion ransom for releasing their captives, a huge sum that is shared among investors and pirates. The money is often spent on alcohol, drugs and prostitutes. One ransom paid last year was reported as $9.5 million. Most ransoms are worth several million dollars.

Given that typical financial motivation, Tuesday's killings left several unanswered questions, such as whether the pirates, being trailed by the Americans, believed there was no way to avoid spending years in a U.S. prison, or if the American forces spooked the pirates by approaching the yacht, or even if the hostages had tried to retake the yacht from the pirates.

The military said U.S. forces have been monitoring the Quest for about three days, since shortly after the Friday attack. Four Navy warships were involved, including the aircraft carrier USS Enterprise.

Mohamed, the pirate in Somalia, told AP that pirate leaders had been expecting the yacht to make landfall soon.

Five cars full of pirates were headed toward the pirate dens of Eyl and Gara'ad in anticipation of the Quest reaching land Monday, he said. Had the four reached land, they may have faced a long hostage ordeal like the 388 days that the British sailing couple Paul and Rachel Chandler spent in the hands of pirates. The two were released in November.

Omar Jamal, first secretary at Somalia's mission at the U.N., sent his condolences to the families of the four Americans and called the deaths a tragic loss of life. Jamal said there is an urgent need to address the piracy problem.

"This incident is a clear message and alarm that it's time the world community quickly steps up to stop these pirate criminal activities. They should be treated mercilessly," said Gen. Yusuf Ahmed Khayr, the security minister in the northern Somalia region of Puntland, a pirate haven.

The Adams ran a Bible ministry and had been distributing Bibles to schools and churches in remote villages in areas including the Fiji Islands, Alaska, New Zealand, Central America and French Polynesia.

At the Seattle Singles Yacht Club, friend Hank Curci said Riggle and Macay were carrying out a lifelong dream.

"Now that they're gone it's just difficult for us to accept because it's like having a family member killed," he said.

160 Comments

This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • RM24 Feb 24, 2011

    Until we recognize the "pirates" for what they are nothing is going to change. We just want to pretend its just some mean ol boys out in the ocean calling them pirates. It is time to do more than analyze the situation.

  • ConcernedNCC Feb 23, 2011

    When the people were found to be dead, the pirates should have been executed on the spot for piracy on the high seas. No wasting money on trials.

  • tab580642 Feb 22, 2011

    ranquick wrote; "When are we going to stop these attacks on Americans all over the world. There is no doubt we could have gotten these people back with a midnight raid by the SEALS. WAKE UP YOU AMERICANS WHO LIVE IN A SHELL."
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    ----
    Sounds like you watch too much tv or you don't think that option had been considered and ruled out. Also, I'll tell you when we'll stop these attacks on Americans around the world," when Americans realize that the world outside of our borders are quite different and when Americans realize that the people that our government support in these other countries are horrible to their people and the people in turn take their anger out on any Americans they can. Not making any excuses, but it is what it is.

    Also, these people placed their own lives in danger after being begged by friends not to go, so with all due respect, pardon me for not having a whole lot of sympathy for them.

  • eccgc Feb 22, 2011

    They knew the dangers!

  • MyNameIsMud Feb 22, 2011

    "When are we going to stop these attacks on Americans all over the world. There is no doubt we could have gotten these people back with a midnight raid by the SEALS. WAKE UP YOU AMERICANS WHO LIVE IN A SHELL."

    They aren't targeting Americans. Anybody on a boat is fair game. It's not a US problem--it's an international one. A commando raid could have ended in gunfire and death just as easily if you know anything about history. *COUGH* Iran hostages *COUGH*

  • kidsrn Feb 22, 2011

    I am sick of this stuff going on. Just do it like they did in the old days. Shoot every pirate you find. Start with the ones that were taken off the yacht after they killed these 4 innocent people. The pirates themselves have said that they will no longer allow any hostages they capture to live but will kill them. So, apply the golden rule---do to them what they are doing to others. Might make them think twice before doing this again.

  • MyNameIsMud Feb 22, 2011

    "The problem is that big companies from all over are dumping there waste products off the coast of Somalia and the people are tired of it so they are doing something about it.

    Is this what this is?"

    That and now that they are getting 7-figure ransoms it's become more lucrative to criminal elements and probably terrorist elements too.

  • paddie Feb 22, 2011

    Navigate life wrote: "The problem is that big companies from all over are dumping there waste products off the coast of Somalia and the people are tired of it so they are doing something about it. I don't condone killing and at the same time if you know there is trouble off that coast then it would be very wise on your part to avoid the area."
    OMG! No...the problem is people such as yourself who assign some kind of noble cause or motivation behind reprehensible acts of violence. Believe me, this has NOTHING to do with waste products being dumped or not off the coast of Somalia. Give me a break!

  • avidreader Feb 22, 2011

    They should have left the pirates on the boat and blown it out of the water, once they removed our citizens.

  • ranquick Feb 22, 2011

    When are we going to stop these attacks on Americans all over the world. There is no doubt we could have gotten these people back with a midnight raid by the SEALS. WAKE UP YOU AMERICANS WHO LIVE IN A SHELL.

More...