Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

7:35 a.m. • 5-19-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 78° F
  • Mon: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 78° F
  • Tue: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 83° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image

Published: 2008-08-10 09:24:00
Updated: 2008-08-10 17:07:15

Race sometimes a problem in eyewitness IDs


print friendly

In the midst of being raped, Jennifer Thompson-Cannino told herself to pay attention to details that would allow her to identify her attacker.

She was able to give police in North Carolina a description that led to a sketch of the suspect. Then she identified a man from photographs, picked him out of a lineup and told jurors she was certain he was the rapist.

That man, Ronald Cotton, received a life sentence and spent more than 10 years in prison before DNA testing cleared him of the crime.

Now victim and the innocent man she helped convict are writing a book together.

Thompson-Cannino, who is white, had mistakenly picked out one black man; another was guilty of the crime.

"Between the composite sketch and the photo identification, I had messed it up," she said, recalling the 1984 rape and its aftermath. "By the time I got to the physical lineup, Ron Cotton had become my attacker, and that was that."

As she came to learn, she was not the only one to make a mistake so devastating that it deprived someone else of his freedom.

Since 1991, 218 people have been exonerated through DNA testing, and in more than three-quarters of the cases, mistaken eyewitness identifications were crucial in the wrongful convictions, according to The Innocence Project, a legal group that has sought genetic testing and led the charge to free innocent inmates.

The North Carolina Project on Actual Innocence, based at the Duke University School of Law, has helped The Innocence Project exonerate inmates, including Dwayne Dail, of Goldsboro, and Darryl Hunt, of Winston-Salem. DNA evidence cleared the men, both of whom spent 18 years in prison. Dail had been convicted of rape and burglary; Hunt, of murder and rape.

Nationally, roughly seven dozen – nearly half – of the cases where The Innocence Project has helped free an innocent person, involved a person of one race wrongly identifying someone of a different color.

Even people with training in law enforcement confront the difficulty of accurate identifications. Boston Police Sgt. Gregory Gallagher, who is white, identified Stephan Cowans, who was black, as the man who shot him twice with Gallagher's own police-issue gun in 1997.

Several years later, testing on a sweat shirt, cap and glass that the suspect wore or touched ruled out Cowans as the shooter. His case was also plagued by misidentification of a fingerprint.

Cowans was released from prison after serving 5 1/2 years. He was found shot to death in his home last year.

This year, North Carolina became the first state to standardize identification procedures. That includes preventing the police officer who is investigating the crime from conducting photo identifications with witnesses and requiring that lineup photographs be shown one after another rather than in groups of six.

The American Bar Association, meeting in New York, is considering whether to recommend that judges use their discretion to make juries aware of the problems that can plague cross-racial identifications.

California, Massachusetts, New Jersey and Utah already employ such instructions in some cases.

"The majority race is not as good at identifying minorities as it is its own race. This is hard-wired in some way that we don't completely understand. But the phenomenon should be presented to the jury," said Barry Scheck, co-founder of The Innocence Project.

Prosecutors, however, do not want judges to raise the issue with juries.

"This is not an appropriate area for judges to go into," said Josh Marquis, district attorney in Astoria, Ore., and a member of the executive committee of the National District Attorneys Association. "Yes, eyewitness ID across races has its issues. But is there a rampant problem to the degree that we need to get judges to start telling juries this is the law? No."

Some criminal justice experts believe that mistakes are so pervasive that nothing short of wholesale reforms in identification procedures will fix the problem.

New software that was on display at the ABA's annual meeting allows witnesses to use police laptop computers to identify photos of suspects in programs that do not vary from investigator to investigator or witness to witness.

The entire session is recorded and defense lawyers are able to obtain digital copies of the photos and the audio. Defense lawyers have complained in the past that authorities often do not turn over the photos used to identify suspects, leaving them no way to measure if the process was tainted.

Thompson-Cannino was 22 when she was raped. She is now the mother of 18-year-old triplets in Winston-Salem. She was changing the sheets on their beds when she spoke to The Associated Press by telephone recently.

Her experience has made her an advocate for criminal justice reform.

She and Cotton, who also lives in North Carolina, are at work on a book called "Picking Cotton," that is to be published next year.

"It's a memoir of our journey through the system, also of forgiveness and redemption," she said.


9 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

View Comments VIEW ALL 9 COMMENTS

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Latest Comments
"I think any race would confuse another."

I am American Indian - but they prefer me to put "Caucasian" down for an answer.

"My point is, there is no need for reform. The reform happened when DNA testing became a common occurance." --DeathRow-IFeelYourPain-NOT

Maybe I am missing the point here, but wouldn't it be a good thing to set in place "anything" that will make incorrect identifying , minority or not a thing of the past? We want "correct justice" in the USA, not just "justice."

'"Between the composite sketch and the photo identification, I had messed it up," she said, recalling the 1984 rape and its aftermath. "By the time I got to the physical lineup, Ron Cotton had become my attacker, and that was that."'

I think this shows just exactly how the cards fell in these cases. The person looked like the person who raped her, she believed it, probably could pass a lie detector test for it, and then come to find out via DNA testing that it was not the case.

The DNA testing needs to be done at the time of the rape and not 10 or 15 years down the road. The DA's need to stop looking for a conviction and start acting ethically to find the right person doing the crimes.

When it all gets boiled down, the DA's responsibility is to find and convict the criminals, not railroad the innocent. If they can not do that, then the DA's themselves are guilty of felonies.

"Nationally, roughly seven dozen – nearly half – of the cases where The Innocence Project has helped free an innocent person, involved a person of one race wrongly identifying someone of a different color."

This statistic is not meaningful and as written seems to attempt to mislead. What if, of all cases in which a witness identified the person committing the crime, 90% involved an identifier and identified of different races. If that were true then you would expect at least 50% of the overturned cases to involve people of different races. Without additional information/statistics, the one that was selected to be disclosed in the article is meaningless.

I don't think this has as much to do with race as it does with the horrible reliability of human memory - especially when the trial occurs months or even years after the incident in question.

View Comments VIEW ALL 9 COMMENTS

National & World

 
  • Your mother always told you to wash your hands but she probably never mentioned your handbag. Now new research from a British company…

  • Seven people were still missing Friday after tornadoes ripped through several towns in North Texas.

  • The scandal within the Internal Revenue Service was front and center Friday on Capitol Hill, as a committee heard testimony from…

  • Disney World is investigating reports that visitors hired people with disabilities to avoid long waits for some rides.

  • A rash of tornados slammed into several small communities in North Texas overnight, leaving at least six people dead, dozens more…

  • President Obama says he'll hold a Rose Garden news conference Thursday to answer questions about the scandal enveloping the Internal…

  • How far would you go to fix your street? Homeowners in Portland, Ore. say it took the city too long to repair huge craters. They…

  • The National Transportation Safety Board wants to lower the legal limit for drinking and driving from .08 to .05. The agency says it…

  • With issues at the IRS and Justice Department and the renewed interest in the Benghazi attack, many are questioning the White House…

  • Just a few people ever manage to escape the brutal hardships behind the heavily-guarded border of North Korea. For many who have, a…

  • Eleven-year-old Lexie Walker can belt out a tune. Her rendition of the National Anthem was captured on video and went viral.

  • A shooting at a mother's day parade in New Orleans has injured more than a dozen people.

  • The Federal Trade Commission is warning people about "cramming," when unauthorized charges sneak onto people's cellphone bills.

  • Caleb McGillvary, who became a viral sensation for being a hitchhiking Good Samaritan, is charged with murder in the death of a New…

  • Former Internal Revenue Service commissioner Steven Miller will be the key witness on Capitol Hill Friday morning as hearings begin…

  • A series of spring tornadoes slammed North Texas Wednesday night, killing at least six people, injuring dozens and destroying homes.

  • Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew asked for and accepted acting IRS Commission Steven Miller's resignation on Wednesday, President Barack…

  • Franklin Graham says two charities he heads were targeted by the Internal Revenue Service for political reasons. Graham heads both…

  • Reshma Begum, a 19-year-old worker who was pulled from the rubble of a collapsed factory in Bangladesh, said she survived for 17 days…

  • The Internal Revenue Service is under a lot of pressure to come completely clean. Lawmakers are demanding to know who made the…

  • Angelina Jolie is a movie star known for her work as a United Nations Ambassador. Now, she's making news for her surprising…

  • People are trying different ways to recover after the Boston Marathon bombings. Heather Abbott visited famous Fenway Park to help her…

  • More and more Americans are using health clinics inside retail stores instead of going to the doctor or emergency room. Companies are…

Click Here