WRAL Investigates

Sting key to picking apart locksmith scheme

Posted April 23, 2009
Updated April 24, 2009

— A nationwide operation in which people pose as locksmiths has infiltrated the Triangle, preying on people who lock themselves out of their homes.

According to reports, the group saturates a market with ads touting low service fees, and when people call for assistance, out-of-state call centers dispatch crews in unmarked vehicles to their homes. Once the crews arrive, however, the price to get inside the house quickly escalates.

Locksmith scam Investigation exposes phony locksmiths

The Better Business Bureau has issued national warnings about the deceptive sales tactics used by the operation. But the BBB said  the operation is hard to track because it uses several business names.

An undercover investigation by WRAL News caught a pair of bogus locksmiths in the act as they drilled the front-door locks on a Cary home and tried to charge the homeowner more than $400.

Paul Atkinson, a licensed locksmith with Marshall's Locksmith Service in Raleigh, inspected the woman's home and said it had standard residential locks on the front door. Because the deadbolt wouldn't be touched – the woman was supposed to have locked her keys inside – Atkinson said a legitimate locksmith could get inside the home for less than $100.

"It should be pretty easy to pick," he said.

The woman called SOS Locksmiths, which has prominent Internet ads for people searching for locksmiths in Raleigh. Within 30 minutes, a white minivan with a Tennessee license plate pulled into her driveway, and two men in street clothes hopped out with a toolbox.

An SOS representative initially told the woman on the phone that getting her inside the house would cost $35. After a quick look at the front door, however, the two men told her they would have to drill the locks. The bill had ballooned to $180.

One man proceeds to drill the deadbolt over the woman's objections that it wasn't locked.

"If the other part wasn't locked, then you wouldn't have needed to break my lock," she said.

"It was locked," the man replied.

After the doorknob lock was drilled, the men opened the door and informed the homeowner that she has high-security locks that will cost an additional $20 each to replace.

"It's a different amount now?" she asked, insisting on getting a calculator from her kitchen to total up the bill.

The final total for the service was $404.98.

After a WRAL News crew confronted the men, they quickly packed up and left without answering any questions – or collecting any payment.

"Couple of slime buckets," the woman said after the men left. "It just made me angry to think someone could come in and take advantage of you like that."

SOS declined to comment on the actions of their locksmiths. When asked where the company was located, a representative said he couldn't give out that information.

Marshall's Locksmith repaired the woman's drilled-out locks in a matter of minutes, but Atkinson said such bogus outfits continue to work in the area, giving the rest of the industry a bad name.

"You feel like you're pressured into paying the higher price. That's outrageous," he said.


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • domotamasi Apr 24, 2009

    just to add additional not value to the discussion............put salt on them.

  • oldfirehorse Apr 24, 2009

    Good lord, people don't even know how to break into their own house anymore? I guess it's a convenience service. So why the alarm about how much they charge? I don't hear anybody weeping about the absolutely absurd and ridiculous charges for mowing grass?

  • SomeRandomGuy Apr 24, 2009

    "What law did they break?"
    I would go with obtaining property by false pretense at mininum, in addition to working without a license.

  • hkypky Apr 24, 2009

    Not sure I see all the "great reporting" here. WRAL get's an atta-boy if they payed for the repair of these people's locks I guess.

    In fairness, I guess there was more "reporting" that went on than there was providing any solution to the problem. Nobody invited the police to the party and chances are the SOS Locksmith folks starring in the video have hit another couple of houses somewhere since this story was posted.

    Titus and loxpick: Thanks for your input. My guess is there's a law that could be applied somewhere. 'Course some of us don't need a law to differentiate between right and wrong.

    Oh, and Superman, so nice to know that every person who has ever locked themselves out of house/home/car, etc. deserved whatever bill they were handed just cuz they weren't the eagle scout you must have been.


  • TallWillow Apr 24, 2009

    Actually, a better solution is to get a combination lock for your front door. I'm not talking about the kind we used to use on our lockers at school, but one specifically made for entry doors. You can change the combination yourself, and use temporary ones if you want, for guests or service people, etc.

    And they cost a heck of a lot less than $400, although they're more expensive than standard door locks.

  • Justin T. Apr 24, 2009

    Good job, WRAL. (This is why I recommend a hidden key... much cheaper and safer than hiring a locksmith.)

  • loxpick Apr 24, 2009

    "What law did they break?" How about working without a license?

  • tran Apr 24, 2009

    They drilled the locks?!? That ought to be a dead giveaway right there. It wasn't more than 3 years ago that a video showing how to make a "bump key" made the rounds. It works on common locks like Schlage or Kwikset but not on the high end stuff like Medeco.

  • superman Apr 24, 2009

    How many thieves you think would have a metal detector walking around your yard trying to find a hidden key. Dont walk out your yard-- you might get hit by a falling airplane too.

  • ConcernedNCC Apr 24, 2009

    The sad fact is that they probably didn't break any laws. The homeowner could have ewasily told them to go and she'd call someone else.