WRAL Investigates

PCBs contaminate Walnut, Rocky Branch creeks

Posted May 13, 2008
Updated May 14, 2008

— Cancer-causing chemicals have been found in two Raleigh waterways, posing a health hazard to people who eat fish caught in them, according to state officials.

Tests by state environmental regulators detected polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs,  in Rocky Branch Creek and Walnut Creek, which flow through south Raleigh and empty into the Neuse River east of the city.

Phil Jeffreys, a former Wake County commissioner, said he urged regulators to test the creeks more than 25 years ago, fearing the sites where he had fished for decades were contaminated.

"Nobody was really interested in it. It did not seem to be important enough at the time," Jeffreys said.

The state Division of Public Health issued a warning last month that people should limit consumption of fish caught in the two creeks. Officials hadn't previously publicly disclosed that the creeks had been tested and that PCBs had been found.

The warning says that people in Wake County should "eat no more than one meal a month of carp or catfish from parts of the Neuse River, Walnut Creek and Rocky Branch, and no more than one meal a week of all other fish caught in Walnut Creek and Rocky Branch."

The advisories, the state says on its Web site, "cover the Neuse River from just below Crabtree Creek to Auburn-Knightdale Road, as well as Walnut Creek and Rocky Branch just upstream of the Neuse. Laboratory tests on fish from those waterways show high levels of PCBs."

PCBs were used as coolants and lubricants in electrical equipment until the late 1970s, when the U.S. banned their production. Federal regulators cited evidence that PCBs build up in the environment and can cause health problems from rashes to liver ailments.

Officials also have designated the chemicals as likely carcinogens.

The Triangle has a tainted history with PCBs:

Thirty years ago, Warren County residents protested when PCB-contaminated soil was dumped in a local landfill. Ward Transformer Co. had used PCBs in its transformers, and workers with the Raleigh-based company sprayed PCB-laced oil along hundreds of miles of state roads.

The soil was eventually dug up and dumped in Warren County, where officials said it could be sequestered. Local protests claiming environmental racism eventually prompted the state to spend $18 million to clean the landfill.

More recently, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has begun preparations to clean PCB-contaminated soil from a former Ward Transformer plant near Raleigh-Durham International Airport.

PCBs on that site leached into Brier Creek and have been found in Brier Creek Reservoir, Lake Crabtree and Crabtree Creek, prompting earlier warnings about fish consumption from those waterways.

Jeffreys said he remembers that Ward Transformer operated a site south of downtown Raleigh, along Rocky Branch Creek, in the 1940s and 1950s, long before it moved to near RDU.

"History is what it was. That's just it," he said. "This is what it was and what happened."

The Division of Public Health tested sediment samples from Rocky Branch Creek and Walnut Creek two years ago and found PCBs at locations upstream and downstream of the former Ward Transformer site, said Doug Campbell, director of the division's Occupational and Environmental Epidemiology Branch.

"We really can't link the PCBs to any specific cause," Campbell said.

Because PCBs sink into sediment, scientists don't believe contact exposure or drinking the water pose major health risks. The primary concern is eating fish that have ingested the chemicals while feeding.

"It's important for people to know there's a risk out there and to avoid eating enough fish that would put them at risk," Campbell said.

Dean Naujoks, of the the Neuse River Foundation, calls the discovery of PCBs in the two tributaries "just another blow to the river."

"How are we going to repair the health of this great river that provides so many people with drinking water and so many recreational opportunities?" Naujoks asked.

Jeffreys said he's frustrated by the fact that the state didn't test the creeks earlier.

"(The contamination) was much higher then, and we've allowed people to eat fish out of it with no restrictions on it," he said.

Campbell said he didn't know why regulators didn't test Rocky Branch Creek – it was once declared the most polluted urban stream in North Carolina – and Walnut Creek years ago.

The relatively low levels of PCBs that have been found and the limited use of the two creeks mean that a cleanup is unlikely, he said, adding that the Division of Public Health doesn't even have money right now to post fish advisory signs along the banks.

He promised, however, state regulators would continue to monitor the waterways. "(As to) what happens in the future, we need to watch it."


This story is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • scientistjo May 14, 2008

    "Why isn't everything routinely tested?" -howdiditgettothis

    Because you don't want to pay taxes.

  • baracus May 14, 2008

    "Why is it that PBCs in fish flesh cause cancer when consumed, but water with PBCs in it does not? That's counterintuitive."

    The PCBs accumulate in the fish and can reach concentrations orders of magnitude higher than are in the water. You probably wouldn't want to drink that water either though.

  • mentalgoose May 14, 2008

    Why is it that PBCs in fish flesh cause cancer when consumed, but water with PBCs in it does not? That's counterintuitive.

  • Shadow213 May 14, 2008

    this isn't surprising. I've known about the PCBs in crabrtree creek for years-- I just naturally figured it'd be everywhere else. It's very disappointing that this issue hasn't come up for this long. I realize that at the time PCBs were used, no one realized they were carcinogenic...but we should've done something to clean up this mess as soon as we figured it out! btw, do people often eat fish they catch from these creeks? ick.

  • CestLaVie May 14, 2008

    "Cancer-causing chemicals"..."designated the chemicals as likely carcinogens"..."

    "The state Division of Public Health issued a warning last month that people should limit consumption of fish caught in the two creeks..." LIMIT CONSUMPTION??? Was this just to cover your behinds so no one could sue you - so you could say "we told you so"?????????

    Arthur: I agree; more should have been done 25 years ago after the Ward Transformer debacle!! More attention & enforcement since then too. NOW they don't have money in Public Health budget for signs??

    davidg: Fired?? You're talking government here, remember?

    Joe: Come on - wake up!!!!!!! It SHOULDN'T take a rocket scientist to figure out why thousands upon thousands of people get cancer & die from it. We are eating, breathing, smelling toxins daily - thanks to big business & lack of government action.

    Past time for EVERYONE to examine their own ingestion & exposure & reaction to these killers.

  • R.O.BdaCZAR May 13, 2008

    Yall out of stories WRA?

  • getrealpeople May 13, 2008

    I didn't know these creeks had fish????

  • Drakula_I_G May 13, 2008

    Um, "Joe" - do a web search on PCB's some time.
    If that was an attempt at humor, it fell very flat.

  • smitty May 13, 2008

    You gotta be pretty hungry to go fishing in Crabtree Creek.

  • Joe May 13, 2008

    Where has it ever been proven that PCBs cause cancer? Show me the proof.