Raleigh, N.C. — An administrative court judge says a former Highway Patrol trooper who lost his job after being accused of abusing his K-9 should be reinstated with back pay and attorney's fees. (Agree with the judge's ruling?)
Senior Administrative Law Judge Fred G. Morrison was also critical of the state agency, saying it has no approved or disapproved training techniques for which handlers should comply.
Former Sgt. Charles Jones was fired Sept. 8 after another trooper turned over two 15-second video clips of Jones suspending his K-9 partner, Ricoh, from a railing and kicking the dog repeatedly to force it to release a chew toy.
In his decision, issued Thursday, Morrison said the Highway Patrol did not give "meaningful consideration" to Jones' responses to the charges against him. (Read Morrison's decision.)
"(The) Respondent has not met the burden of persuading me by the greater weight of the evidence presented that it had just cause, procedurally and substantively, to terminate Petitioner's employment," Morrison wrote.
Jones' case now goes before the North Carolina State Personnel Commission, which will determine whether Jones will be reinstated.
Jones sued the Highway Patrol to regain his job, claiming he was fired only because Gov. Mike Easley's office pressured the state agency to get rid of him – an allegation the Highway Patrol denies.
"We're surprised. We believe this agency did the right thing, based on the investigation, based on the video. "And we stand by that decision that we made," spokesman Lt. Everett Clendenin said Thursday.
Evidence presented at a hearing on the matter in April showed the Patrol had planned to punish Jones with a maximum three-day suspension.
Jones claimed he was unfairly singled out because the Highway Patrol was receiving unwanted attention for trooper misconduct and because of publicity surrounding pro-football player Michael Vick's arrest on dog-fighting charges.
He testified he was following the Highway Patrol's training techniques and was doing only what was necessary to train Ricoh, a particularly aggressive dog that required extra training.
Morrison observed in his decision that handlers' training stressed obedience and control and that troopers were told "to rule with an iron fist" and that "when your dog is not performing, bust his ass" and do whatever works to discipline their dogs.
"My final conclusion is that the State of North Carolina forego the future use of dogs such as Ricoh for law enforcement purposes, unless it purchases fully trained canines to be handled by fully trained troopers who are given specific written compliance techniques."
Bryan Beatty, secretary of the Department of Crime Control and Public Safety, suspended K-9 operations following testimony from Jones' hearing.
He said he was disturbed by evidence that some troopers thought kicking a dog was acceptable training and that testimony about "abusing dogs to get compliance" was inconsistent with an independent review of the K-9 program following Jones' termination in September.
"Dog experts say Trooper Jones conduct was completely unacceptable," Easley said in a statement. "If the state has to resort to that level of cruelty to train dogs demonstrated in the video by Trooper Jones, then they (Highway Patrol) will simply not be in the dog business."
Fired trooper should be reinstated, judge rules
- Reporter: Amanda Lamb
- Photographer: Chad Flowers
- Web Editor: Kelly Gardner
Copyright 2011 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
305 Comments
| MOST | Viewed | Shared | Discussed | |||
Most Viewed Stories
Most Viewed VideosMost Viewed Slideshows
| ||||||
Free Consult w/ Dr.Mann-Dental Implants CALL TODAY
Home Alarm - $0 Down + $25/month
2013 Honda Civic lx $229mo $0 Due at Signing


![[READ STORY]](http://wwwcache.wral.com/asset/news/national_world/national/2013/05/14/12445890/12446751-1368816960-100x75.jpg)
![[VIEW PAGE]](http://wwwcache.wral.com/asset/news/local/2013/05/13/12441232/hahn-100x75.jpg)
![[GALLERY]](http://wwwcache.wral.com/asset/entertainment/2013/03/28/12278304/LNL-100x75.jpg)
![[VIEW PAGE]](http://wwwcache.wral.com/asset/traffic/2009/07/23/5645694/beltline-100x75.jpg)
![[GALLERY]](http://wwwcache.wral.com/asset/entertainment/2013/03/04/12182235/12182236-1362457268-100x75.jpg)

WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.
This story is closed for comments.
You just keep thinking that, because that thinking is exactly why the world is so screwed up.
We're no better and no less than any other being that draws breath on this planet.
"And therin lies the" TRUTH. Until we get that through to the egotistical gray matter that lies between our ears, nothing will ever get better on this planet - only worse. God help us!!!
God bless.
Rev. RB
June 6, 2008 2:42 p.m.
God bless.
Rev. RB
USMC Sergeant
69-72
Semper Fi!!!
June 6, 2008 2:41 p.m.
BALONEY!
You're kind of sentiment is exactly why some are mistreated. They may be tools, but no more so than the officer themselves. And which officer would be ok with being treated like this "tool" was? NONE! Right?
They draw breath, and have hearts and minds, and like all living things, they deserve respect and good treatment.
God bless.
Rev. RB
June 6, 2008 2:39 p.m.
Amen to that! And hopefully everyone will realize this story was originally about the way the State handled the firing of Sgt Jones and the Judges Ruling. Had nothing to do with the animal. Gossip masters at work!
June 6, 2008 2:14 p.m.
June 6, 2008 1:38 p.m.