Local News

Court Opinion Criticized Raleigh's New Police Chief

Posted August 9, 2007

— A federal appeals court ruling last week in a lawsuit involving a Michigan police department was critical of Raleigh's incoming police chief.

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals denied the City of Grand Rapids' motion this week for a new hearing in the matter and criticized Harry Dolan, 49, for waiting six weeks to suspend a police officer after concluding that she was psychologically unfit to continue in her  job. He also had suspended a second female officer on the same grounds.

"Chief Dolan’s decision to wait to suspend the plaintiffs until two months after the injunction hearing raises concern about the sincerity of his belief that the plaintiffs posed a danger to themselves or others," the ruling stated. The issue had grown out of a suit several Grand rapids female officers had filed claiming gender discrimination and other issues.

Raleigh Mayor Charles Meeker said the city was aware of the lawsuit and that Dolan had disclosed it and discussed it at a public forum.

The decision, he said, is another legal step in a longstanding legal battle, and it was nothing that caused him to be concerned about Dolan's ability to serve as police chief.

Dolan acknowledged the matter last month at a public forum before he was named police chief.

"Lawsuits have been certainly difficult times, but even from that negative, watching the police department come together, rally and provide exceptional service, even while living through great adversity, has been some of the highlights of my career," he said.

Dolan, who served 24 years with the Grand Rapids Police Department, nine as chief, replaces former Raleigh police Chief Jane Perlov. He will take over Sept. 4.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • lizard Aug 10, 2007

    female - glad to hear you think you do your job so well

  • female5-0 Aug 10, 2007

    To Fair Tax Now-
    That is a very sexist comment you made about females being police officers. You are a very closed minded person. I have been an officer for 6 years I do my job just as good, if not better than some of my partners. I can't believe there are people like you still in todays society.

  • allswell Aug 10, 2007

    Fair Tax Now-That is too funny

  • yinyangback2u Aug 9, 2007


  • allswell Aug 9, 2007

    There are always two sides

  • ifcdirector Aug 9, 2007

    Your assumption is correct tarheelalum.

  • frayedknot Aug 9, 2007

    From the story: "Dolan, who served 24 years with the Grand Rapids Police Department, nine as chief"...

    Umm. No, he didn't.

  • cryinshame Aug 9, 2007

    he has eyes like nifong, watch out

  • shine Aug 9, 2007

    Let the man do his job - then criticize him - unless any of you are takers.

    Your don't the circumstances of the situation.

  • jhnewman Aug 9, 2007

    to tarheels57:

    You are right on! Regardless of the fun that is poked here, courtesy of Freedom of Speech, citizens have to respect and allow the elected decision makers to do their jobs. I do hope the appointment turns out for the best. I would also hope a very strong relationship will be built with the Durham law enforcement organization. The crime "borders" between those cities are becoming very blurred and transparent to the thugs.