Not All Students Have Benefit of Seat Belts on Buses
Posted December 3, 1996
RALEIGH — The worst is over for a group of preschoolers who dangled from their seatbelts in an overturned bus Monday. Authorities say it was those restraints, required by the Headstart program that was transporting the children, that spared them.
Not all school transportation systems are required to use restraints, however. Only New York and New Jersey require seatbelts on all public school buses. In Wake County, only special education buses are required to have them.
Transportation officials say special construction, including extra padding on seat-backs, makes school bus seats safe, but some parents aren't so sure.
Armanda Noel, whose young son was slightly injured in Monday's crash, says she's thankful he was wearing a seatbelt.
Barbara Lang thinks the time has come for mandatory seatbelts on buses. Her son didn't have one when a commercial bus taking students on a field trip crashed on Sunset Drive last year.
Lang has been campaigning for seatbelts in Wake County and statewide, but without success. One reason is that transportation officials say they believe bus seat construction is as safe, if not safer, than seatbelts. They say children wearing lap-seatbelts tend to hit only their heads on the padded cushion in front of them, while children without restraints receive the impact over a wider range of their bodies. That, they say, reduces the danger of head and neck injuries.
While a Canadian crash test seems to support that view, many parents across the country still worry that a padded seat just isn't enough.
Officials say there is no shoulder belt yet it existence that is safe enough for use on buses. There is a Federal law pending that would require all Headstart buses to have seatbelts installed.