Raleigh, N.C. — Evidence that could be used to convict whomever killed Michelle Young was never collected, even though a document that accompanied her body to the medical examiner's office shows investigators asked for it.
According to the pathology sheet, obtained Thursday by WRAL, agents with Wake County's City-County Bureau of Investigation, requested tests to determine whether Young had either been sexually assaulted or had sex prior to her death.
Young, 29, was found dead inside her south Raleigh home on Nov. 3. An autopsy later revealed she died from blunt force trauma to the head. Authorities still have not made an arrest in the case.
Sexual assault kits are normally only performed when there is obvious evidence at the crime scene or on the victim's body. Otherwise, investigators must request those tests.
Young was fully clothed when her body arrived at the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner.
The CCBI, which collects forensic evidence in all homicide cases, asked for several types of evidence from the autopsy: blood, hair (both head and pubic), clothing and the sexual assault kit.
CCBI Director Sam Pennica said his agency also made the request to a member of the medical examiner's staff, but for some reason, the sexual assault tests were never performed. If it is collected during an autopsy, it is indicated on the autopsy report, but there was no mention of a sexual assault examination on Young's report.
"The medical examiner is in charge of the body, not us," Pennica said. "We can only request what we would like to have -- what we feel is important to the investigation."
In criminal cases, investigators try to get as much evidence as possible to identify and eliminate suspects.
Legal experts say that when the case goes to trial, a lack of evidence, such as the sexual assault kit, could cast reasonable doubt for a jury and make it difficult for a conviction.
"Certainly, it leaves an area of unanswered questions," Pennica said.
Investigators, however, do have other methods of obtaining the evidence.
It's unclear why the evidence was not collected and Chapel Hill's chief medical examiner, Dr. John Butts, doesn't know, because he said he has not had a chance to talk to pathologist Dr. Thomas Clark, who performed the autopsy, about that piece of evidence.
"I wasn't there," he said. "If a decision was made not to collect that kit, I don't know why that decision was made."
Butts did say, however, that requests on the pathology sheet often change once a body is ready for autopsy. But those requests aren't always documented on the sheet and that the sheet isn't always used during the autopsy.
"The fact that someone checked something doesn't mean that request was conveyed to us," he said.
Evidence Not Collected in Young Murder Case
- Reporter: Amanda Lamb
- Photographer: Chad Flowers
- Web Editor: Kelly Gardner
Copyright 2009 by Capitol Broadcasting Company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
48 Comments
-
- Report: 18 counties have poverty levels above 20 percent
Updated Nov. 24 6:58 p.m. |
- Online help for holiday shopping
Updated 45 minutes ago |
- MADD launches program to curb holiday drunken driving
Posted at 12:30 a.m. | Slideshow |
- Gov. puts rush on unemployment benefits for ConAgra workers
Posted Nov. 24 5:17 p.m. | Slideshow |
- Girl's death could impact state programs to protect children
Updated Nov. 24 11:20 p.m. |
- Report: 18 counties have poverty levels above 20 percent
- Most Viewed Slideshows
- Pet Photos | November 23 - November 29, 2009
Updated Nov. 24 11:42 p.m. - Scandalous entertainment moments
Posted Nov. 24 5:24 p.m. - Thousands cheer Palin during Bragg book-signing
Nov. 23, 2009
- Pet Photos | November 23 - November 29, 2009
Photo Spotlight
-
Bands, marchers in holiday paradeChoose your group to watch their performance in the 2009 WRAL-TV Raleigh Christmas Parade.
-
Web only: Complete 2009 WRAL-TV Raleigh Christmas ParadeWatch the parade in its entirety from the comfort of your computer any time.
-
Search for missing IRS refundsThe Internal Revenue Service released the names this week of more than 100,000 taxpayers who have not received their 2009 income tax refund.
-
North Carolina unemployment ratesView an interactive map with county unemployment numbers.
-
A year of N.C. Drought MapsView a time lapse animation of drought conditions during the last year.










STORIES
VIDEOS
SLIDESHOWS

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.
You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.