Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

Login Options

9:26 a.m. • 2-10-12

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Rain.
    • Hi: 58° F
  • Sat: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 54° F
  • Sun: Clear.
    • Hi: 43° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image

Marketplace Links

Social Links

Main Menu

Death Penalty up for Debate at Cary Forum


e-mail print friendly
Death Row, Death Penalty, Execution (Generic)
Death Row, Death Penalty, Execution (Generic)

Wake County District Attorney Colon Willoughby and others debated both sides of the death penalty at a forum in Cary Tuesday night.

There are 166 inmates on Death Row in North Carolina, but recent rulings have brought executions to a standstill. At an event hosted by the Western Wake Democratic Club, people close to the subject shared their thoughts on capital punishment, sometimes telling intensely personal stories.

"I'm here as a victims advocate. I am the brother of a homicide victim,” said panelist Wayne Uber.

Others, like Willoughby, said they carry the weight of the people with their every move.

"If folks are opposed to capital punishment, we ought to ask the legislature to stop it,” he said. “We ought not to take one particular group to give us an ethical opinion that it's wrong."

What Willoughby referred to was a January decision by North Carolina's medical board to adopt a policy that declares it unethical for a physician to participate in executions. That was one point that panelist Dr. Robert Bilbro said he disagrees with.

"It's unethical for doctors to intentionally do harm to their patients,” Bilbro said.

The medical board’s ruling led to a Wake County judge to halt several planned executions. State officials would need to adopt a new protocol to get around the policy. Death penalty supporters argue the legislation limbo is a burden for victims’ families.

"They are just emotionally drained,” said Mel Chilton, a member of a victims’ support group. “It is something that they've been going through for more than 10 years."

But that’s a point that some feel shouldn't affect state policy.

"Most observers say it's a brutalizing effect,” said anti-death penalty advocate Jim French. “The message the death penalty gives is that life is cheap. To some degree, some lives don't mean as much."

RELATED TOPICS: Wake County, Death Penalty, Cary

e-mail print friendly

51 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

View Comments VIEW ALL 51 COMMENTS

This story is closed for comments.

Latest Comments
Smorgas_Of_Borg,

Interesting observation. While I have known people that were opposed to the death penalty make an exception when some real sickco comes along, I’ve never seen them totally change their philosophy. I’m always interested in WHY someone such as yourself, goes from believer to opposer. Is it really the fear of an innocent getting whacked? I once had a co-worker that was uber-LeftWing. He said he opposed it for that reason. But given a hypothetical situation of himself being a witness to the crime, therefore knowing for sure of the guilt, he STILL opposed the death penalty, citing such silliness as he might couldn’t trust his own eyes. Clearly he was opposed because of other reasons, and the fear for the innocent was just a convenient response. So, what about cases in which guilt is certain (i.e. 14 witnesses, gun in hand, video, confession, God even takes the witness stand for the prosecution, etc.)?

Most of you will recall Michael Peterson from Durham who was given a life sentence for killing his wife-- The last I heard of him he was at a camp--working in the print shop and tutoring GED. He is not locked up-- just a fence around the prison. He gets the same kind of treatment that Martha Stewart and Meg S. Phillips. With a life sentence he gets the same treatment in prison that a person would get from writing bad cheeks, or DUI. He just gets to stay there longer-- but he is not locked in a cell. He gets to stand by the fence and wave at all the people working to support him. A person with a life sentence should at least have to serve it locked up in a cell 24/7-- He is also paid to work in the print shop if he is still assigned there. A life sentence is served the same way a 2 year sentence is served-- no different in his assignment. He can walk around the prison unit all day if he is not working

I work in a medical facility where inmates come and go all day long. Did you know that we have to "fix" a death row inmate before they can be executed?!? I quite personally don't care if they are experiencing a little bit of back pain while being administered the lethal injection. They had no regard for the pain and suffering of their victims. But what a joy it is to see my tax dollars at work! NOT! There are so many more things in North Carolina that tax money should be going towards, but instead we spend years supporting inmates, paying all their expenses until their appeals run out just so we can kill them! Does anyone else see a problem here? I do understand where those of you come from who are concerned about the few innocents who get convicted, but for those of you bleeding hearts who believe in "rehabilitation" or have a generous moral standard... it would be an injustice to the victim to let the murderer live.

Smorgas. I just can't help but think about Jessica Lunsford buried alive inside a trashbag in the ground. I think of her crying and not being able to see her father and mother ever again. It kills me inside to think that there is a person capable of hurting someone to that magnitude. Maybe I am a little bias since I am a cop and I see the dirtbags of society at their very worst. I just want to be honest. There are some people that don't deserve to walk this earth.

sick, the simplest answer to why I came to oppose the death penalty is that it is the only sentence in our legal system that, once carried out, cannot be corrected if a mistake was shown to have been made. This is precisely what happened in England to bring about a total ban on the death penalty there. One man was convicted of murder, sentenced to death, and hanged. Years later it was discovered that his downstairs neighbor had committed the crime. The outrage was such that no power nor 'morality' on earth could prevent the end of the death penalty there. I would prefer to see us go to a system with life without parole BEFORE an innocent is proven to have been executed. If that ever happens here, the death penalty WILL be history in the USA. Our collective morality would settle for nothing less.

View Comments VIEW ALL 51 COMMENTS
Report It

Multimedia

Click Here