Council of State Approves Death Penalty Protocol
The new "execution protocol" was approved on a voice vote by the Council of State. Gov. Mike Easley said the vote would move the issue where it belonged—back before the courts and with lawmakers at the General Assembly.
The council—the governor, lieutenant governor and the elected heads of eight state government agencies—was forced into the state's ongoing debate over capital punishment by Superior Court Judge Donald W. Stephens. Last month, he placed three executions on hold, citing a law written in 1909 that requires the governor and the council to approve any change in the state's execution procedure.
State corrections officials changed the protocol while trying to resolve the role a doctor must play in the execution process.
State law requires a doctor be present at an execution, but the North Carolina Medical Board said in January that a "physician who engages in any verbal or physical activity ... that facilitates the execution may be subject to disciplinary action."
Meanwhile, the state said in response to a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of lethal injection that a nurse and a medical technician , not a doctor, would monitor a condemned inmate's vital signs. The state said a doctor would only observe the execution and later sign a death certificate.
That change was apparently designed to satisfy both the medical board and the demands of the federal court, which had previously agreed to let an execution proceed only after the state said a physician and a registered nurse would be present to ensure the inmate did not suffer pain as he was put to death.
But the change also led to Stephens' ruling, and he stayed the executions of Marcus Reymond Robinson, James Adolph Campbell and James Edward Thomas until the council approved the new procedure.
Attorney General Roy Cooper, who voted to approve the new protocol and did not speak with reporters after the meeting, did not immediately return a call seeking comment about whether his office would ask Stephens to vacate his orders.
Secretary of State Elaine Marshall, Superintendent of Public Instruction June Atkinson and Insurance Commissioner Jim Long, all Democrats, voted against the proposal.
"I don't find that we've got jurisdiction to even get into an issue like this," Long said. "I'm very concerned about the Council of State trying to override the state medical board."
Although the council's vote should meet the requirements of the 1909 law, the new execution procedure appears to increase the role of a doctor. Instead of tasking a nurse and medical technician with monitoring an inmate's vital signs, it requires a physician to monitor "the essential body functions of the condemned inmate" and notify the warden if the inmate shows signs of "undue pain and suffering."
Several defense attorneys with clients awaiting execution have said that appears to conflict with the dictates of the medical board, which decided in January that a doctor's participation in capital punishment constitutes "a departure from the ethics of the medical profession."
"The way things have been done today are backward," said Ann Groniger, who represents Thomas. A spokeswoman for the medical board has said the organization won't comment on the new protocol until the full board reviews it.
Easley said he expected the overall question of what role doctors should play will be litigated for some time before ending up before the Legislature.
"No one anticipated the Council of State would be involved in this at this stage, given the complexity of the problem," Easley said.
That's an opinion shared both by defense attorneys and several lawmakers, who at a meeting Monday of a commission examining flaws in the state's death penalty system said the General Assembly must ultimately resolve the issue.
"I have never seen legislators run as fast away from taking on their legislative responsibilities as I have today," said Rep. Paul Luebke, D-Durham, after the panel decided to wait for Tuesday's council meeting before discussing a proposal for an execution moratorium.
"I don't understand ... why the General Assembly would not want to clarify the statute if we have the medical board saying a doctor can't participate even if the needle is put in improperly."
- Reporters: John Bachman, Cullen Browder
- Web Editor: Kamal Wallace
86 Comments
-
- Documents uncover conflicting accounts of Cooper marriage
Updated Jul. 23 11:42 p.m. |
- Second-grader left by bus driver
Updated Jul. 23 11:14 p.m. |
- Man charged in armed robbery spree
Updated Jul. 23 7:28 p.m. |
- As minimum wage increases, low-income families still struggle
Updated Jul. 23 7:46 p.m. |
- Ag commissioner: N.C. peppers are safe
Updated Jul. 23 11:15 p.m. |
- Documents uncover conflicting accounts of Cooper marriage
- Most Viewed Slideshows
- Hurricane Dolly causes destruction
Posted Jul. 23 6:43 p.m. - Nancy Cooper case images
Jul. 17, 2008 - Pet Photos | July 21 - July 27, 2008
Updated Jul. 23 4:07 p.m.
- Hurricane Dolly causes destruction
-
10 questions with Durham Schools SuperintendentSuperintendent Carl Harris answers your questions about the school system.
-
10 questions with WRAL Anchor Debra MorganWRAL Anchor Debra Morgan answers your questions about TV news.
-
10 questions with Raleigh Police Chief Harry DolanRaleigh's police chief answers your questions about officers' pay, panhandlers, violent crime ...
(8 votes) second-grader left by bus driver
(1 votes) ask fifi: fifi investigates | lucybelle
-
Capitol Broadcasting unveils live, mobile TVAlmost 12 years to the day that WRAL-TV went “live” as the first commercial high-definition station in the nation, parent company Capitol…
-
The Amistad Saga: ReflectionsThe 1839 mutiny about the slaveship Amistad is re-created in this outdoor drama, featuring music, dance and speeches. "The Amistad Saga:…
-
Grocery Cart TrackerWorried about rising food prices? Use our interactive Grocery Cart Tracker to compare local prices on popular items.
-
Fuel Tracker: Find lowest gas pricesOur Fuel Tracker can help you find the lowest prices by zip code or city. And sign up for e-mail alerts, too.
-
What is salmonella and how can it be avoided?What is salmonella and how can it be avoided?




STORIES
VIDEOS
SLIDESHOWS



Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.
You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.