State Must Satisfy Judge to Keep Executions on Schedule

Judge: Physician Boycott Would Prevent Executions
A Wake County judge said Wednesday that he would block three scheduled executions if state officials cannot come up with a protocol for carrying out the death penalty without physicians.

Superior Court Judge Donald W. Stephens said North Carolina wouldn't be able to comply with its death-penalty statute if a new rule prohibiting physicians from participating in executions is upheld. He gave Gov. Mike Easley and the Council of State until 10 a.m. Thursday to devise a new protocol for carrying out executions.

Without a new protocol, Stephens said he would issue an injunction to halt the three executions scheduled for the next two weeks until the legal issues could be resolved.

"Unless the governor and the Council of State have found that qualified personnel is not required — the participation by a licensed physician — this court cannot approve an execution," Stephens said.

Marcus Robinson is to be executed Friday for the 1991 murder of a Fayetteville teenager. James Edward Thomas is scheduled to be executed Feb. 2, and James Adoph Campbell is scheduled to be put to death on Feb. 9.

Attorneys for Robinson and Thomas asked Stephens to block the executions on the grounds that the state can't assure they would die without pain.

"We asked the court to look at that and to grant an injunction to give us some time to look at those questions, since one of those injections is scheduled for less than 48 hours, said Ann Groninger, the attorney for Thomas.

North Carolina uses lethal injection for executions, and state law requires that a physician be present when inmates receive the deadly cocktail.

But the North Carolina Medical Board last week approved a policy that prohibits physicians from participating in executions, saying doing so would violate the profession's ethics. Anyone violating the rule could lose his or her medical license.

Geoffrey Hosford, an attorney for Robinson, said the intent of law is to have a physician participating in executions. A ruling last April by U.S. District Judge Malcolm Howard in another death-penalty case said that the doctor must monitor vital functions during the execution, Hosford said.

State House minority leader Paul Stam said the current law should take precedent over any medical board policy.

"The medical society can't trump the decision of the elected members of the assembly who have decided that that is the appropriate punishment for premeditated deliberate murder," Stam said.

Tom Pitman, an attorney with the Attorney General's Office, said the law states that a physician simply must be present at an execution and sign the death certificate, which Pitman said would  not violate the new Medical Board policy.

Other medical professionals, such as nurses and paramedics, are present to handle the execution, and the licensing boards for those groups have taken no public position on the execution issue, Pitman said.

But Robert Zaytoun, an attorney for death-row inmate James Edward Thomas, said the law didn't intend for the physician to be "a potted plant" and that the Medical Board policy creates a "moral and legal conundrum."

Stephens agreed with the inmates' lawyers, saying the state's argument doesn't make sense. Standing by at an execution creates "an awkward position for a medical professional," he said.

Thirty state lawmakers have sent a letter to Easley calling for him to suspend executions. They referred to states like Florida, where Gov. Jeb Bush issued a moratorium after a botched lethal injection.


43 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.

View Comments View Comments

Ask Anything
  1. WRAL.com moderator
    10 questions with a WRAL.com moderator

    A WRAL.com moderator answers your questions about comments on stories, abuse reports and more.

  2. Bryan Beatty
    10 questions with N.C. Secretary of Crime Control & Public Safety

    Bryan Beatty answers your questions about homeland security, gang prevention and illegal immigrants.

  3. David Heckel
    10 questions with Funeral Director David Heckel

    Funeral Director David Heckel answers your questions about embalming, cremation and burial.

Multimedia
  1. WRAL Election 2008 logo
    Watch 2008 debates

    N.C. voters have two tough choices to make at leadership positions. Play back the debate video from races from president to lt. governor and see…

  2. Offshore drilling, offshore oil rig
    Voters talk about big issues of 2008

    Energy, the economy, health care and the war in Iraq resonate most with voters in the upcoming presidential election.

  3. North Carolina upends UConn 38-12

    The Heels made a strong statement with their resounding victory over previously undefeated UConn Saturday night.

  4. 00 bc ncsu.jpg
    State comes up short against Boston College, 38-31

    N.C. State came back from a 14-point defecit in the 4th quarter against Boston College, but lost the game when the Eagles scored a touchdown with…

  5. Vice_Presidential_Debate
    Biden, Palin debate issues

    Republican Sarah Palin and Democrat Joe Biden sparred over taxes, energy policy and the Iraq war in a high-profile debate Thursday night.