Debate Over Who Controls Insurance Rates Continues

Debate Over Who Controls Insurance Rates Continues

A legislative committee Wednesday heard arguments for and against a proposal that would give auto insurance companies more control over the rates they charge consumers.

The industry wants a free-market system that would take control of the rates away from North Carolina's commissioner of insurance, who is elected.

Senate Bill 901, which calls for an impartial panel to set rates, was pulled from the Legislature last May so that lawmakers could further study it.

The Joint Legislative Study Committee on Automobile Insurance Modernization decided Wednesday that it needs more information about the matter.

Commissioner of Insurance Jim Long said he thinks the current system is working for all parties involved.

North Carolina drivers have the sixth-lowest insurance rates in the nation, and insurance companies are making a profit, Long said.

"We've got companies coming in every year to write auto insurance business in North Carolina. They're making a profit – they're making a healthy profit. We want them to make a profit," Long said.

Long and others fear premiums could increase if insurers get more control.

"In a captive market, where consumers have no choice but to buy auto insurance, there has to be a third-party regulator to ensure customers don't get ripped off," Consumer advocate Rob Thompson, with the North Carolina Public Interest Research Group, said.

Insurance companies have contended that Long's political power puts them at a disadvantage.

Historically, they typically ask for much higher rates than they get, and when they appeal the rates enforced by the Department of Insurance in court, Long almost always wins.

Insurers also point to fairness for bad and risky motorists.

"The point is the rates need to be right for everyone," said Joe Stewart, executive director of the Insurance Federation of North Carolina. "If you are a good risk, you deserve a great rate, and you shouldn't subsidize someone else's accidents."



31 Comments


Golo

Welcome to GOLO, where WRAL.com visitors can comment on stories and create profile pages, blogs and photo galleries.

You must be a registered WRAL.com user to use these tools. Click here to register or log in.

View Comments View Comments

Report It
Send us your news photos, videos, tips and story ideas.
Submit Videos Submit Photos Submit Reports
  1. APTOPIX_People_Michael_Jackson
    Michael Jackson (1958-2009)

    The life and death of Michael Jackson in video and photos.

  2. Drought Map
    A year of N.C. Drought Maps

    View a time lapse animation of drought conditions during the last year.

  3. Antiques Roadshow
    'Antiques Roadshow' in Raleigh

    The "Antiques Roadshow" taped Saturday, June 27, 2009, at the Raleigh Convention Center, where over 5,000 ticket holders lined up to learn what…

  4. Film_Review_Ice_Age
    The week in entertainment

    A look at the top entertainment stories this week through the lenses of Associated Press photographers.

  5. APTOPIX_World_s_Ugliest_Dog
    The week in photos

    A look at the top news, politics and business stories this week through the lenses of Associated Press photographers.