NC education leaders: Transgender students' bathroom usage up to local school boards

Posted May 9, 2016

House Bill 2

— As legal battles emerge over whether North Carolina's House Bill 2 discriminates against LGBT people, state education leaders say local school boards must decide where transgender students should use the bathroom.

House Bill 2 requires transgender people to use public bathrooms that match their birth gender. But the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction has not offered any guidance to the state's 115 public school systems about the law or its possible impact on transgender students.

"That is a local question," said DPI spokeswoman Vanessa Jeter. "They seem to be handling bathroom issues well at the local level."

It's unclear exactly how many transgender students are enrolled in North Carolina public schools because DPI does "not collect data at this time," according to Jeter.

Attorneys for the Wake County Public School System are reviewing the law and recent developments to determine "what impact, if any, it has on our school system," according to spokeswoman Lisa Luten.

The Wake County school district does not have a policy on transgender students and bathroom use, according to Luten, but transgender students can request permission to use bathrooms matching their gender identity. The student must have permission from his or her parents.

"Just because they make a request doesn't mean it's granted," Luten said.

Some requests have been granted in the past, but Luten was not able to say how many because the district does not keep data on that. She also was not sure if any transgender students are currently using bathrooms matching their gender identity. She would need to contact every school to find out, she explained.

Some transgender students use private bathrooms or staff bathrooms in Wake County schools, Luten said.

In Durham Public Schools, House Bill 2 has not changed the way they handle bathroom usage, according to spokeswoman Chrissy Deal.

"We advise principals to work with the student and family individually to find a restroom he or she can use privately," she said. "The solutions may vary by school, but we leave that to the principals and team at the school. This is how it was handled prior to HB2 as well."

Although the solutions may vary, Deal says transgender students have never been allowed to use bathrooms matching their gender identity. Instead, schools may let them use a single-person bathroom or staff bathroom.

"We had been having this conversation before HB2 passed. We had a lawyer come in and give advice to our principals. We were beginning to see students come in with different levels of discomfort," Deal said. "Students' comfort, respect and dignity are at the top of our list of priorities."

The Durham County Board of Education has been vocal in its opposition to House Bill 2. Board members passed a resolution in April that called for the law to be repealed, saying that they oppose "discrimination, prejudice, homophobia, and transphobia."

NC may lose federal education funding

Since House Bill 2 was passed, education leaders have been waiting to see whether North Carolina will lose federal education funding because of it.

The state receives an estimated $4.5 billion in federal support each year for schools, roads, the environment and other programs, and such funding could be at risk if the government believes the state is flouting federal law.

Public schools alone account for about $1.4 billion in federal funding to the state. Bill Cobey, chairman of the State Board of Education, said losing that money would hurt the students who need the most support.

For example, more than 750,000 North Carolina students last year benefited from the program that subsidizes school lunches so that students from low-income families can eat lunch for free or at a reduced price, which received $505 million from the government.

The Every Student Succeeds Act, the successor to No Child Left Behind, provides $534 million in federal funds to the state to help low-income schools, as well as support English as a second language programs and education for homeless children.

The government also provides $306 million for special education programs through the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and $32 million for career and technical education.


Please with your WRAL.com account to comment on this story. You also will need a Facebook account to comment.

Oldest First
View all
  • Amanda Townsend May 10, 2016
    user avatar

    I agree that it should be a case-by-case review. We cannot put the comfort and privacy of the TG students above the comfort and privacy of other students, in my opinion. It is not a violation of rights, I don't believe, but an application of common sense. I cannot see harm in allowing a TG student to use a unigender bathroom, single stall bathroom, or staff bathroom. I don't see how that harms the TG student at all. I don't see how that does not all the TG student appropriate rights.

  • Roy Pine May 10, 2016
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    I really believe this is a local issue and if the state government decides it wants to override the wishes of local residents expressed through their local governments, then we as residents should stop paying state taxes. I like that for sure.

    Someone needs to go back and retake Civics 101.

  • Tracy Darren May 10, 2016
    user avatar

    Michael, this is one of the many reasons my child will remain in private school. If they open the locker rooms and bathrooms as they have in the Chicago government schools, then I expect the private schools will get a lot more crowded.

  • Michael Bawden May 10, 2016
    user avatar

    And people wonder why private schools are flourishing in this state. Then we hear the liberals complain about the haves and the have nots. How the private school kids have such a large advantage over those attending public school. What are they actually admitting?

    Those that agree with the liberals will continue to go to public school. Those that don't will flock to a private/home school.

    Check the numbers. People are voting with their feet. And is not in favor of the liberal LGBT, social engineering practices.

  • Elizabeth Hawkins May 9, 2016
    user avatar

    I really believe this is a state issue and if the federal government decides it wishes to stop any federal funding coming into this state to help with education, the we as citizens of this state stop contributing as payees into the federal government tax system. In other words we NC pay no federal taxes again. I like that for sure.