Miserable marriage? In five years, yours could be a love story
Posted March 9
Couples who hang on when their marriage seems too rocky to endure are likely to be very happy together a few years later, according to studies from England, the United States and Canada that suggest marital unhappiness is a phase and couples are not powerless to fix their problems.
"Couples on the Brink" from the Marriage Foundation in England looked specifically at unhappy couples whose children were very young and found those who stayed together were quite apt to be happy a decade later. Other research, including the six-university collaborative National Divorce Decision-Making Project led by Brigham Young University in 2015, has considered marital happiness more generally, rather than focusing on new parents. But the findings are similar: Unhappiness is seldom a permanent condition, and most couples can improve and save their marriages.
"The message is that ups and downs are normal and if you're going through a tough time, hang in there because things will almost certainly improve," said Harry Benson, research director of the Marriage Foundation in Cambridge, England, and co-author of the report. "I know when my own marriage was in a bad place, it was so bleak that we couldn't imagine a way out."
He said the research showed two things: "First, that unhappy parents are rarer than one might imagine; second that unhappiness is almost always a phase. Out of 10,000 mums, just 23 were still unhappy when their child was aged 11. Permanent unhappiness is incredibly rare."
The study said that "perhaps surprisingly, the biggest risk of splitting up over the subsequent decade or so is borne by parents who are … neither happy nor unhappy, neither on the brink or not on the brink."
The small percentage who believe they are close to a breakup "do about as well as the parents who say they are not." The findings do not hold for couples who are not married. "The extent to which cohabiting couples think they are on the brink is a linear predictor of stability," the report said. "The more doubt, the bigger the risk. In all cases, their risk is higher than among married couples."
"There can certainly be a death of a marriage," agreed Alan J. Hawkins, professor of Family Life at Brigham Young University, who has studied the issue in America and led the collaboration of American and Canadian researchers in the decision-making project. "But most of the time, you can work on, improve and revitalize a marriage."
Hanging in, not up
"We are so happy right now," Sherry Anderson proclaims, smiling at Frank, her spouse of 25 years, over breakfast sandwiches in a cafe. "I couldn't have imagined this. You had to have seen what it was like."
It is a declaration that feels miraculous to the couple because a decade ago, they were headed for divorce. Worse, they'd reached a point of disconnect where neither cared much. They were mostly biding their time until the youngest two of their 10-child blended family were grown — the two they had together, ages 10 and 12. They would wait, they decided, because each had seen what divorce did to the children they'd had in their first marriages. They were going to coexist and avoid each other when they could until the kids were all out of the house.
The Andersons had been fighting for some time — about money, about interactions with step-children, about boundaries. Frank Anderson jokes now that if they wrote a book about that tumultuous time, they'd call it "You're Not the Boss of Me." He spent most of his time at work or downstairs. She seethed, not always silently.
They saw a series of counselors but didn't find one that both liked or with whom both felt comfortable. They were still going to church, but even their bishop had given up on their marriage. He suggested a different church leader might be able to help, but said he'd personally run out of ideas.
The Andersons' rough patch is "normative," according to Hawkins, whose own recent research found that 25 percent of the married couples in a national survey said they'd thought about divorce in the past six months and another 28 percent said they hadn't recently considered it, but they had in the past because of serious problems.
Of those 28 percent who had chosen to remain married in spite of problems, 89 percent said they were glad they stayed together, Hawkins said.
"Thinking about divorce is common," Hawkins noted, "but most of the problems are not the most serious and most dangerous kinds of problems and they do suggest the possibility of being able to resolve them."
About one-fifth of those surveyed who described themselves as unhappily married actually divorced over the next five years in the American/Canadian study, which included researchers from Brigham Young University, University of North Texas, University of Minnesota, Montana State University, University of Missouri and University of Alberta.
About half of them five years later described themselves as happily married to each other. Another roughly 20 percent said, "I'm better, but I'm not up there in the happy range," he told the Deseret News.
Seeking help, or not
Chronic unhappiness is a roughly 1 in 10 experience, said Hawkins, who noted that people take different steps to try to save their marriages.
"There's one group that's doing everything they can; seeking professional help from a religious leader, from a counselor, going to a marriage-strengthening class," he said. "They are doing self-help kinds of things and talking to others. But what we find more commonly is people are not seeking out a lot of professional help."
Only 40 percent received any counseling, including religious counseling, Hawkins noted. About 10 percent tried a marriage-strengthening class. "The more common things are the more private things: We had a serious conversation about what we need to do. We just worked harder to solve some of our problems," he said.
The BYU-led research also found that the ambivalent couples were most at risk.
"What we know is that most divorces come from low-conflict marriages," he said. "Most of the problems are issues around 'we've kind of lost our connection,' 'we seem to be falling out of love.' Not to trivialize, but they are the kind of garden-variety problems that couples face. They don't indicate the marriage is dangerous or unhealthy, it's just stale and unsatisfying."
Some marriages are difficult to save. Factors Benson thinks put marriages in the small-chance category include abuse, abandonment, addiction or adultery.
Fighting through it
While it's better if both parties try to fix what's not working, an effort by one partner in the union can change the trajectory, said Hawkins.
Just as the negative attitude of one person can send a relationship spiraling, one's positive attitude can infuse hope, especially if it's "rooted in kindness. There's always hope. It's never over until it's over. What changed for us was that I eventually realized I needed to put my wife first. That little mental shift put us on solid ground and with a chance for the first time. We've now been married 30 years and have six kids: we must be doing something right," Benson said.
Couples respond to different solutions and what works for one may not be a cure-all for another. But they're worth considering.
The Andersons had several turning points. First, they negotiated some boundaries. They agreed to not discuss their marriage with anyone outside a small group they both felt were invested enough to root for them instead of taking sides. That meant counselors and their parents were in, but everyone else was out.
UK researcher Benson and his wife sat down with wise friends. "They were on our side. They never put either of us down. They made us feel normal, they wanted our marriage to succeed, and they gave us practical hope. So that's my No. 1 piece of advice to couples who are struggling. Sit down with wise older friends."
The Andersons said they benefited more from marriage coaching than from counseling. With the latter, you talk about problems. Coaching focuses on what would correct them.
Frank Anderson calls himself "a nice guy who forgets things." That was important to him in the negotiations to work things out. He told Sherry if she could accept that instead of badgering him about it, he would work on his behaviors that bothered her.
When he overstepped one of their boundaries, he owned the mistake and apologized.
Both say sage counsel from their church leaders helped. While they said they didn't know how to fix their relationship, they figured God did. One leader told them he wanted them to pray together about their marriage every day. "We can do that," Frank Anderson said.
Then he told them he wanted them to do it while holding hands.
"Oh," they thought. They'd each been praying for the other to change. But as they prayed together for their union, they became partners in fixing it. "It's impossible to hold hands with someone and hear them pray about the marriage and stay mad," he said. "That was huge."
Five years ago, their relationship had turned around. Frank Anderson said he'd gone from not knowing how he would stay with her to not being able to picture being with anyone else.
Email: firstname.lastname@example.org, Twitter: Loisco