McCrory threatens fight over coal ash commission

Posted August 23, 2014

Gov. Pat McCrory

— Gov. Pat McCrory says he's likely to sign the coal ash cleanup bill lawmakers sent him on the last day of session, but he also suggested his administration could take state lawmakers to court over it.

McCrory made the comments in an interview with Tom Campbell on NC Spin this week.

McCrory said the bill's creation of an independent coal ash oversight commission, appointed by House and Senate leaders and the governor, blurs the separation of powers of different branches of the government – just one example, he added, among several such proposals lawmakers advanced this year.

"I'm going to have to fight them from a constitutional standpoint, including even the coal ash commission," he told Campbell. "I think this concept of creating commissions that are appointed by the legislature – or a majority by the legislature – is unconstitutional, regardless of the subject. Because that means the legislature is doing the operations of state government, which is not their responsibility. I think there's a constitutional issue there.

"If those commissions start doing a bad job," he added, "there's no one in control."

Asked whether Duke Energy's shareholders or customers should pay for the clean up of the utility's 33 coal ash ponds around the state, the governor said that decision should be made by the state Utilities Commission.

"I think it'll end up being some sort of shared process, just like it is with nuclear power or any other type of power were dealing with. Right now, it's a shared process, by the way, even with solar power and other types of power which are subsidized," McCrory said.

"But," he continued, "Duke's got to take care of their responsibility, and they did some shoddy work. They did some shoddy work with the dams, they did some shoddy work in their communications, and they did some shoddy work on the infrastructure underneath the dams, and I'm very critical of the way they've handled it. But at the same time, we've got to fix it and make sure that doesn't happen again."

On the topic of the economic incentives package voted down by the House last week after it was tied to other legislation, McCrory said he wasn't surprised it failed to pass.

"Frankly, I'm not upset at the House, even though I wanted the majority of the bill," the governor said, noting that he had criticized Democratic leaders for similar "Christmas tree" bills when they were in the majority.

"There were parts of the bill that had no relevance to the other part of the bill, and that's not the way you should do legislation," he said.

The full interview airs Sunday morning at 6:30 on WRAL.


This blog post is closed for comments.

Oldest First
View all
  • Matt Wood Aug 27, 2014
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    Ding ding ding! He should veto it, let them override it, THEN take them to court. Otherwise, he is also implicated in the passage of the bill.

  • Stacie Hagwood Aug 26, 2014
    user avatar

    Grow some bigger marbles, gov! If you feel so strongly about it,don't sign it? YOu've been their puppet for too long.

    And how do you expect to win a challenge if you AGREED to it?

  • Tammy Rush Aug 26, 2014
    user avatar

    "the Utilities Commission has ALREADY factored in PROPER waste storage & maintenance of facilities into the customers rates for decades upon decades!" -- SIXNITEPKG


  • CherryDarling Aug 26, 2014

    Duke's got to take care of their responsibility... Sooooo, what you're trying NOT to say is that they are really the ones that need to pay for this mess they caused? Speak plain English and not all this double talk...

  • oakcity Aug 26, 2014

    if he really cared, he wouldn't sign the bill and he would call them back to session to address this problem.

  • Paul Maxwell Aug 25, 2014
    user avatar

    This 'administration' gets funnier every day. And I'm gonna laugh all the way to the voting booth.

  • dirtydozen431 Aug 25, 2014

    Democrats caused it and took Duke money.

  • 42_wral_mods_suck_i'm_gone Aug 25, 2014

    Isn't it cute. The gov and GA fighting over who get to shaft the NC tax payer.

  • Eric Hammond Aug 25, 2014
    user avatar

    don't think for one minute that someone in his family doesn't own his Duke stock.....
    scubagirl2 Aug 25, 1:07 p.m.

    Scary that to some people it's somehow o.k. for him and/or anyone in his family to be holding utilities stock, since as the son of a former N.C. State Utilities Commissioner it would have been a conflict of interest (as well as setting off an insider trading investigation by federal authorities) for me to hold/buy/sell any stock (Duke, CP&L, PSCo, or AT&T) while my dad was on the commission!
    Any way, I especially dislike the notion of "the customers and company sharing the cost of clean-up" he keeps spewing - the Utilities Commission has ALREADY factored in PROPER waste storage & maintenance of facilities into the customers rates for decades upon decades! The customers gained NOTHING when Duke cut corners to save $$$ - Only the stock holders and upper echelon execs (whose pay is partly stocks and definitely profit based) benefited from not doing the job right!

  • Forthe Newssite Aug 25, 2014
    user avatar

    View quoted thread

    don't think for one minute that someone in his family doesn't own his Duke stock.....

    he is SUCH a joke, I can't wait until he's moved out