Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

8:51 a.m. • 5-19-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Today: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 78° F
  • Mon: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 76° F
  • Tue: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 81° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image
@NCCapitol
graduation
print friendly

McCrory: Fund higher education based on results

Published: 2013-01-29 09:50:00
Updated: 2013-01-29 18:54:56

Gov. Pat McCrory told a national radio audience Tuesday that state community colleges and universities should be funded based on how well they do at placing their students in the job market.

"Right now, we pay based upon how many students you have, not on the results of how many jobs you're getting people into," McCrory said. "I'm looking at legislation right now – in fact, I just instructed my staff yesterday to go ahead and develop legislation – which would change the basic formula in how education money is given out to our universities and our community colleges. It's not based on butts in seats but on how many of those butts can get jobs."

Speaking on Bill Bennett's "Morning in America" show, McCrory touched on themes similar to those he talked about during the campaign. 

"I'm a big vocational training advocate," McCrory told Bennett. "I think some of the educational elite have taken over education, where we're offering courses that have no chance of getting people jobs."

University of North Carolina President Tom Ross said the 16-campus system is already transitioning its funding formula to include measures related to student achievement and academic and operational efficiencies. Still, he expressed reservations about gauging university success solely on the employment rate of students and graduates.

"The university’s value to North Carolina should not be measured by jobs filled alone. Our three-part mission of teaching, research and public service requires that we prepare students with the talent and abilities to succeed in the workforce, because talent will be the key to economic growth," Ross said in a statement. "Higher education plays a key role in ensuring a higher quality of life for all North Carolinians."

North Carolina Community College System officials need to learn more about McCrory's stance before commenting on it, spokeswoman Megan Hoenk said.

Legislative leaders also weren't quick to embrace McCrory's comments, but House Speaker Thom Tillis told reporters that it sounds like suggestions developed by a strategic planning committee of the UNC Board of Governors.

"What it really means is making sure that what we're teaching our students in community college and university systems are aligned with the market demands,"  said Tillis, R-Mecklenburg.

The General Assembly should not micromanage how the university system does its business but measure the outcomes for students, he said.

"One of the most frustrating things that we have as legislators is hearing the businesses out there saying we simply do not have qualified people to fill these jobs," he said. "We've got a 9 percent-plus unemployment rate, and we have hundreds, maybe thousands, of jobs that can't be filled because the right skill sets are not available."

Rep. Linda Johnson, R-Cabarrus, co-chairwoman of the House Education Committee, said the problem McCrory outlined is a national issue of matching graduate skills to business needs.

"That’s the sign that tells us we need to change what we’re doing," Johnson said. "I’m not thinking the degrees would change, but the content of the courses."

Because more than half of the General Assembly is serving in their first or second term, she said, members will need to learn about the state of education and talk among themselves before deciding on a course of action. 

"We have to have sort of a conversation to find out where they are coming from," she said.

Sen. Josh Stein, D-Wake, a member of the Senate Higher Education Committee, said university campuses and community colleges should be evaluated on a range of criteria, including the employment rate of graduates.

"Universities are much more than job factories; they’re also about broadening minds," Stein said. "That doesn’t mean we can’t get more out of our universities and having them be stronger engines of economic growth."

On the radio with Bennett, McCrory talked about the dual gaps of North Carolina high unemployment rate and employers who can't find jobs as well.

"To me, that means we have a major disconnect between the education establishment and commerce," McCrory said. "So, I'm going to adjust my education curriculum to what business and commerce needs to get our kids jobs as opposed to moving back in with their parents after they graduate."

Elisya Mason, a senior marketing major at North Carolina State University, said a range of courses prepare students for life outside the university.

"I feel pretty confident I’ll be able to find a job after I graduate," Mason said. "I think there is a place, especially in the university, for those types of classes."

In response to a dig that Bennett took at gender studies courses, McCrory expanded on the theme of connecting classes offered to potential employment.

"You're right," McCrory said. "That's a subsidized course, and frankly, if you want to take gender studies, that's fine. Go to a private school and take it, but I don't want to subsidize that if that's not going to get someone a job ... It's the tech jobs that we need right now."

The governor tied his train of thought into the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill athletics department scandal.

"It's even hit our athletic department at Carolina – our great basketball program," McCrory said. "They took Swahili on a night study course where they didn't have to do any work, and they got B-pluses. What are we teaching these courses for if they're not going to help get a job?" 

McCrory said he believes in liberal arts education.

"I got one. I think there are two reasons for education. One is, as my Dad used to say, to exercise the brain, but the second is to get a skill."

Read More Posts from this Blog

364 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

This story is closed for comments. Comments on WRAL.com news stories are accepted and moderated between the hours of 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. Monday through Friday.


page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

McCrory was some kind of executive flunky at Duke Energy. It's not a real company. It's a regulated monopoly. So he's not the second coming of Steve Jobs, Bill Gates....

We need plumbers, electricians, skilled carpenters, heating and air conditioning technicians, horticulturalists, dairy farmers, poultry farmers, etc. (more than I can reiterate)

We DO NOT NEED artists, communications EXPERTS, basket weavers and community organizers, etc. (more than I can reiterate)

Not a theory. I have 2 children with useful degrees and 2 with useless degrees. The 2 with useless degrees are back in the training education process as their career tracking did not live up to their university "career counselors" promises.

If you get a job at McDonald's serving fries does that count?

"Old McRoary sure is full of it. Strange how none of his hogwash was put on the table prior to the election." That's because you were listening to Pat McCrory and not the REAL governor, Art Pope.

Public funding of education based on results!!!... THE HORROR! Actually expecting results... the nerve of this guy.... doesn't he know if taxpayer money is not achieving set goals/standards, we need to just throw MORE taxpayer money at the problem until it goes away, or we lower the standard... or both.

Personally... I like where McCrory is going with this idea.... and eliminating the sales tax.... a fair taxation BONUS! Now if we can get school vouchers.... I cant afford to pay for two schools at one time. (Public and private)

BTW, graduates, your professors are in the comfy, cozy, tenured land of funded retirement.

Old McRoary sure is full of it. Strange how none of his hogwash was put on the table prior to the election.

NC provides public funding to all private colleges based in NC based on enrollments of NC residents, from Duke on down.

This is just an excuse to remove funding from education. Corporations will loooove this. More excuses to hire fewer people and pay those they do employ less. This is one of the greediest schemes yet.

It is sad how anti-intellectual the GOP has become. It used to be some our best brains were also registered republicans, but that was a long time ago it seems. Meanwhile, he best be careful about this idea--I suspect he may be surprised at which schools have the most unemployed grads. Myword .......You talk as if being "intellectual", is a good thing, as Jerry Clower used to say, "you can be educated BEYOND your intelligence"!

Government gun control - BAD! Government education control - GOOD! The hypocrisy and ignorance that has taken over the REPUBLICAN party in the 21st century is absolutely staggering.

It is sad how anti-intellectual the GOP has become. It used to be some our best brains were also registered republicans, but that was a long time ago it seems. Meanwhile, he best be careful about this idea--I suspect he may be surprised at which schools have the most unemployed grads.

""Private school, if parents want to foot the bill for that, it's their choice and not taken from taxpayers" - Nancy

Nancy, folks who send their kids to private schools are STILL TAXPAYERS! We just get doubly hit - first we pay for YOUR school, then we pay for ours!"

You don't follow the full post well, I was referring to Duke University as the prior poster had. You don't pay for students to attend Duke. We're not talking public K-12 here, try to read more thoroughly.

Is the unemployment rate in NC higher or lower for persons with college degrees?

It is amazing that the counties with the lowest unemployment rates are the ones with the highest percentage of college and advanced degrees.

Already been studied. There is no viable methodology. https://edsurveys.rti.org/IPEDS_TRP/documents/TRP34__SummaryPackage_suggestions_final.pdf

McCrory wants voter registration. How is that going to bring in jobs? Republicans do not care about public education because most Republicans have money and can go to any school anywhere.

"Critical thinking is code for a Socialist or Communist professor brainwashing a student to think that Socialism, Communism, or Marxism is the only way to think and that Capitalism is bad. -ConservativeVoter

I REALLY hope this was a joke but fear otherwise - scary.

AliceBToklas"

You only need look at how he signs his comments to know he is serious, which is REALLY scary.

conservative voter-"Then why do so many people come to the United States from countries who have socialist medical systems like Canada and the United Kingdom to be treated by American doctors in American Hospitals."

Your proof? Canada on the other hand has to have national health ID cards as so many Americans were crossing the border. Other than a few wealthy individuals getting specialized care here in the U.S., what you claim isn't true. Canadians and Brits like their systems and would never consider going to our much more expensive system. And guess what? They get equal or better overall outcomes! I can prove what I say, can you?

Can we just call gender studies "Women's Studies"? I mean, its not like you go to college and take a "Men's Studies" course. We just call that history.

Critical thinking is code for a Socialist or Communist professor brainwashing a student to think that Socialism, Communism, or Marxism is the only way to think and that Capitalism is bad. -ConservativeVoter

I REALLY hope this was a joke but fear otherwise - scary.

"Curious to know how McCrory got from liberal arts at Catawba to executive at Duke Energy."

Governor Pat (Pope) is contradicting himself in this interview, as he has a liberal arts degree himself. Wonder why it worked for him but now will not work for others? Perhaps he needs to look up the word 'liberal' in the dictionary and all its meanings and not listen to whoever is chattering in his ear about the 'elite liberals' in the university system, whoever they may be. He is an embarrassment to our great state.

This is what we told you all would happen - the hypocritical little REPUBLICANS want to use BIG GOVERNMENT to force their social engineering on the good people of North Carolina. BIG GOVERNMENT is going to dictate what you study in school. If the hypocritical rich REPUBLICANS don't like it, too bad. You should have been smart enough to have been born rich like they think they are.

FYI.. Ronald Reagan (those republicans) cleaned house on the lousy 'private schools' by simply cutting off thier access to tuition assistance when their default rate went so high. It was not the republicans that reversed that, so now we have an armada of lousy 'private schools' ripping off the tax payers and the students for non-existant educations,and putting the money in rich folks pockets (can you say slick willy).

The Republicans are cluless when it comes to education

Soooo how come they are successful and wealthy if they are clueless, or we can keep the regressive dem approach and just throw money at a failing system, talk about clueless.

Better idea, close two or three of the UNC system campuses, reduce the number of students in 'no real purpose' degree programs at the remaining schools (this will require some subjective decisions). Put 50% of the money saved into debt payments and/or tax reduction. Put the other 50% into high schools. You can recieve a better education in high school already (if you apply yourself) than college some (many?) grads have after partying four years in a liberal arts program.

Apparently our new governor does not understand the difference between a University and a Technical College

I saw nothing in the column that would make me think that. Tech schools do have classes they lead to no jobs, and a lot that do. What Mccrory is doing is going on ALL over the country , nothing new about this.

wlo0638 Management training program at Duke Energy after Catawba.From digging ditches and climbing poles, to office work. Wow imagine hard work making you a success, tough swallow I know.

"So only those with money get certain types of education. Others have to settle for what they can afford."

So yes.

"Isn't government dictating what courses should be offered the very thing that cons should be up in arms about? Let the free market dictate what courses a college offers?" Unbroken

You're confusing "we will only rob the taxpayers for degrees that lead to jobs" with "govt dictating what courses will be offered." If Susie wants to be a community organizer, let her pay for her own Community Justice PhD.

The Republicans are cluless when it comes to education.

I feel this formula is archaic and rather ignorant. If a person loves history, is great at it, and wishes to teach it...so be it. Simply because they won't find a job right out of college means nothing. You cannot put job finding on the colleges and universities backs, that is unfair. It is North Carolina State Government's job to produce jobs for its graduates. Time to get to work, Pat, and our legislature, of course...instead of dumping the finding of available jobs on someone else. It is state government who is responsible for producing jobs, not colleges and universities. Grow up!

"Can one assume that getting rid of lousy "schools" like Phoenix University are high on the good governor's list? I wouldn't bet on iti anytime soon." - humm61

How could he do this exactly?

Can one assume that getting rid of lousy "schools" like Phoenix University are high on the good governor's list? I wouldn't bet on iti anytime soon.

Curious to know how McCrory got from liberal arts at Catawba to executive at Duke Energy.

Apparently our new governor does not understand the difference between a University and a Technical College. These republicans are quickly selling out state out to business and their own special interests.

This comment is really ignorant. Have you done any research lately on brain development and the malleability of neural pathways? I am sorry to say that, if you are correct, things are hopeless for you. This comment screams unintelligent.

"I love the arcane myth that people can be taught to THINK. They can not be taught to THINK. They either do or they do not. This skill also has little to do with KNOWLEDGE. People can cram all sorts of information into their little brain pans, but still have no earthly idea how to APPLY it to anything. Another myth is that you can teach people to be organized. YOU can not. You can teach people that are already organized how to improve that skill, but disorganized folks, just tend to exist in that state for their entire lives."

McCrory graduated with a liberal arts degree from Catawba College. Enough said....

""It is funny how liberals think the way to "think critically" is by paying a liberal college professor several thousand dollars."

The above post is an example of the shortcomings of a limited education."

Actually it is the shortcoming of extended education that makes people believe someone can be taught to THINK. It is one of those educational MYTHS that the system claims it can accomplish.

I have a BA degree in history. I now work in my company's communications department, handling things such as regular commiques to our customers as well as developing the marketing and technical documentation for our products.

It took me several years of starting off at entry-level positions. I've been a temp, a call center rep, and did my share of development materials for cookie-cutter computer training companies.

I didn't walk out of college and move into a position that pays well above the median income in North Carolina. It took me years & years of working and proving my abilities, which I credit to large part for having an arts degree.

I've owned a home for over 10 years, I pay my taxes, and I have no qualms to support students who have degrees that teach them how to think. It is an important skill to have.

"If you are looking for a narrowly focused individual, you may look to the tech schools and the associate degrees rather than degrade a bachelor's degree. -quilting bee"

It is amusing that people think a BA or a BS is valuable. It is no longer of much value. that is unfortunate, but it is the truth. Once you have millions upon millions upon millions of people with a BA or BS, they just become one more of the herd. I know many people will get irate over my comment, but it is the reality of the real world. Plus each and every year another new crop of thousands obtain their BA or BS. It is becoming common place for people to have two or more masters degrees, and Doctoral degrees are much more numerous. Our Education establish needs to be seriously changed. It should not take 14 years to get from K5 to a bachelors. But it is not in the interest of the SYSTEM to provide education more efficiently and effectively.

GO Gov Pat, Good Job!

"The colleges and public schools don't fail anybody. Everybody receives a passing grade and those that can't perform get socially promoted. They do this to keep from destroying the failing students self esteem"

And this is a problem in K-12 that no one will address. It's a problem that is starting children on the path of failure.

I made an "A"s in English and philosophy at Wake Forest. Been out a long time. My paycheck last week was $175. Working part time but want full time.

I love the arcane myth that people can be taught to THINK. They can not be taught to THINK. They either do or they do not. This skill also has little to do with KNOWLEDGE. People can cram all sorts of information into their little brain pans, but still have no earthly idea how to APPLY it to anything. Another myth is that you can teach people to be organized. YOU can not. You can teach people that are already organized how to improve that skill, but disorganized folks, just tend to exist in that state for their entire lives.

I'm not sure college is worth it unless you major in business or have solid professional school plans.

I have a B.A. f/ Wake Forest, been out 25 yrs. Did business classes at night. I've had interviews for good jobs, bank mgmt training program, trust department, Enterprise RentACar, others., but no offers. Spent lots of time applying. Never made more than $25k/yr.

I completely agree that we need more focus on jobs that do not require a 4 yr degree. We need mechanics, plumbers, heat/ac repair jobs. These jobs are necessary and important and not everyone can do them. Plus not everyone wants to go or can go to a 4 yr college. That being said, don't tell me to take Gender Studies at a private school because it's not going to get me a job. FYI, gender studies can help w/ careers in advertising, design, psychiatry, counseling, and even the tech industry. Focus on adding voc courses (we had shop & cosmotology in my HS)and expanding opportunities for everyone, but not by restricting what the colleges offer based on the name of the course.

"It is funny how liberals think the way to "think critically" is by paying a liberal college professor several thousand dollars."

The above post is an example of the shortcomings of a limited education.

It took 1100 years but we have finally done away with the Academy. Congratulations NC!

The university I attended for my Bachelor's did NOT pass everyone. In fact, I knew a lot of people who attended colleges up north who failed classes. You do have to perform in college to earn a degree. If the south doesn't hold up that expectation, then that's a cultural issue that needs fixed. Other parts of the country do fail students at any level if they do not perform. Basing funding on job placement makes no sense. First, the funding is needed to run the university. The university's costs are based on the number of students who use university resources. They will not be able to provide the necessary resources or pay their own bills if funding is based on graduates finding jobs. The universities cannot motivate graduates to get jobs so they can get funding. That is extremely unreasonable to make colleges rely on someone else's tenacity and work ethic.

With college loans exceeding credit card debt;

with hugh government expenditures on eduction;

with national global competitiveness dependent on proper eduction;

there should be accountability by objective measures with funding consequences,

so we get the best outcomes for our investment in education with which our country is literally gambling our future economic health.

I'd hope to see bipartisan effort on higher education especially.

How on earth did Obamacare get dragged into a story about education funding?

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Political Video Picks

 
  • Dozens of proposals failed to clear the House or Senate before the General Assembly's self-imposed "crossover" deadline this week for…

  • The scandal within the Internal Revenue Service was front and center Friday on Capitol Hill, as a committee heard testimony from…

  • The House and Ways Committee holds a hearing on the Internal Revenue Service's practice of targeting conservative political groups.…

  • The state House has released its own version of a tax reform bill that lower income and sales tax rates, but makes fewer sweeping…

  • The House approved several bills before the "crossover" deadline, including measures on abortion and social media privacy.

  • President Obama says he'll hold a Rose Garden news conference Thursday to answer questions about the scandal enveloping the Internal…