Log in to WRAL.com with one click using your favorite social network:
OR
Log in using your WRAL.com account:



Wrong email/password combination.

Forgot password?

Register with WRAL.com using your favorite social network:
OR
Register for a WRAL.com account using our web form.

6:52 p.m. • 6-19-13

Weather Forecast for Raleigh

  • Thu: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 85° F
  • Fri: Partly Cloudy.
    • Hi: 85° F
  • Sat: Thunderstorm.
    • Hi: 85° F

Other Locations

> 7 Day Forecast

Doppler Image
@NCCapitol
graduation
print friendly

McCrory: Fund higher education based on results

Published: 2013-01-29 09:50:00
Updated: 2013-01-29 18:54:56

Gov. Pat McCrory told a national radio audience Tuesday that state community colleges and universities should be funded based on how well they do at placing their students in the job market.

"Right now, we pay based upon how many students you have, not on the results of how many jobs you're getting people into," McCrory said. "I'm looking at legislation right now – in fact, I just instructed my staff yesterday to go ahead and develop legislation – which would change the basic formula in how education money is given out to our universities and our community colleges. It's not based on butts in seats but on how many of those butts can get jobs."

Speaking on Bill Bennett's "Morning in America" show, McCrory touched on themes similar to those he talked about during the campaign. 

"I'm a big vocational training advocate," McCrory told Bennett. "I think some of the educational elite have taken over education, where we're offering courses that have no chance of getting people jobs."

University of North Carolina President Tom Ross said the 16-campus system is already transitioning its funding formula to include measures related to student achievement and academic and operational efficiencies. Still, he expressed reservations about gauging university success solely on the employment rate of students and graduates.

"The university’s value to North Carolina should not be measured by jobs filled alone. Our three-part mission of teaching, research and public service requires that we prepare students with the talent and abilities to succeed in the workforce, because talent will be the key to economic growth," Ross said in a statement. "Higher education plays a key role in ensuring a higher quality of life for all North Carolinians."

North Carolina Community College System officials need to learn more about McCrory's stance before commenting on it, spokeswoman Megan Hoenk said.

Legislative leaders also weren't quick to embrace McCrory's comments, but House Speaker Thom Tillis told reporters that it sounds like suggestions developed by a strategic planning committee of the UNC Board of Governors.

"What it really means is making sure that what we're teaching our students in community college and university systems are aligned with the market demands,"  said Tillis, R-Mecklenburg.

The General Assembly should not micromanage how the university system does its business but measure the outcomes for students, he said.

"One of the most frustrating things that we have as legislators is hearing the businesses out there saying we simply do not have qualified people to fill these jobs," he said. "We've got a 9 percent-plus unemployment rate, and we have hundreds, maybe thousands, of jobs that can't be filled because the right skill sets are not available."

Rep. Linda Johnson, R-Cabarrus, co-chairwoman of the House Education Committee, said the problem McCrory outlined is a national issue of matching graduate skills to business needs.

"That’s the sign that tells us we need to change what we’re doing," Johnson said. "I’m not thinking the degrees would change, but the content of the courses."

Because more than half of the General Assembly is serving in their first or second term, she said, members will need to learn about the state of education and talk among themselves before deciding on a course of action. 

"We have to have sort of a conversation to find out where they are coming from," she said.

Sen. Josh Stein, D-Wake, a member of the Senate Higher Education Committee, said university campuses and community colleges should be evaluated on a range of criteria, including the employment rate of graduates.

"Universities are much more than job factories; they’re also about broadening minds," Stein said. "That doesn’t mean we can’t get more out of our universities and having them be stronger engines of economic growth."

On the radio with Bennett, McCrory talked about the dual gaps of North Carolina high unemployment rate and employers who can't find jobs as well.

"To me, that means we have a major disconnect between the education establishment and commerce," McCrory said. "So, I'm going to adjust my education curriculum to what business and commerce needs to get our kids jobs as opposed to moving back in with their parents after they graduate."

Elisya Mason, a senior marketing major at North Carolina State University, said a range of courses prepare students for life outside the university.

"I feel pretty confident I’ll be able to find a job after I graduate," Mason said. "I think there is a place, especially in the university, for those types of classes."

In response to a dig that Bennett took at gender studies courses, McCrory expanded on the theme of connecting classes offered to potential employment.

"You're right," McCrory said. "That's a subsidized course, and frankly, if you want to take gender studies, that's fine. Go to a private school and take it, but I don't want to subsidize that if that's not going to get someone a job ... It's the tech jobs that we need right now."

The governor tied his train of thought into the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill athletics department scandal.

"It's even hit our athletic department at Carolina – our great basketball program," McCrory said. "They took Swahili on a night study course where they didn't have to do any work, and they got B-pluses. What are we teaching these courses for if they're not going to help get a job?" 

McCrory said he believes in liberal arts education.

"I got one. I think there are two reasons for education. One is, as my Dad used to say, to exercise the brain, but the second is to get a skill."

Read More Posts from this Blog

364 Comments


WRAL.com welcomes your comments on this story. All comments are moderated prior to publication based on our posting guidelines. Please review them prior to posting and if your message is not approved.

This blog post is closed for comments.


page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

This is of course a load of hooey..other than some of the 2 year tech degrees or some of the 4 year degrees such as nursing you can't measure success by hiring. How would you force a grad to tell you what job they do or do not have..having said that, I would love for Art Pope to spend ALL of his time for the next 4 years trying to develop the metric for this results based evaluation plan.

"Goodbye to educational freedom of choice and a well rounded education"

Choice? When you choose a major you have to take certain classes and pick from accepted electives. There are very few choices and if you have look lately weight lifting, swimming really don't pertain to the Science major my son just had. Only added dollars to the cost of getting that degree. And before you jump on the fact swimming is important and can save your life bla, bla or being healthy is important bla bla. He was an athlete in college and could swim like a fish.

GREAT IDEA GOVERNOR MCCRORY!!

the end-game of all education, be it, high school, an undergraduate degree or an advanced degree is a job. At some point after your initial education has been completed, you have to get paid for what you have learned. As a teacher, I tell my students if you fail here at school, you will likely fail at life. I like the idea of measuring the success of an educational institution by seeing how well it's customers are placed and progressing in the life of work, but it shouldn't be the only measure of success.

What an idiotic concept. From an idiotic mind. So now McCroy is trying to dictate what fields of study we major in? Will he next issue an executive order banning the arts? Sheesh! One & done, people, one & done! Cut already too low unemployment benefits to folks who really hurting, then give your buddies...er, uh....cabinet cronies a hefty raise....bad enough.. but say it's so he can attract top talent? Who does he have to attract? They're already hired! Sheesh! The fleecing of NC....or a feeble attempt....hopefully, his motives are transparent enough that even the simplest voters can see through his thinly veiled devices. One & done, people, PLEASE.

lol is he serious? This is the dumbest thing yet...looks like it all goes hand in hand with those that have the money for expensive schools with big names (you know the privileged and wealthy). So yes the rich kids get richer because they come from money and they get the jobs. This idea just helps keep them all in the upper class. So a company will recruit from these colleges before looking at East Jesus University kids.

There are a lot of kids being passed to the next grade when they can't read, do any kind of math or anything else

======================================

I disagree. I see the EOC exams and others for my kids. I don't believe a kid is "passed" through the grades just to get rid of them anymore. Some may "get" through, but not on purpose because of the school system, at least in WCPSS. Just my opinion. Hope I'm correct.

Government gun control - BAD! Government education control - GOOD! The hypocrisy and ignorance that has taken over the REPUBLICAN party in the 21st century is absolutely staggering. geosol

==========================================

Why the comparison? From a quick glance, one issue is protected by the Bill of Rights and the other isn't. Although it is a moral obligation to educate, I didn't see it was a protected right. Could be wrong, or you could just be sideways.............AGAIN.

This should be done with K-12 too. There are a lot of kids being passed to the next grade when they can't read, do any kind of math or anything else. Then, somehow, they get into college where they are at a loss as to how to get through it.

Ugh. Just noticed I failed to include an apostrophe. That SHOULD read: "My anecdotal evidence trumps Governor Mcrory's!" My apologies for my failure to punctuate properly. (Note to self--proof-read!)

"...not attempting to punish higher education schools that don't control world economies." gopack

It's true the schools don't control the economy. But they're not much different from the banks that wrote loans for people they knew couldn't repay them. Some degrees will not lead to a job and that's fine, as long as everyone knows that going in. Some kids are not college material right now; some never will be, and it's not just a question of IQ. But the colleges admit them and take their money.

With 0 doing his best to shift individually-chosen debt to all taxpayers, ("we" must make college "affordable"...must not "disenfranchise" anyone) we do have the right to say how it's spent. Especially in this economy, when incurring debt makes about as much sense as having babies.

"As far as finding uneducated employees, there is a great supply. Master Obama has seen to that by opening the borders and putting out the welcome sign for illegals."

Actually, the past 4 years has seen the HIGHEST SECURITY AND BORDER ARRESTS in the last 20 YEARS but rightwing radio will never report the truth if it conflicts with their delusions.

Everyone I know who graduated with a degree in philosophy or the classics is employed. ALL of them are making over six figures. Every. single. person. The folks I know in the IT/engineering business? Not so much. Several of them are among the long-term unemployed. Sometimes specialized education bites one in the backside.

My anecdotal evidence trumps Governor McCrorys! (Actually, anecdotal evidence is no way to make a cogent argument... but, hey, why let logic get in the way?)

geosol.... why is there always so much hostility in your posts?

Maybe teachers should have to pass the same exams and tests they expect their students to pass.

The thought that community colleges that do SO much MORE than technical education (basic skills, GED, Adult High School, Continuing Education, etc.) should be judged and, worse yet, funded based on a single outcome measure shows how little this new administration understands the mission of community colleges in this state. It is pitiful that he has gone so far as to direct his staff to DRAFT LEGISLATION!!! with so little knowledge and/or input from the people who DO know and understand. Legislation for performance-based funding for community colleges is already on the books and it is a much better model than basing it on a single outcome largely out of the control of the community colleges -- job placement. And this is on top of the fact that there is no viable methodology for calculating job placement. This shooting from the hip without adequate knowledge does not bode well for our state.

"Where did you see that? Are you one of the "if I have to pay for it myself, I'm denied access" libs? Colleges can teach and "focus on" whatever they want. They just can't charge me for their decisions. It's called "accountability"" Morrigan You obviously didn't understand what I wrote. If McCrory forces universities to focus on the job placement of their graduates, rather than an overall education, how are universities supposed to look at students who know they are going or want to go directly into a graduate degree program rather than the workforce? As someone applying for grad programs, you need a different set of 'skills' to get into a grad program than to get into a job upon graduation.

It's a shame that our current governor is so woefully out of touch with the community college system's efforts to tie funding to performance on a much broader base than simply "but ts getting jobs." All he has to do is take look here: http://www.successnc.org/initiatives/performance-measures-funding?utm_source=SuccessNC+Newsletter+Issue+%233+Jan+2013&utm_campaign=SuccessNC+eNews&utm_medium=email

Government education is such a joke they even make fun of it on govt radio.

"English majors, where is the money Go ahead, make a demand English is a beautiful language Don't accept less than a hundred grand."

http://prairiehome.publicradio.org/programs/2013/01/19/scripts/english.shtml

They did this show at ASU.

I really don't think unemployment among UNC grads is a huge problem.

The issue that the governor should look at is getting more grads in math and science fields that NC companies have to fill with foreign workers due to a lack of qualified US workers.

There are some really disturbing comments here. The truth is, that regardless of the degree, college educated people have far and away the lowest unemployment rate. The people with only high school diplomas or with no high school diplomas are the ones struggling to find work at a much higher rate. That should be the focus and not attempting to punish higher education schools that don't control world economies.

"Yes, because corporations are always complaining about how hard it is to find uneducated employees." - xxxxxxxxxxxxx

No, they complain about finding qualified employees with a useful education. There are only so many jobs in private industry for 18th Century African Study majors....

As far as finding uneducated employees, there is a great supply. Master Obama has seen to that by opening the borders and putting out the welcome sign for illegals.

The problem when I worked at NC State was that all the students are from India, China, Japan, Korea and that area. There is NO REAL POPULATION of native students with enough brains to be engineers. This is America where we raise basketball players and iPhone buyers while we educate foreign students because they are here for an education not to party on daddies money.

"And we DON'T need the GOVERNMENT telling us what to study for a career, do we wingers?" - geosol

Even if they are paying for it? You can't have it both ways. You want government (taxpayers) to pay for your education, but don't want them to have any say in what type of eduction they are paying for.

You want to study Roman Poetry, Haiku or Swahili? Go to a private school and pay for it yourself! The taxpayers deserve to get some VALUE for their investment.

The well is not bottomless little leftist one....

Finally! A way to ignore all of the medical, scientific, historical, etc. research and work done at our public universities!

Thomas Jefferson would sure be proud of our Gov. Pat.

"It is amazing that the counties with the lowest unemployment rates are the ones with the highest percentage of college and advanced degrees."

Not really all that amazing - just common sense.

"Stop trying to limit higher eduction with your conservative ideals." - boachieee

But we still have to pay for it right? Shut up and send a check.

Amazing the edutocracy's arrogance and contempt for the working taxpayers of the state...

"This is just an excuse to remove funding from education. Corporations will loooove this."

Yes, because corporations are always complaining about how hard it is to find uneducated employees.

Well lets all be artists so we can live in Art communities provided by the city of Raleigh, get welfare from Obama and sing Kumbaya and be happy. Get a life folks, get an education so you can grow up to support the Democratic party and their constituents as they will need every TAX dollar they get their hands on to keep the entitlements going to the sorry that refuse to work.

"I will not pay for my children to go to college for a degree that's worthless towards their future regardless of any pleas of how happy it would make them. The world doesn't need many more starving artists."

How nice for them. The advice columnists have letters all the time from children whose parents force them into degrees that they don't want.

"I love the arcane myth that people can be taught to THINK. They can not be taught to THINK."

Of course not. All humans think. Your premise is faulty. However, you can teach people to think critically. People do it every day. And people have been doing it for a long time. Ever heard of the "Socratic method"?

We saw how massive tax cuts and deregulation worked from 2001-2008. It gave us a Depression that keeps on giving!

We'll see how things look when the state is completely bankrupt after eliminating income tax. How much groceries and haircuts will it take to replace tax on EVEN ONE 6 figure income?

We'll also see how all the universities and colleges take to being funded based on placement.

These ideas sound more like they're from grade schoolers which is about the speed for McCrory and the rightwing billionaires who bought the state!

"There aren't enough students graduating in engineering fields to fill positions in the area. NC companies are having to hire out of state graduates."

So what? What's so noble about hiring in-state grads? Shouldn't employers simply be looking for the best qualified candidates? And how many of the in-state grads are looking elsewhere for jobs? That's how it works - people in this country move around a lot for any number of reasons.

Omg what? You mean we finally have a politician that won't just blindly throw money to teachers?

Holy cow we have a winner :)

"There aren't enough students graduating in engineering fields to fill positions in the area. NC companies are having to hire out of state graduates."

The problem is, how can you force some one to be an engineer if they don't want to be an engineer. This isn't China.

I guess Art Pope and the Koch Bros gave McCrory permission to say that. Must be in the scheme to destroy North Carolina.- jack

you cant destroy whats already broken--- now folks can see what the resutls are when 1 political party runs the state for 120 yrs...

"Personally... I like where McCrory is going with this idea.... and eliminating the sales tax.... a fair taxation BONUS!"

I thought he wanted to eliminate the income tax and increase sales taxes one_nc_citizen

Correct..... I meant income tax.

whatelseisnew: "myth that people can be taught to THINK. They can not be taught to THINK. They either do or they do not."

People CAN be taught to think, it happens every day. It's the whole PURPOSE of an education. The fact that you don't recognize that shows clearly that it's just right-wing Goobers and Gomers who can't be taught to think. People this clueless really shouldn't have any voice in public policy. Being too brain-dead to understand reality does NOT make your position accurate--you're just too hopeless to understand how hopeless you are.

I guess Art Pope and the Koch Bros gave McCrory permission to say that. Must be in the scheme to destroy North Carolina.

I was a widget maker,, did live in a mobile home and drank well water,, Whats your point,, Graduated from 3 Community Colleges, 3 different fields Electronics , Machinists and mgmt, military. I made things, Fixed things,,and never had to look a job,, Did not mind working for over 50 years, Now send me my check

North Carolina Home:

Who has the higher unemployment rate in North Carolina, people with college and university degrees or people without?

Why are people with college and university degrees much more likely to NOT be on government assistance, to pay more taxes, to employ more people, than those without?

Why are the counties with the highest ratio of people with college and university degrees to those without, the same counties with the lowest unemployment rates?

Why are the counties with the fewest college and university degrees the some of the same counties with the highest unemployment rates?

Which members of Gov. McCrory's cabinet do not have college or university degrees?

It boggles the mind.

I was a women studies major class of 2011 and I am happy to say that I have a great job... and no I don't work at McDonalds. I work with UNC Women's Hospital. I also have many friends who were not liberal arts majors who don't have jobs so we shouldn't be so quick to generalize. I transferred to UNC my junior year from a private school because I was tired of being told what to think. UNC has provided me with an excellent liberal arts education, and to take these classes away because Pat doesn't approve is simply tragic. Stop trying to limit higher eduction with your conservative ideals.

"Personally... I like where McCrory is going with this idea.... and eliminating the sales tax.... a fair taxation BONUS!"

I thought he wanted to eliminate the income tax and increase sales taxes

Makes you wonder about all the diplomats, politicians, journalists, university chancellors, etc. that started out with an undergraduate degree in liberal arts. How did they do it? Simple, they got graduate degrees which made them employable. Today, and undergraduate degree is what a high school degree was forty years ago. Many employers will not consider hiring anyone with a bachelors degree for a professional position. You have to have either a Masters or Doctorate...or be satisified with a low paying job and plan to continue your education. That's the real world.

I guess "Do want fries with that?" will become the new graduation test phrase for everyone at all state colleges and universities. Competition for fast food management positions should become fierce.

There aren't enough students graduating in engineering fields to fill positions in the area. NC companies are having to hire out of state graduates.

As a product of 16 years of Catholic schools, I can attest to the fact that problem children were simply kicked out. Period. I became a teacher and looked back in horror at a great deal of abuse,physical and psychological, in those schools that I attended. In Massachusetts Catholic Schools do not take the required state tests, which are the most rogorous in the nation. They do not service special education students, but send them out for an hour a day to local public schools...at taxpayers' expense (including transportation.) So please,don't tell me that Catholic schools do a better job. Let public schools play by the same rules, and they would run rings around religious schools.

"Private schools operated by the Catholics not only score better, but cost less than public ones. "

That's comparing apples and oranges. Our Catholic friends can pick and choose who they accept into their schools, bypassing the more costly and problematic "problem children". Many private schools, enjoy the same higher scores for the same reasons.

Liberal arts and sociology degrees failing in the job market is not a new problem. This is the result of a few decades of high school counselors and college admission officers telling students that it's important to get a degree, any degree and they will find a place in the job market. Unfortunately once colleges have to encourage engineering, medical and science degrees the graduation rate will be dismal. Their are just too many students out there claiming math is "not their thing" so they shoot for the easiest piece of paper a college will reward them, no matter how useless.

I will not pay for my children to go to college for a degree that's worthless towards their future regardless of any pleas of how happy it would make them. The world doesn't need many more starving artists.

And we DON'T need the GOVERNMENT telling us what to study for a career, do we wingers?

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9
<prev    next>
sort order: oldest first | newest first

Political Video Picks

 
  • North Carolina first lady Ann McCrory urged lawmakers Wednesday to take action on a bill that would establish basic standards of care…

  • After laying out his plans to reform Medicaid, transportation funding and job-recruitment efforts, Gov. Pat McCrory turned his…

  • Who should pay to clean Jordan Lake?

  • The House takes up legislation that would allow the speed limit on some N.C. highways to be raised to 75 mph.

  • The Senate Health Committee is expected to take up an as-yet unannounced proposed committee substitute for a state symbols bill.

  • The Senate Education Committee discusses a bill that would give students with disabilities publicly-funded scholarships to attend…